Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Metrics for quantifying an intraday strategy?

True

The way i read the first post is that he has back-tested say 10 yrs, but the results are only like this if he leaves a certain year out (im guessing 2008).

If i am reading it correctly, how does Punta know what years to enter and what to sit out? Hence why i want to see the equity curve to prove my suspicions

Oh no, that's not it - by leave-one-year-out, I simply mean I'm testing the algo on data that it was not trained on. This period could be at the beginning, middle, or end of the available dataset, but obviously it makes sense to chose the most recent period, if you plan on implementing it into the future.
 
See attached - the time is one calendar year (around 250 trading days). This is ASX data, finishing in Oct 2011. The test data plotted were not used in training the algorithm...
The ASX has been predominantly down daily so that graph is another sign of b.s..
 
The ASX has been predominantly down daily so that graph is another sign of b.s..

Doesn't mean it's B.S if all the down moves happen over night and during the day prices move to fill the overnight gaps - improbable but not impossible.
 
Doesn't mean it's B.S if all the down moves happen over night and during the day prices move to fill the overnight gaps - improbable but not impossible.

The strategy is based on indicators over the last few days. If 60% of the positions you enter are successful, you will make money (assuming no skew in the up/downside), and like I said (and the graph shows), this strategy actually makes money on 75% of the days it trades.

As people have said, maybe the brokerage fees on lots of small trades will kill this (but then again it is possible that fewer larger positions will work equally well).
 
Yeah I was thinking that. I realise (through talking to people here) that I can get filled at open, but not at close. I have had a brief look at prices at 3.45 versus close, and didn't find any systematic differences.

Think you have it the other way around. Liquidity at the close is massive. Open is pretty crap. You can definitely use the close price, but treat the open with a grain of salt.

You might want to put in some liquidity filters. Eg, you can only do 10% of a day's volume. So that'll filter out small stocks with large moves ticked on a few shares.
 
Top