This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Electric cars?

Would you buy an electric car?

  • Already own one

    Votes: 10 5.1%
  • Yes - would definitely buy

    Votes: 43 21.7%
  • Yes - preferred over petrol car if price/power/convenience similar

    Votes: 78 39.4%
  • Maybe - preference for neither, only concerned with costs etc

    Votes: 38 19.2%
  • No - prefer petrol car even if electric car has same price, power and convenience

    Votes: 25 12.6%
  • No - would never buy one

    Votes: 14 7.1%

  • Total voters
    198

This evidence of why some of the traditional vehicle manufacturers are going to disappear. Just like what happened to Packard, Studebaker, Leyland, AMC, Pontiac, Oldsmobile, SAAB... the list is long of automobile manufacturers that have disappeared through bankruptcy or taken over by cashed up competition.


The problem this time is that there isn't much competition with the cash to buy a struggling company.
 
I wondered about creating a separate thred for elctric trucks, but decided this was still the thread.
Tesla has (finally) delivered its first EV Semi to pepsi .
fromDrive
There is some pretty impressive stats in that.
800 kms on a single charge is good, especially as it was on a real world test drive carrying a 37 ton GVM.
And the price is a lot less than i would have expected,
The caveats of course are
1. The 1000 volt battery and motor pack is going to require some very serious training and isolation procedures during service.
2. Although the stated ability to charge at 1MW is sensational, the physical ability to have stations with multiple 1MW outputs are going to create some engineering challlenges in terms of supply and distribution.
3. Truckies brought up on the delights of a cummins, detroit or caterpillar will take some convincing.
I can see where the new Freuhauf trailers coming out will have rooftop solar panels to charge while stationary or even on the move.
Maybe a smaller battery pack in the trailer to augment the semi may be the go.
Interesting times ahead.
Mick
 
3. Truckies brought up on the delights of a cummins, detroit or caterpillar will take some convincing.
Perhaps a test drive ? I suspect that the power, comfort, quietness and operating economy of these electric truck rigs will win users over in a heart beat. The cost of buying one will always be a factor but the cheapness of running it 24/7 will make many friends
 

One great safety feature is the regenerative braking. Google ‘adelaide hills truck crash’. Every year there are multiple accidents from trucks having brake failure down that hit, the Jacob Brakes aren’t up to the job.
 
A side of E.V's that people didn't see coming, obviously when power is restricted, so is E.V usage.

Electric cars could be banned from making non-essential journeys in Switzerland this winter under a COVID-19 lockdown-style plan to deal with potential energy shortages.
Emergency proposals have been drafted by the government that could see buildings heated to no more than 20C, shop opening hours reduced and streaming services limited.
 
Same thing happens to petrol cars during oil shocks during wars, Australia and most of the western world has had Petrol rationing at multiple times.

The great thing with electricity is you can make your own, not many households can easily refine their own oil.

Also, not only can households make their own electricity, but obviously nations can make their own, so although the initial shock of russian energy being turned off is painful, the nations effected will wean them selves from that supplier and in the future the geopolitical energy problems will be less.
 
I think those truckers that love their diesels, will soon be convinced when they are sitting at 30km an hour chugging up an incline, and Tesla’s are charging past at 100km per hour not missing a beat on the incline.

I had a conversation will my brother in-law who is a trucker, over the week end about the Tesla semi. He told me he could never be convinced to drive an electric, but I showed him that footage of the Tesla vs the diesel on the incline and he literally had his jaw drop.

While I am guessing he will still have a sentimental attachment to the old diesels, but the end of that Tesla event video he seemed pretty convinced that they will be very hard to compete with.

———————
When it comes to charging, they won’t have to be charging at the full 1MW/hour speeds all the time.

Truckers need to sleep too, so a lot of their charging can be done at slower speeds, while the trucker is either sleeping or away from the truck at a depot or truck stop.

800kms is about 8 hours of driving, so if the truck was full at the start of the day via an over night or 5 hour type slow charge, the driver would have a full days driving ahead of him with only needing to charge towards the end, after 8 hours they are probably going to want (or be forced by law) to break for a meal and a rest for at least 30mins to an hour, during which time even a fast charger with 1/4 speed of the stated 1MW could pick up enough charge to get them another 4 hours driving before they stop for their nap, at which time a slower charger could be used again.
 
Last edited:
The great thing with electricity is you can make your own, not many households can easily refine their own oil.

Also, not only can households make their own electricity
I've actually done both.

Electricity generation at home is however somewhat easier, safer and more successful than my attempts to get oil from shale in the backyard. I did manage to get oil from it, but not in an economical manner.

At a national or regional level though well if it gets hot, moves or shines then it can be turned into electricity. Any sort of fuel either fossil or bio, geothermal heat, nuclear energy, solar, wind, hydro, wave, tidal and so on. Between them there's far more options for producing electricity than there are for making petrol certainly.

That aspect alone is a huge benefit of EV's. There's still benefit in them even if 100% of the electricity is sourced from coal. It still has benefits in terms of not needing to import fuel from hostile regions etc.
 
Last edited:

That is one point that most people forget, we can make or own electricity, but we can't make oil or fuel.

We have two vehicles in our family, my partner was averaging $300 per month on the fuel card. Since replacing the Honda Accord Euro with a Tesla M3 we are saving an average of $150 per month by using solar, with the previous 30 days is turning out to be our best savings ever, $68 in power costs.

I challenge anyone to try making those type of savings with a petrol or diesel vehicle and an oil well in the backyard.
 
The real benefit IMO is, if push comes to shove, you can swap out the grid connect inverter, for a stand alone off grid one and charge the car from that if the need eventuates.
Happy days, now where is my tool bag.

 
 

 
If one can believe rhe sales spiel, MIT may have made a lot of existing batteries, whether they be BYD blade or Teslas 4680, somewhat obsolete.
From Some bloke called Will Locket
I guess we will have to wait to see what comes out of the newly licensed giga factories of VW, Lucas TVS and FREYR.
As we say round here, the jury is still out.
Mick
 
You also have the CATYL Qilin blade battery, interesting times, keep an eye on the materials.
Nothing much is changing, just how much you can shove in a box and keep it cool. ?

 
I mentioned that a while back: but probably shut from the many active posters here.things are moving indeed,issue remains of reliance on lithium.i hope for the current buyers that these tech will be backward compatible in rhe form of adaptation kit.
At present time,systems and so whole cars are closely integrated with batteries in the absence of standards so it is not tomorrow your new Tesla battery will not be a Tesla one
 
There is around 80KGS of copper in a Tesla model 3 versus about 63 kg of lithium.
I would be more concerned about Copper than lithium. No matter what material is used in batteries, copper will always be used.
One of the reasons that EV's are moving to ever higher DC voltages is that the higher the voltage , the lower the current to produce the same level of power. Lower current means less thick copper wires and bus bars, meaning less cost and just as important, less weight.
The backward compatibility issues will be solved by non OEM third party business opportunities for replacement batteries.
By the time most EV's need a new battery pack, there will be no warranty left in the vehicle, so third parties will be able to do whatever they can to make it commercially attractive. There will always be a trade in for battery packs - the fact that the batteries only hold say 70% of their original capacity does not mean they will be scrapped.
There is already a steady aftermarket for second hand EV battery packs, some used in original ICE to EV conversoons, some used as residential emergency storage, some will be used in the remote EV /solar charging stations that will eventually pop up. The possibilities are endless.
Mick
 
And one of the reasons I bought the Kona, in five years time the whole E.V space will be completely different IMO, so the Kona will be going to the daughter. She only drives locally so range degradation wont be an issue and cosmetic parts are the same as for an ICE Kona so she should be able to keep it on the road for a relatively cheap cost, as she will never earn a high wage.
Everyone to their own.
 

Sorry, this year has been extremely busy for me, and I think I am suffering from brain fog. Could you please clarify what you are saying and explain the point of it.

I think you said

  1. 'I told everyone about 1000km battery range, and I was shut down for it by forum members that post a lot'
  2. 'Tech is changing, lithium is a problem, backward compatability issues will required adaption kits'
  3. 'EVs have a system that integrates with the battery, and with no standards there will be problems sourcing a battery pack and it may not be a Tesla battery'
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...