The Elliott Wave debate

[lukeaye]

wow

great charts bud

are you actually trading any ?

absolutley, pdn and yellow i eneted last week, got that nice little spike.

and seek im waiting for a pullback or some support before i enter.

 

[lukeaye]

T/H
Many moons ago you posted a scatter chart showing a days trading.From that it clearly showed that the 4 or so big winners gave you an edge over the lots of small losses and smaller wins. Not a critisism but an observation.
Is this true in the long run with your trading?

Thanks Lukaye--compelling stuff. But your charts are rubbish.

M/W yes understand.

Just noticed this re volume you may comment on.(Using GBG as an example seen on most stocks.)

thanks tech, i am at work and have limited software, why are you going out of your way to attack me? i dont understand?

anyway i dont feel like sharing anymore with you because i dont particulary like you.

 

[nunthewiser]

absolutley, pdn and yellow i eneted last week, got that nice little spike.

and seek im waiting for a pullback or some support before i enter.

can you show this via broker statements? or are you yet another hindsight trading expert we see so much off ..........

no offense intended

just asking ,as a lot of stuff we see in these threads are great in hindsight but not many actually call it in real time.

i do like how all these charts show that EW is a definate goer

 

[lukeaye]

no offence taken

These are real time nun, these are as recent as the close on friday

so i dont see why i should have to prove statements, because the movement hasnt happened yet? there is no hindsight involved, wait to see what unfolds, pdn has done nothing yet? neither has seek, yellow has just started but im not showing things that have already happened.

 

[tech/a]

thanks tech, i am at work and have limited software, why are you going out of your way to attack me? i dont understand?

anyway i dont feel like sharing anymore with you

I'm questioning you and your "theories"
I guess you'd prefer to have heads nodding in approval.

You seem to be taking this personally?
Your not female are you?
Was I married to you once?

i dont particularly like you

This is a common affliction. Something some people never get over.
Statements are normally asked for to weed out the "Idiot gee I'm good factor" If Statements are produced then generally the one who asks for proof and is proven flicks $500 to Joe Blow in appreciation of such a good forum. If of course as you have---deny to do so then you fit in the "Idiot gee I'm good category"

(More popularity votes!!)

Back to work then.

 

[lukeaye]

I'm questioning you and your "theories"
I guess youd prefer to have heads nodding in approval.

You seem to be taking this personally?
Your not female are you?
Was I married to you once?



This is a common affliction. Something some people never get over.
Back to work then.

well wait to see what happens in comming weeks tech, then you will put it in between your legs? like i hear your so good at doing, back to your weekend job. enough breath wasted on you

 

[nunthewiser]

absolutley, pdn and yellow i eneted last week, got that nice little spike.

.

no offence taken

but i dont see why i should have to prove statements, because the movement hasnt happened yet? there is no hindsight involved, .

ok then

i also entered DYL at its lowest ......... i sold at its highest ....... i dont know how to post charts and add wave counts as i am technically challenged

but thats ok we are a trusting bunch here and if i say i bought low and sold high , i should be believed because this is the internet

thankyou for your time

 

[Trembling Hand]

T/H
Many moons ago you posted a scatter chart showing a days trading.From that it clearly showed that the 4 or so big winners gave you an edge over the lots of small losses and smaller wins. Not a critisism but an observation.
Is this true in the long run with your trading?

Yes. Isn't it true of all profitable trading?

The big wins make the diff between BE or nice profit.... most days.

 

[nunthewiser]

I LIKE TECH/A

he may annoy the sheet outta me at times but i have no doubts on his sincerity

however there are others here that do not annoy me but BOY do i have some major doubts on there sincerity

wow thats deep man

 

[lukeaye]

ok then

i also entered DYL at its lowest ......... i sold at its highest ....... i dont know how to post charts and add wave counts as i am technically challenged

but thats ok we are a trusting bunch here and if i say i bought low and sold high , i should be believed because this is the internet

thankyou for your time

i didnt say that? i just said im entered into a position pdn, that isnt in profit yet, im waiting in real time for it to unfold? there is no hindsight, i do not understand what you mean?

 

[nunthewiser]

Statements are normally asked for to weed out the "Idiot gee I'm good factor" If Statements are produced then generally the one who asks for proof and is proven flicks $500 to Joe Blow
(More popularity votes!!)

.

NO thats your thang tech

i personally just like to ask politely and see what happens

 

[tech/a]

Yes. Isn't it true of all profitable trading?

The big wins make the diff between BE or nice profit.... most days.

In some yes.

You could still be trading 50 trades a day with a 1.2 expectancy and do very well.

Or of course as I'm sure happens with you from time to time a combination of both through the week.

 

[nunthewiser]

absolutley, pdn and yellow i eneted last week, got that nice little spike.

.

ok i must have misread that bit about you catching the DYL spike

ok my bad

as you were

 

[lukeaye]

ok i must have misread that bit about you catching the DYL spike

ok my bad

as you were

08SEP09 10:34 4HWXAP CFD Paladin Energy Ltd A$ +5,000 4.6900 4.7500 1,300.00 300.00
Controlled risk stop 4.4300
Limit 5.6900
A$ Total 1,555.40 310.00

is that what you need or should i gif it?

 

[tech/a]

NO thats your thang tech

i personally just like to ask politely and see what happens

Oh sorry.Thought it was universally adopted.Weeds out the idiots.

Whats "politely" mean?
The word is foreign.

 

[nunthewiser]

Oh sorry.Thought it was universally adopted.Weeds out the idiots.

Whats "politely" mean?
The word is foreign.

and some people may take offense to your manner in asking ,and post statements in other threads to verify there "idiot "factor elswhere ....

"politely" is in the websters edition of "bogan speak for the internet "

 

[tech/a]

and some people may take offense to your manner in asking ,and post statements in other threads to verify there "idiot "factor elswhere ....

"politely" is in the websters edition of "bogan speak for the internet "

Thanks.
Yes Happy to offend and happy to pay the $500 when wwwrrrrong.--as you know.

 

[lukeaye]

Well im not making outlandish claims, im just trying to show elliot wave trades, they havent finished yet, and my point was simply to show that the happen, not to gloat, and boast about past wins, if you guyz dont want to look at it then thats your business, but i have simply laid it out for you. see what happens is all i say. there is every possibilty that they wont work, and i accept that.

 

[nunthewiser]

Well im not making outlandish claims, im just trying to show elliot wave trades, they havent finished yet, and my point was simply to show that the happen, not to gloat, and boast about past wins, if you guyz dont want to look at it then thats your business, but i have simply laid it out for you. see what happens is all i say. there is every possibilty that they wont work, and i accept that.

nah dont get me wrong

happy actually more than happy . overjoyed that people put there necks out and give there take on future directions/expected outcomes on any stock/indicies .... its intresting and educational to see other ppls thoughts on where they think we heading .....

you posted that you caught the DYL spike "yellow " i think you called it . and that was my reasoning for asking for a bit of proof not just a chart .....

glad that you are posting your thoughts on future trades and entrys right or wrong

what does sheet me is when ppl add the lines and squiggles AFTER the fact to prove a hindsight entry that only gets mentioned AFTER it goes up ......

 

[tech/a]

Luke

im just trying to show elliot wave trades

My apologies.
Im confused.

I would never trade, purely on an elliot wave theory, it is in my opinion, not a strategy with a high probabilty of sucess, but when used with other techniques can become very powerful.

Clearly then you have taken these trades with "other techniques" could you explain these in addition to your labelled charts?