- Joined
- 21 December 2013
- Posts
- 232
- Reactions
- 83
What big whinge?
XAO Banter Thread
- Thread starter clayton4115
- Start date
The chart I present is the the All Ords Index of the Australian Market adjusted for dividends. One can very easily gain exposure to the ASX200 index via STW and exposure to the ASX300 index via VAS. The index is a mechanical trading system based on Market Cap traded quarterly - by default as a company's share prices falls, market cap falls and they go out of the index (although some go broke whilst still in the index but normally the index is so well diversified one going broke has little effect on it). It is a classic example of the saying let your winners run and cut your losers. The strong survive.
If one wishes to pick their own shares, then that is a real risk - picking shares that underperform the market (index) or other shares - there is also the opportunity to pick shares that outperform the market, of which there are many eg CSL, COH, ALL, REA, MFG, CTD to name a few.
The shares you mention look to have been strong dividend yield payers at one point or another. Maybe that was the reason one may have accumulated them???? Surely you had others that went on to make many multiples of the buy price?
Last edited:
- Joined
- 3 July 2009
- Posts
- 27,044
- Reactions
- 23,578
That is all true, but take for example the Banks,at the moment they are on the nose.
They have been great dividend payers, but in reality, your capital could well end up back at what it was 10 years ago.
Most investors that wish to make an income from dividends, tend to hang on to ones that pay good dividends and sell ones that don't.
I guess that may be one of the reasons, LIC's and ETF's, are becoming more popular.
tinhat
Pocket Calculator Operator
- Joined
- 1 May 2009
- Posts
- 1,756
- Reactions
- 768
Today's announcement at Whyalla with the steelworks expansion has a lot of relevance to the ASX generally.
How many times have we seen things like that run down and eventually close? Around Australia there would be too many instances to list.
One man from overseas has by turning Whyalla around shown that rather a lot of Australian corporate management is sadly lacking in vision and ability. At just one site he's shown countless business leaders and politicians to be lacking at best, incompetent at worst.
So it's not just broader economics or government, I think the quality of management we have in Australia and the lack of vision at least partly explains the performance of our stock market over the past decade compared to overseas markets. Too many want to go sideways or shrink, there aren't many with vision and the ability to make it happen.
This is a fair bit off topic, and I am just showing my ignorance here... I do wonder where the money is coming from? If this is all being financed with debt and interest rates go up and if steel prices fall (after all this business is tied to the market for an underlying commodity) things could all turn south. I just wonder about the quality of the funds being used. Is there any transparency around the financing of Gupta's business empire?
I find the timing of this market downturn perplexing as none of the key leading indicators that predict a recession within 12 months (typically) have ticked over yet so to me this is mistimed based on news narrative.
I'm probably just repeating myself but I'm high conviction that the market will be positive for the next 6 months and would be surprised if these losses (whatever they amount to) weren't fully recovered by mid year.
I'm probably just repeating myself but I'm high conviction that the market will be positive for the next 6 months and would be surprised if these losses (whatever they amount to) weren't fully recovered by mid year.
- Joined
- 14 February 2005
- Posts
- 15,094
- Reactions
- 16,868
I must stop looking at the overseas markets.
I see red.
She goes down.
Down down deeper and down.
Unfortunately the obvious musical reference missing is the one that I want - Money for nothin'
I see red.
She goes down.
Down down deeper and down.
Unfortunately the obvious musical reference missing is the one that I want - Money for nothin'
PZ99
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
- Joined
- 13 May 2015
- Posts
- 3,303
- Reactions
- 2,402
Multiple musical references so I guess the bands you had in mind wereI must stop looking at the overseas markets.
I see red.
She goes down.
Down down deeper and down.
Unfortunately the obvious musical reference missing is the one that I want - Money for nothin'
Split Enz did (I see red)
Motley Crue (She goes down)
Status Quo (Down down)
and the most apt one being... Dire Straits.
10cc Wall Street Shuffle has good lyrics too
- Joined
- 6 September 2016
- Posts
- 1,260
- Reactions
- 1,596
Are you operating under the assumption that the market can only fall as it discounts a recession?
- Joined
- 29 August 2014
- Posts
- 500
- Reactions
- 72
Future down a far bit. Another very poor year most investors
Tax revenue up, clearly something wrong with our sharemarket
Tax revenue up, clearly something wrong with our sharemarket
- Joined
- 29 August 2014
- Posts
- 500
- Reactions
- 72
Joules MM1 you still here?
Generally, as the most extreme example of the 1987 crash fully recovered the discounting by 1989 as there was no real world follow through.
Last edited:
greggles
I'll be back!
- Joined
- 28 July 2004
- Posts
- 4,460
- Reactions
- 4,494
Things aren't looking good. Last time the XAO was at these levels was exactly two years ago but it was travelling north instead of south. Support at 5,700 has been breached. With US markets looking very shaky I think we'll see 5,500 before the end of the year.
- Joined
- 29 August 2014
- Posts
- 500
- Reactions
- 72
another 70 points today.
best place in the world?
best place in the world?
As of this minute the US is 0.9% off a bear market.
You'd think it's in alot of people's interest to get it done with, possibly as soon as tonight, if not by end of year.
I'm super bullish on a comeback to previous highs in 2019 before we run into the real deal.
You'd think it's in alot of people's interest to get it done with, possibly as soon as tonight, if not by end of year.
I'm super bullish on a comeback to previous highs in 2019 before we run into the real deal.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 31 March 2015
- Posts
- 477
- Reactions
- 865
Interesting on what % fall is qualified as a bear market. At this current juncture most people's portfolios have ripped to shreds..
Given the current fear and persistent selling, can't see a long lasting rally starting any time soon. Downtrend will persist till Feb/March before any meaningul rally gets underway.
This is gonna be a long bear me thinks and an excursion back to GFC lows eventually.
- Joined
- 9 June 2011
- Posts
- 1,926
- Reactions
- 480
It’s entirely possible this is the start of a bear market but I’d be interested in how one justifies the s&p back to 675?
- Joined
- 31 March 2015
- Posts
- 477
- Reactions
- 865
This is the XAO banter thread, who said anything about SPX? As for the XAO, given the corrective looking advance off the March 2009 low that didn't make new high, then it would be surprising to see a re test of 3050 again before the bear that started in 2007 is finally finished
My philosophy is the timing of this pullback is not yet supported by fundamental deterioration so I think we'll see a significant recovery that will mirror whatever the magnitude is IE. a +20% type bounce.
Yield inversion is possible in H1 2019 but that typically is around a 12 month leading indicator suggesting no recession until 2020.
Yield inversion is possible in H1 2019 but that typically is around a 12 month leading indicator suggesting no recession until 2020.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 9 June 2011
- Posts
- 1,926
- Reactions
- 480
Apologies I saw the reference to the S&P above and assumed.
I agree no new highs in the index is a concern however I wonder if the accumulation index is more appropriate given how heavy dividend paying out stocks are
- Joined
- 25 February 2011
- Posts
- 5,685
- Reactions
- 1,218
Similar threads
