Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Thanks for the links TS!

Yeah, i reckon all the Global QE have rooted the clock, i think its in need of some kind of re-calibration.:2twocents
 
When was there falling real estate prices? 3% is hardly a fall after %15+ gains in one year.

Careful what you read in the papers.

Yeah, we be looking a little more like 3 O'clock and we haven't had our property correction as they did in the GFC well, unless you live in Karratha. Gonna start somewhere!! Trickle trickle
 
Careful what you read in the papers.

we haven't had our property correction as they did in the GFC

I wouldn't be expecting a repeat, why would you? What are the similarities? Its a bubble? All bubble are not alike....:2twocents
 
I wouldn't be expecting a repeat, why would you? What are the similarities? Its a bubble? All bubble are not alike....:2twocents

I think there is a massive overbuild in apartments. That's where the bubble is. Guess who's buying, Yep The Chinese I did have a chat with a Lend Lease guy the other day, he said it's all still going strong. I said, 'your selling everything to the yellow fellas aren't ya.' He said 'yep!' I said, 'you concerned about the slow down and clamp down on the funny money?,' he said, 'people don't get it' and 'it's still going like hot cakes.' I caught his eye a little later on, in the evening, he looked a little sheepish! Not sure why.
But it will end soon enough and we can all pick up $150,000 apartments that were sold for 300k or 400k.
Cash up :D
 
I think there is a massive overbuild in apartments. That's where the bubble is. Guess who's buying, Yep The Chinese I did have a chat with a Lend Lease guy the other day, he said it's all still going strong. I said, 'your selling everything to the yellow fellas aren't ya.' He said 'yep!' I said, 'you concerned about the slow down and clamp down on the funny money?,' he said, 'people don't get it' and 'it's still going like hot cakes.' I caught his eye a little later on, in the evening, he looked a little sheepish! Not sure why.
But it will end soon enough and we can all pick up $150,000 apartments that were sold for 300k or 400k.
Cash up :D
In all my years of investing I have never seen half price or 60% reductions of real estate in Sydney. It won't happen, it never has before and it won't in the future, good luck with hoping, wishing and praying for that.
 
I must have been asleep.

When was there falling real estate prices? 3% is hardly a fall after %15+ gains in one year.

I also must have slept through the recession.

More to property prices in Australia then just Sydney satan ;)

Amortise 3% over a full year and the 15% gain does not seem that much anymore :eek:

The clock is not specific to Australia either. Remember Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece, Slovenia, Belgium, United Kingdom / half of the Eurozone? Pretty sure they were in recession.

Cottesloe is a suburb revered for its relaxed beach-side lifestyle. Close to the city, yet still far enough away to not be exposed to its hyper-urban nature, Cottesloe is an ideal location for those who want the best of both worlds. Its land area spans four square kilometres and is characterised by a blend of historical and modern residences.

PERTH METRO AREA
10.8 % decline http://reiwa.com.au/wa/cottesloe/6011/ Median house price $1,700,000 - High end market
2.6% decline http://reiwa.com.au/wa/morley/6062/ Median house price $554,300 - Medium end market

ADELAIDE METRO & MAJOR TOWNS
https://www.sa.gov.au/topics/housin...vice-for-buyers/median-house-sales-by-quarter

TOWNSVILLE - December 2014
Domain Group figures showed the median house prices for the six months ended December 14 was $370,0006.3 per cent lower than five years *earlier. The median price for units was $283,000 or 18 per cent down on 2009 prices. Ms Grice said she was confident about 2015.

http://www.afr.com/real-estate/resi...erty-market-on-downward-trend-20150129-131ka1

TOWNSVILLE - March 2015
However, the agency advises that it is currently "a good time to buy" in Townsville, given low median prices and low interest rates. According to the Real Estate Institute of Queensland (REIQ), Townsville's median house price was down 5.6% in the September quarter to $340,000, with a 27% increase in sales activity.

http://www.propertyobserver.com.au/...-for-townsville-market-herron-todd-white.html

Hmmmm more to property then just Sydney and Melbourne eh? Regional Australia RE is doing it tough. :2twocents
 
In all my years of investing I have never seen half price or 60% reductions of real estate in Sydney. It won't happen, it never has before and it won't in the future, good luck with hoping, wishing and praying for that.

That's what they all thought in the US, and elsewhere, before the subprime mortgage crisis hit and we got the GFC.

I can't imagine it would halved in Australia, but it's not going to stay where it is either.

Remember a friend back maybe 15 years ago.. .the guy was just starting out and bought an investment apartment in the CBD for around $550K. The market collapsed and he have to quit his part time uni, pick up another job so that's two jobs just to barely keep up with the mortgage. He couldn't sell it else he would lose $150K or so. Since then he's been working in factories.

The way it is now, houses are not affordable without a lot of loans from relatives and both couple having to work 3 jobs between them. I personally know a couple of property owners who couldn't collect their rent recently because the tenants have to send some cash back to their parents in Vietnam for the Lunar New Year.

I mean, rent in the West is around $450 a week; take home pay maybe $700... Most couldn't do it without sharing with a relative or a friend.

We're all on very thin ice. Let's just hope it's brought down slowly and not collapse in a hurry.
 
That's what they all thought in the US, and elsewhere, before the subprime mortgage crisis hit and we got the GFC.

I can't imagine it would halved in Australia, but it's not going to stay where it is either.

We're all on very thin ice. Let's just hope it's brought down slowly and not collapse in a hurry.

1) We don't have jingle key loans here. We have full recourse loans. Mortgage arrears are at 7 year lows ;)

2) Sydney will be the market that will be corrected to be around 15% IMO. Mainly from the HIGH END market contracting which skewiff sales/pricing data. Rest of the country has already stagnated. Started about 3 years ago.

3) Nope ... I read somewhere money owing on housing loans taken out by households was equivalent to 29% of the value of residential land and dwellings owned by households. Pretty good shape really. Must mean there are a lot of people with huge equity in residential property !

4) Steady as she goes skipper.
 
1) We don't have jingle key loans here. We have full recourse loans. Mortgage arrears are at 7 year lows ;)

2) Sydney will be the market that will be corrected to be around 15% IMO. Mainly from the HIGH END market contracting which skewiff sales/pricing data. Rest of the country has already stagnated. Started about 3 years ago.

3) Nope ... I read somewhere money owing on housing loans taken out by households was equivalent to 29% of the value of residential land and dwellings owned by households. Pretty good shape really. Must mean there are a lot of people with huge equity in residential property !

4) Steady as she goes skipper.

If they declare bankruptcy, how will the bankers get their money back? Send over the lawyers, the goons and then prison or what?

Money still owing on the loans is 29% of land/property value... and if land/property value now is at an all time high... that's not a good thing at that rate either.

Say I still owe the bank $300K; my property is valued at $1000K [1 million]. That's around 29% of property value right?

But if my property should be worth, say, $500K... and if the market correct itself and it get to say $600K.. my loan is now 50% of value, so my equity is much less. And if it get to that ratio, might not be able to borrow against the property/ies.

I think more accurate ratio would be something like debt owing to total borrowed.
So if I borrowed $1M and had paid off $700k, still owing only $300k. The other ratio doesn't make sense to me.
 
If they declare bankruptcy, how will the bankers get their money back? Send over the lawyers, the goons and then prison or what?

Money still owing on the loans is 29% of land/property value... and if land/property value now is at an all time high... that's not a good thing at that rate either.

Say I still owe the bank $300K; my property is valued at $1000K [1 million]. That's around 29% of property value right?

But if my property should be worth, say, $500K... and if the market correct itself and it get to say $600K.. my loan is now 50% of value, so my equity is much less. And if it get to that ratio, might not be able to borrow against the property/ies.

I think more accurate ratio would be something like debt owing to total borrowed.
So if I borrowed $1M and had paid off $700k, still owing only $300k. The other ratio doesn't make sense to me.

1) The banks foreclose on the house and sells it for the current market achievable rate. Any losses incurred is the responsibility of the mortgagee. If there is LMI in place then the LMI underwrites the bank then pursues the mortgagee. If the house sells for LESS than what it is valued for then the bank and the LMI pursue the VALUER. Which is why they pay so much in indemnity insurance. End of the day the bank/LMI/valuer then will pursue the mortgagee for any losses. If they declare bankruptcy then the bank will look internally as to WHO approved the loan and pursue them (as in they get the sack)

2) Better than anywhere else in the world ;)

3) Yes give or take 1%

4) Are you saying there will be a 40% correction? Are you Steven Keen? You can borrow up to 90% with LMI in a refinancing option under current bank guidelines. Therefore your 600k house you can borrow up to $540,000 depending on income and debt serviceability ratios etc etc. REMEMBER this ratio is over ALL residential property in Australia. Like I said there MUST be a lot of people who own houses outright or have huge equity in them. Most of the people I know are around the 20% equity mark and contributing over 35% of income to mortgage.

5) You have not accounted for the DEPOSIT you would have been required to place down on the property to borrow 1 million? Let's say you purchased a property for 1 million in Sydney and you placed a 20% deposit down. You do the math :cool:
 
1) The banks foreclose on the house and sells it for the current market achievable rate. Any losses incurred is the responsibility of the mortgagee. If there is LMI in place then the LMI underwrites the bank then pursues the mortgagee. If the house sells for LESS than what it is valued for then the bank and the LMI pursue the VALUER. Which is why they pay so much in indemnity insurance. End of the day the bank/LMI/valuer then will pursue the mortgagee for any losses. If they declare bankruptcy then the bank will look internally as to WHO approved the loan and pursue them (as in they get the sack)

2) Better than anywhere else in the world ;)

3) Yes give or take 1%

4) Are you saying there will be a 40% correction? Are you Steven Keen? You can borrow up to 90% with LMI in a refinancing option under current bank guidelines. Therefore your 600k house you can borrow up to $540,000 depending on income and debt serviceability ratios etc etc. REMEMBER this ratio is over ALL residential property in Australia. Like I said there MUST be a lot of people who own houses outright or have huge equity in them. Most of the people I know are around the 20% equity mark and contributing over 35% of income to mortgage.

5) You have not accounted for the DEPOSIT you would have been required to place down on the property to borrow 1 million? Let's say you purchased a property for 1 million in Sydney and you placed a 20% deposit down. You do the math :cool:

Let's just hope the insurer still have cash to pay claims when they come calling then. But then taxpayers will bail them out if they're big enough anyway. :xyxthumbs Our money, somebody else's wealth. Awesome.

Don't know what the correction would be, or when it will happen. But I just know that Australia, with all its land and few people, shouldn't have property prices at a HK level.
 
In all my years of investing I have never seen half price or 60% reductions of real estate in Sydney. It won't happen, it never has before and it won't in the future, good luck with hoping, wishing and praying for that.

I'm not hoping for anything. And I never said Sydney, I said apartments. I'm not talking about the old style blocks in great locations I'm talking about the high rise housing commission flats with lipstick going up all over the place.

Regarding your experience :rolleyes:
My uncle owned a really nice 5 bedroom house, with a pool, spa, sauna, tennis court, in one of the best leafy streets in one of the best suburbs in the most livable city in the world.

About 10 years before a sub-developer bought the big block and chopped it in two and built two of em. They were exactly the same apart from the wrapping paper. The one next door sold for 1.1million my uncles was passed in about 15 months later for 665,000. I've seen it right outside my window!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! There probably worth about 5 million each today.

Uncles house.JPG

:D:D:D
 
I'm not hoping for anything. And I never said Sydney, I said apartments. I'm not talking about the old style blocks in great locations I'm talking about the high rise housing commission flats with lipstick going up all over the place.

I am talking specifically, Sydney and the Northern Beaches of Sydney, that is where most a my buying and selling has been done and 90% of all the real estate I bought there was apartments. There is no such thing as "high rise housing commission flats with lipstick" in that whole area. Most of it is 3 level apartments, those that are higher are all privately owned apartments. Manly to Palm Beach is some 40 kilometers in distance, it has never ever suffered a 50 to 60% drop in prices. I reckon a mass of bargain hunters would be out and about looking if only a 10% correction happened.

This is an area that Chinese buyers aren't interested in much, it's all the locals who are buying it up. People who love the Aussie beach lifestyle, people who wouldn't live anywhere else as their fathers and grandfathers all grew up there and will pay a little more to live there.

When you make statements like
But it will end soon enough and we can all pick up $150,000 apartments that were sold for 300k or 400k
You need to quantify that, like where exactly, ...etc. I can tell you now, price drops like you are suggesting of 60% won't happen ever in this area, it never has. 400K won't even buy you a 1 bedroom unit in this high demand area.

My question to you is, do you really think that a nice 2 br apartment with views that is now selling on the Northern Beaches for $1M today, will one day be worth 400K?......... NEVER. There are people with serious money in these high demand beach areas, just a minor correction and they will be out in droves buying....... believe me I had no trouble selling my last property 14 Months ago and they are still selling easily now.

I am currently out of investment property, I've made my money. But if those 60% reductions ever came along I'd be buying 2 for the price of one with my ears pinned back, so yes it is only wishful thinking.

About 10 years before a sub-developer bought the big block and chopped it in two and built two of em. They were exactly the same apart from the wrapping paper. The one next door sold for 1.1million my uncles was passed in about 15 months later for 665,000. I've seen it right outside my window!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! There probably worth about 5 million each today.

I note that it was passed in at 665K, means nothing. I had a property in Manly that went to auction that didn't even attract a bid. I ended up selling it 3 weeks later for a nice profit. Thanks for mentioning that each of those properties are worth $5 Million today, I wouldn't have sold at the throw away bid of 665K either.:xyxthumbs
 
I am talking specifically, Sydney and the Northern Beaches of Sydney, that is where most a my buying and selling has been done and 90% of all the real estate I bought there was apartments. There is no such thing as "high rise housing commission flats with lipstick" in that whole area. Most of it is 3 level apartments, those that are higher are all privately owned apartments. Manly to Palm Beach is some 40 kilometers in distance, it has never ever suffered a 50 to 60% drop in prices. I reckon a mass of bargain hunters would be out and about looking if only a 10% correction happened.

This is an area that Chinese buyers aren't interested in much, it's all the locals who are buying it up. People who love the Aussie beach lifestyle, people who wouldn't live anywhere else as their fathers and grandfathers all grew up there and will pay a little more to live there.

When you make statements like You need to quantify that, like where exactly, ...etc. I can tell you now, price drops like you are suggesting of 60% won't happen ever in this area, it never has. 400K won't even buy you a 1 bedroom unit in this high demand area.

My question to you is, do you really think that a nice 2 br apartment with views that is now selling on the Northern Beaches for $1M today, will one day be worth 400K?......... NEVER. There are people with serious money in these high demand beach areas, just a minor correction and they will be out in droves buying....... believe me I had no trouble selling my last property 14 Months ago and they are still selling easily now.

I am currently out of investment property, I've made my money. But if those 60% reductions ever came along I'd be buying 2 for the price of one with my ears pinned back, so yes it is only wishful thinking.



I note that it was passed in at 665K, means nothing. I had a property in Manly that went to auction that didn't even attract a bid. I ended up selling it 3 weeks later for a nice profit. Thanks for mentioning that each of those properties are worth $5 Million today, I wouldn't have sold at the throw away bid of 665K either.:xyxthumbs

You and TS might be right about the fringes and Northern beaches, but for most other folks their dream of owning a home now is either for the market to collapse by 30 to 50%; or that they'd earn enough to be able to afford a $1M+ property. Which dream is more likely give the state of the economy and housing market?
 
Top