- Joined
- 23 April 2008
- Posts
- 1,838
- Reactions
- 599
The game was over after 7 minutes due to the send off. If I was a paying spectator, I would want my money back. Artie Beetson and Tommy Raudonikis would be rolling in their graves.
Rugby League
- Thread starter rcw1
- Start date
So 18 all as the Dolphins and the Storm go to the sheds at half time. Good game of footy, thus far.
rcw1 notes big Johnny Singleton helping the bluebags to get back into the NRL competition over in WA. Looks to rcw will be some competition with Norths attempting to do the same thing. First time have read something in the media about Singleton back in the frame to get Newtown over the line. Will take some talking and of course some big amounts of coin, something which Singleton has got allot of and more than likely can get hold of. Interesting days ahead.
Kind regards
rcw1
rcw1 notes big Johnny Singleton helping the bluebags to get back into the NRL competition over in WA. Looks to rcw will be some competition with Norths attempting to do the same thing. First time have read something in the media about Singleton back in the frame to get Newtown over the line. Will take some talking and of course some big amounts of coin, something which Singleton has got allot of and more than likely can get hold of. Interesting days ahead.
Kind regards
rcw1
I did tip Melbourne so all good but a really good game, it could have been a draw as they both worked so hard at it
SoO2 preview:
rcw1 prediction
Maroons by 10
The belief by the Queensland team will be such that the Blues will flounder and panic under overwhelming defensive pressure placed upon them by the Maroons and their senior players will make the right decisions at the right time when under the blow torch. This will intimately be the difference over the full 80 minutes.
Predict it to be a extremely tough gig in the middle. Nothing different, suppose, but Haas has admitted he has not owned SoO yet. True that. Redemption for the Blues forwards or otherwise?? So, very much looking forward to the forward clash. What has not been said, or published to rcw1 knowledge, is the Queensland bench... Capewell and Kaufusi ... these two are defensive warriors and run good lines and they were picked to do one thing... bash and barge... and harass the Blues kickers and their forward pack, for mine.
Now then
The expert predictions!!!!!!!
PHIL ROTHFIELD
NSW by 4
A much stronger attacking force with Latrell Mitchell and Dylan Edwards in the side. However, the Blues need midfield dominance and it’s time for Payne Haas to step up on the Origin stage.
PETER BADEL
NSW by 6
The Blues have picked a much better side and will be more desperate with their series on the line. Latrell Mitchell loves the big stage. Bring on a Suncorp decider.
DEAN RITCHIE
NSW by 10
New-look side with plenty of strike. Mitchell Moses’ long kicking game and Latrell Mitchell’s brilliance will be the difference.
BRENT READ
Queensland by 2
The Blues have picked a better team but the return of Reece Walsh will supercharge the Maroons to a series win. Walsh only played seven minutes in Origin I after being KO’d and he will be champing at the bit in Melbourne.
ROBERT CRADDOCK
Queensland by 2
It’s the 30th anniversary of Mark Coyne’s “miracle’’ try and don’t be surprised if this match is decided by a similar work of art.
rcw1 prediction
Maroons by 10
The belief by the Queensland team will be such that the Blues will flounder and panic under overwhelming defensive pressure placed upon them by the Maroons and their senior players will make the right decisions at the right time when under the blow torch. This will intimately be the difference over the full 80 minutes.
Predict it to be a extremely tough gig in the middle. Nothing different, suppose, but Haas has admitted he has not owned SoO yet. True that. Redemption for the Blues forwards or otherwise?? So, very much looking forward to the forward clash. What has not been said, or published to rcw1 knowledge, is the Queensland bench... Capewell and Kaufusi ... these two are defensive warriors and run good lines and they were picked to do one thing... bash and barge... and harass the Blues kickers and their forward pack, for mine.
Now then
The expert predictions!!!!!!!
PHIL ROTHFIELD
NSW by 4
A much stronger attacking force with Latrell Mitchell and Dylan Edwards in the side. However, the Blues need midfield dominance and it’s time for Payne Haas to step up on the Origin stage.
PETER BADEL
NSW by 6
The Blues have picked a much better side and will be more desperate with their series on the line. Latrell Mitchell loves the big stage. Bring on a Suncorp decider.
DEAN RITCHIE
NSW by 10
New-look side with plenty of strike. Mitchell Moses’ long kicking game and Latrell Mitchell’s brilliance will be the difference.
BRENT READ
Queensland by 2
The Blues have picked a better team but the return of Reece Walsh will supercharge the Maroons to a series win. Walsh only played seven minutes in Origin I after being KO’d and he will be champing at the bit in Melbourne.
ROBERT CRADDOCK
Queensland by 2
It’s the 30th anniversary of Mark Coyne’s “miracle’’ try and don’t be surprised if this match is decided by a similar work of art.
Knobby22
Mmmmmm 2nd breakfast
- Joined
- 13 October 2004
- Posts
- 9,609
- Reactions
- 6,401
In Melbourne tonight. They are hoping for 80,000+.
rcw1 jealous, you going o the game bloke??
Knobby22
Mmmmmm 2nd breakfast
- Joined
- 13 October 2004
- Posts
- 9,609
- Reactions
- 6,401
No, I have to go to something else.
Knobby22
Mmmmmm 2nd breakfast
- Joined
- 13 October 2004
- Posts
- 9,609
- Reactions
- 6,401
Wow! I think Brisbane have not got enough Melbourne Storm players
IFocus
You are arguing with a Galah
- Joined
- 8 September 2006
- Posts
- 7,471
- Reactions
- 4,467
Really surprised how Qld went in the 1st half, the blues did have some stand out players, don't normally follow other than state of origin always support Qld.
Good afternoon
Big Wayney's gripes:
EXCLUSIVE: ‘I have to stand up’ — Wayne Bennett takes aim at refs, bunker in stunning NRL plea
Paul Crawley from Fox Sports
Wayne Bennett has unloaded on the overall unfairness in the standard of NRL refereeing and the Bunker, while calling for a dramatic overhaul on punishment for foul play, including a major revamp of the sin bin and send-off rules.
The Dolphins super coach says his frustrations about the standard of officiating has been growing for some time.
But he decided to speak out publicly because he says the current system is not getting better -and is having too big an impact on too many games.
“If I was a punter I couldn’t bet a penny on rugby league at the moment,” the game’s greatest coach said in an exclusive interview with foxsports.com.au.
“Do I need the grief this will cause? No, I don’t.
“But I have to stand up for the players and the game I have spent my whole life being a part of and loving.
“We can’t hide and pretend it is not a problem because it is a problem.
“And it is causing massive frustration, not just with the players and coaches, but the fans.
“People always go on about consistency.
“I know how hard consistency is.
“What I want is fairness for every team.
“I want to know we are all getting a fair shake out there.”
FOUL PLAY PUNISHMENT A LOTTERY
Every game it seems has different rule interpretations for illegal high contact.
One game you see a player sin binned for a high shot that wouldn’t bruise a grape.
Then the following game someone gets clocked good and proper and it doesn’t so much as warrant a penalty.
“I will give you an example,” Bennett continued.
“I have had four players in the last two weeks hit with contact to the head by the opposition illegally.
“Not one penalty in those four times.
“But I have had two of these players taken out of the game on the advice of the independent doctor, who believed that they were concussed and so they were out of the game for 15 minutes.
“So the doctor, who is the expert, believed they were concussed.
“Yet the referee accused one of the players (Herbie Farnworth) that he was milking it.
“Who is the expert here? The referee, the guy in the Bunker, or the doctor?
“If the doctor believes he has been concussed, how can we leave it up to the referee or Bunker to argue that?
“That is part of the frustration.
“Then in Wednesday night’s State of Origin there were two penalties for high tackles. The players affected didn’t go to ground, nor were they called from the field for a HIA.
“So this is where I get confused because in a game played five days before you can’t get a penalty for illegal contact to the head. “And five days later under the same set of rules they get penalties and the game goes on.”
SO HOW DO WE FIX IT?
“I will go back to my original point,” Bennett said.
“If someone is hit in the head, unless it is clearly accidental, then that should be a penalty.
“What they do after that (in respect to possible suspensions) is their prerogative.
“But there is a duty of care the game has to its players.
“Have they met some of that? Of course they have.
“But typical of these people is that they continue to put band aids on situations rather than make the hard decision and getting us all to fall in line with it.”
Bennett says it’s a similar scenario with punishment dished out for players running in to spark a melee.
“In our game (against the Storm) there is a melee when Tevita Pangia did that good tackle,” Bennett explained.
“He was offside but it was not an illegal tackle.
“And yet a player from the other team raced in and started a melee. Even though we didn’t start the melee, no action. No penalty. No sin bin.
“Then you can go back to Origin on Wednesday night, and it was a great example of the frustration I am getting at.
“There was a melee in the second half and the referee takes no action. But he said, ‘If it happens again I will take action’.
“Sure enough it happened again and he took action.
“My point here is if he took action in the first place and didn’t put the band aid on there wouldn’t have been a second melee.
“Anyone who thinks the melee is a good look for the game is kidding themselves.
“So why do we put up with it?”
BAN THE BIN AND ALLOW A SEND OFF REPLACEMENT
Bennett wants to go two giant steps further by abolishing the sin bin for anything other than professional fouls, while revamping the send-off rule so teams get a replacement player after 10 minutes.
He says the send-off should also cost the offending team three interchanges while the offending player should not return to the game.
“We can’t get the sin bin right because of all the different variations and interpretations,” he said.
“We played this game for 90-odd years without a sin bin.
“So let’s just keep it simple and stick to the professional fouls for sin bins, and then let the match review committee take control of the grading and suspensions.”
“And now to the send-off.
“If you go back to the send-off in the first State of Origin, this is what the game has to look at.
“What I am saying is the decision (to send off Joseph Suaalii) was right. 100 per cent.
“But we have no comeback when it leaves one team with 12 men and the game is done.
“The send-off was created in 1908.
“There were T Model Fords in 1908.
“We still have cars today. But, geez, the cars have changed enormously.
“Yet we still have the same send-off.
“We are asking fans to pay $300 to go to a State of Origin game.
“If I am paying $300 and I am going to take my family and it costs well over $1000, and I know the game is over in 7 minutes, we have got to be better than that.
“It is a discussion we need to have.
“I am not trying to belt anyone up.
“I just want to be constructive.
“I want to be honest and tell what is really happening out there.
“The kickback is always that you have to send players off or otherwise they will be doing this or doing that (to illegally rub out the best players).
“But the AFL have never sent a player off in their history.
“They have had tough men. They have great players. They have all survived with no sent off players.
“Am I saying we do that, not necessarily.
“But we have to look at what we can do. And don’t use the excuse they will just be taking out the best players.
“There were times in our game when players got rubbed out for two years (for foul play) because the game was brutal on foul play.
“The bosses at the time brought Jim Comans in to clean up the game and there is still nothing to stop us doing that.
“High profile players have always been targeted. The great Wally Lewis. Allan Langers. Andrew Johns. Brad Fittlers.
“You don’t think they were singled out as well?
“But the answer is heavier penalties post-match. We need to have a mature discussion about the send-off and the sin bin.
“I have not spoken to other coaches about this, but I am sure they would share the same frustrations.
“It is a great competition.
“The salary cap is working.
“It is also why it is so important to get the officiating right.
“I have no doubt they are saying to themselves in there at the NRL, ‘Here comes Bennett again, whinging’.
“But no one rings me up from the NRL.
“Nobody says to me that ‘we have reviewed the performance of the referee and Bunker and it wasn’t where it should be’.
“I have got to question them.
“They have a responsibility much greater than not to be having a whinge about me because I am unhappy or disappointed about the way a game was officiated.
“But I am the bad guy because I am making a complaint.
“I make the complaint because I care about my players.
“I don’t want to see them get hit in the head illegally, we all understand the consequences of that. The head is a no-go zone.
“I don’t want my players copping poor decisions.
“I owe it to them.
“I ask them to go out there and play to the rules and we judge them on their performance.
“And I feel like I have let them down if I don’t question when I know the decisions are wrong.
“In our last game they got four decisions wrong which they admit to, and we should have got four penalties. We got none.
“Am I saying drop the ref? No, I am not.
“We have players that have bad games.
“But we have to be better.
“Everyone thought the Bunker was going to be the saviour of the game.
“The Bunker has made it worse because they have hindsight and time on their hands, and they still can’t get it right.
“I think the answer is more accountability, better training for the Bunker, and less people in the referee’s ears when he is referring the game.
“Because right now he has a coach, two sideline officials and a Bunker person who have access to him.
“I couldn’t imagine sending my player into a game with all that information being fed to him why he is trying to do his job.
“Am I against talking to the referee? No, I am not.
“But it should only be in a break of play and the referees’ coach should have the same rule on him as we do on our players.
“A message can be taken out in a break of play and then we all move on.
“We can’t just sit back and continue to let this happen.
“It’s not just me disgruntled by this.
“It is other coaches, players and most importantly the fans who pay their hard-earned money to support our game.
“We can’t just continue to fob it off and say, ‘He is whinging again’. And we can’t say the fans are whingers too.”
Source: www.foxsports.com.au
Big Wayney's gripes:
EXCLUSIVE: ‘I have to stand up’ — Wayne Bennett takes aim at refs, bunker in stunning NRL plea
Paul Crawley from Fox Sports
Wayne Bennett has unloaded on the overall unfairness in the standard of NRL refereeing and the Bunker, while calling for a dramatic overhaul on punishment for foul play, including a major revamp of the sin bin and send-off rules.
The Dolphins super coach says his frustrations about the standard of officiating has been growing for some time.
But he decided to speak out publicly because he says the current system is not getting better -and is having too big an impact on too many games.
“If I was a punter I couldn’t bet a penny on rugby league at the moment,” the game’s greatest coach said in an exclusive interview with foxsports.com.au.
“Do I need the grief this will cause? No, I don’t.
“But I have to stand up for the players and the game I have spent my whole life being a part of and loving.
“We can’t hide and pretend it is not a problem because it is a problem.
“And it is causing massive frustration, not just with the players and coaches, but the fans.
“People always go on about consistency.
“I know how hard consistency is.
“What I want is fairness for every team.
“I want to know we are all getting a fair shake out there.”
FOUL PLAY PUNISHMENT A LOTTERY
Every game it seems has different rule interpretations for illegal high contact.
One game you see a player sin binned for a high shot that wouldn’t bruise a grape.
Then the following game someone gets clocked good and proper and it doesn’t so much as warrant a penalty.
“I will give you an example,” Bennett continued.
“I have had four players in the last two weeks hit with contact to the head by the opposition illegally.
“Not one penalty in those four times.
“But I have had two of these players taken out of the game on the advice of the independent doctor, who believed that they were concussed and so they were out of the game for 15 minutes.
“So the doctor, who is the expert, believed they were concussed.
“Yet the referee accused one of the players (Herbie Farnworth) that he was milking it.
“Who is the expert here? The referee, the guy in the Bunker, or the doctor?
“If the doctor believes he has been concussed, how can we leave it up to the referee or Bunker to argue that?
“That is part of the frustration.
“Then in Wednesday night’s State of Origin there were two penalties for high tackles. The players affected didn’t go to ground, nor were they called from the field for a HIA.
“So this is where I get confused because in a game played five days before you can’t get a penalty for illegal contact to the head. “And five days later under the same set of rules they get penalties and the game goes on.”
SO HOW DO WE FIX IT?
“I will go back to my original point,” Bennett said.
“If someone is hit in the head, unless it is clearly accidental, then that should be a penalty.
“What they do after that (in respect to possible suspensions) is their prerogative.
“But there is a duty of care the game has to its players.
“Have they met some of that? Of course they have.
“But typical of these people is that they continue to put band aids on situations rather than make the hard decision and getting us all to fall in line with it.”
Bennett says it’s a similar scenario with punishment dished out for players running in to spark a melee.
“In our game (against the Storm) there is a melee when Tevita Pangia did that good tackle,” Bennett explained.
“He was offside but it was not an illegal tackle.
“And yet a player from the other team raced in and started a melee. Even though we didn’t start the melee, no action. No penalty. No sin bin.
“Then you can go back to Origin on Wednesday night, and it was a great example of the frustration I am getting at.
“There was a melee in the second half and the referee takes no action. But he said, ‘If it happens again I will take action’.
“Sure enough it happened again and he took action.
“My point here is if he took action in the first place and didn’t put the band aid on there wouldn’t have been a second melee.
“Anyone who thinks the melee is a good look for the game is kidding themselves.
“So why do we put up with it?”
BAN THE BIN AND ALLOW A SEND OFF REPLACEMENT
Bennett wants to go two giant steps further by abolishing the sin bin for anything other than professional fouls, while revamping the send-off rule so teams get a replacement player after 10 minutes.
He says the send-off should also cost the offending team three interchanges while the offending player should not return to the game.
“We can’t get the sin bin right because of all the different variations and interpretations,” he said.
“We played this game for 90-odd years without a sin bin.
“So let’s just keep it simple and stick to the professional fouls for sin bins, and then let the match review committee take control of the grading and suspensions.”
“And now to the send-off.
“If you go back to the send-off in the first State of Origin, this is what the game has to look at.
“What I am saying is the decision (to send off Joseph Suaalii) was right. 100 per cent.
“But we have no comeback when it leaves one team with 12 men and the game is done.
“The send-off was created in 1908.
“There were T Model Fords in 1908.
“We still have cars today. But, geez, the cars have changed enormously.
“Yet we still have the same send-off.
“We are asking fans to pay $300 to go to a State of Origin game.
“If I am paying $300 and I am going to take my family and it costs well over $1000, and I know the game is over in 7 minutes, we have got to be better than that.
“It is a discussion we need to have.
“I am not trying to belt anyone up.
“I just want to be constructive.
“I want to be honest and tell what is really happening out there.
“The kickback is always that you have to send players off or otherwise they will be doing this or doing that (to illegally rub out the best players).
“But the AFL have never sent a player off in their history.
“They have had tough men. They have great players. They have all survived with no sent off players.
“Am I saying we do that, not necessarily.
“But we have to look at what we can do. And don’t use the excuse they will just be taking out the best players.
“There were times in our game when players got rubbed out for two years (for foul play) because the game was brutal on foul play.
“The bosses at the time brought Jim Comans in to clean up the game and there is still nothing to stop us doing that.
“High profile players have always been targeted. The great Wally Lewis. Allan Langers. Andrew Johns. Brad Fittlers.
“You don’t think they were singled out as well?
“But the answer is heavier penalties post-match. We need to have a mature discussion about the send-off and the sin bin.
“I have not spoken to other coaches about this, but I am sure they would share the same frustrations.
“It is a great competition.
“The salary cap is working.
“It is also why it is so important to get the officiating right.
“I have no doubt they are saying to themselves in there at the NRL, ‘Here comes Bennett again, whinging’.
“But no one rings me up from the NRL.
“Nobody says to me that ‘we have reviewed the performance of the referee and Bunker and it wasn’t where it should be’.
“I have got to question them.
“They have a responsibility much greater than not to be having a whinge about me because I am unhappy or disappointed about the way a game was officiated.
“But I am the bad guy because I am making a complaint.
“I make the complaint because I care about my players.
“I don’t want to see them get hit in the head illegally, we all understand the consequences of that. The head is a no-go zone.
“I don’t want my players copping poor decisions.
“I owe it to them.
“I ask them to go out there and play to the rules and we judge them on their performance.
“And I feel like I have let them down if I don’t question when I know the decisions are wrong.
“In our last game they got four decisions wrong which they admit to, and we should have got four penalties. We got none.
“Am I saying drop the ref? No, I am not.
“We have players that have bad games.
“But we have to be better.
“Everyone thought the Bunker was going to be the saviour of the game.
“The Bunker has made it worse because they have hindsight and time on their hands, and they still can’t get it right.
“I think the answer is more accountability, better training for the Bunker, and less people in the referee’s ears when he is referring the game.
“Because right now he has a coach, two sideline officials and a Bunker person who have access to him.
“I couldn’t imagine sending my player into a game with all that information being fed to him why he is trying to do his job.
“Am I against talking to the referee? No, I am not.
“But it should only be in a break of play and the referees’ coach should have the same rule on him as we do on our players.
“A message can be taken out in a break of play and then we all move on.
“We can’t just sit back and continue to let this happen.
“It’s not just me disgruntled by this.
“It is other coaches, players and most importantly the fans who pay their hard-earned money to support our game.
“We can’t just continue to fob it off and say, ‘He is whinging again’. And we can’t say the fans are whingers too.”
Source: www.foxsports.com.au
cracker of a game this Newcastle v Paramatta battle. Moses form in SoO he has taken into his game.
Watched the Blackhawks v Norths, Qld State League game live earlier today in Townsville after a punt at the Pub Tab. Norths won convincingly 36 to 10.
Kind regards
rcw1
Watched the Blackhawks v Norths, Qld State League game live earlier today in Townsville after a punt at the Pub Tab. Norths won convincingly 36 to 10.
Kind regards
rcw1
Good evening
It has been reported, Chad Townsend will quit the Cowboys at season’s end. Been offered $300,000 deal to finish his career at the Roosters. Understand was on $750K at the Cowboys. Had been some talk 12 months ago or more, that Townsend was unhappy at the Cowboys. rcw1 will give the lad his dues, stayed on until his contract finished in 2024. $450K pay cut is quite substantial. Maybe believes could win another premiership with the roosters...
Reported Chad is at the roosters to mentor up and coming halves, Sam Walker and Sandon Smith and maybe they have their eye on somebody younger to come across to the Roosters in 2026... who knows for sure???
rcw1 has commented in this thread, time for Townsend to make tracks.
Kind regards
rcw1
It has been reported, Chad Townsend will quit the Cowboys at season’s end. Been offered $300,000 deal to finish his career at the Roosters. Understand was on $750K at the Cowboys. Had been some talk 12 months ago or more, that Townsend was unhappy at the Cowboys. rcw1 will give the lad his dues, stayed on until his contract finished in 2024. $450K pay cut is quite substantial. Maybe believes could win another premiership with the roosters...
Reported Chad is at the roosters to mentor up and coming halves, Sam Walker and Sandon Smith and maybe they have their eye on somebody younger to come across to the Roosters in 2026... who knows for sure???
rcw1 has commented in this thread, time for Townsend to make tracks.
Kind regards
rcw1
Titans have beaten the Sharkies 20 points to 16 ...
Never in doubt ha ha ha Wonder if Billy gives David Fifita a call over the weekend. Qld SoO team announced on Monday.
Broncos v Panthers next. Hmmmm gotta tip Brisbane on this occasion.
Have a very nice weekend.
Kind regards
rcw
Never in doubt ha ha ha Wonder if Billy gives David Fifita a call over the weekend. Qld SoO team announced on Monday.
Broncos v Panthers next. Hmmmm gotta tip Brisbane on this occasion.
Have a very nice weekend.
Kind regards
rcw
Garpal Gumnut
Ross Island Hotel
- Joined
- 2 January 2006
- Posts
- 13,344
- Reactions
- 9,450
Although the "new" NQ Cowboys stadium is just across the road from the Ross Island Hotel, I was unable to visit it until last night. It is a magnificent venue with seating enabling a view close to the action from every seat.
I would encourage supporters of Southern RL Clubs to visit Townsville for their away games. They will not be disappointed. The hotel space has increased with good value for money availability in the Region.
Now I'm back up the stairs to watch the V8's from the verandah.
gg
I would encourage supporters of Southern RL Clubs to visit Townsville for their away games. They will not be disappointed. The hotel space has increased with good value for money availability in the Region.
Now I'm back up the stairs to watch the V8's from the verandah.
gg
