This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Electric cars?

Would you buy an electric car?

  • Already own one

    Votes: 10 5.1%
  • Yes - would definitely buy

    Votes: 43 21.7%
  • Yes - preferred over petrol car if price/power/convenience similar

    Votes: 78 39.4%
  • Maybe - preference for neither, only concerned with costs etc

    Votes: 38 19.2%
  • No - prefer petrol car even if electric car has same price, power and convenience

    Votes: 25 12.6%
  • No - would never buy one

    Votes: 14 7.1%

  • Total voters
    198
Just heard that in Norway effective from 2025 people there will only be able to buy & drive an EV & nothing else.
Norway has power(hydro and oil), a strong currency, it might be possible to some workers to afford EV..and that makes sense as they can charge them overnight on hydro power available....
Not exactly our case....?
And i forgot to mention the size of the country??
 
ps: the engineer view best place for EV are small islands: Vanuatu Fidji Norfolk's..small size,fully dependent on oil imports, no repair shops but able to put wind and solar power.ideal..except for road surface and purchasing power.there is a market for an EV Jeep and 200km range at a decent price
 

It seems that Norway are still having EV growing pains, which may be resolved by the time you get there.

"My story may sound a little grim, especially when one compares it to the seamless interoperable experience at any Tesla Supercharger in the world. Fortunately, there is hope for non-Tesla drivers in the form of ISO 15118, otherwise known as Plug and Charge, and it was much discussed at EVS35."

 
@JohnDe and @mullokintyre do yourselves a favour and see the latest Top Gun movie in the cinema, Im not a big movie fan, but if you are into planes, it is un bloodi believable.
I never saw the original, so unlikely to see the latest one.
Stopped watching TV and movies years ago because I hate violence of any sort, real, staged or CGI.
Last film I saw was when I took kids to see Toy story 1.
Can see all the real flying skill I want flying formation with other pilots.
Mick
 
I don't know what all the other "progressive" states are doing, but Victoria has introduced an EV tax.
From RACV

Its a bit rich for the state government to complain about missing out on a tax that they don't even collect, seeing as the excise is a federal one.
I guess then at least the road tax on EV's will be signifcantly lower than the Excise on diesel, petrol or gas.
Yeah right. It will go into consolidated revenue and we will still be left with **** roads and the state government bleating about not getting their fair share of federal funding for major roads programs. And of course, as RV's get more and more numerous, the amount goes up, the requirements for studies will be gone, so the coffers will get filled.
And who is going to check these readings?
Will we have Vicpol pulling over cars and checking the readings of the odometer?


They don't say what level of proof is required. Especially for some ag vehicles that have an hour meter rather than an odometer.
I can see border residents registering their EV's in cross border jurisdictions to evade it.
Mick
 
It looks as though the battery supply issue is starting to bite.
From the article:
SAN FRANCISCO, June 22 (Reuters) - Tesla Inc's (TSLA.O) new car factories in Texas and Berlin are "losing billions of dollars" as they struggle to increase production because of a shortage of batteries and China port issues, Chief Executive Elon Musk said in an interview published on Wednesday.

"Both Berlin and Austin factories are gigantic money furnaces right now. Okay? It's really like a giant roaring sound, which is the sound of money on fire," Musk said in an interview with Tesla Owners of Silicon Valley, an official Tesla-recognized club, in Austin, Texas, on May 31.
Musk said Tesla's Texas factory produces a "tiny" number of cars because of challenges in boosting production of its new "4680" batteries and as tools to make its conventional 2170 batteries are "stuck in port in China." read more "This is all going to get fixed real fast, but it requires a lot of attention," he said.
He said its Berlin factory is in a "slightly better position" because it started with using the traditional 2170 batteries for cars built there.
He said the COVID-19-related shutdowns in Shanghai "were very, very difficult." The shutdown affected car production not only at Tesla's Shanghai factory, but also at its California plant, which uses some vehicle parts made in China, he said. read more

Tesla plans to suspend most production at its Shanghai plant in the first two weeks of July to work on an upgrade of the site to boost output, according to an internal memo seen by Reuters.
 
BYD ATO 3 still doesn't have approval for the ANCAP 5 star crash rating. Sounds like a good reason for customers to ask for a discount.

While the vehicle is expected to pass routine regulatory safety requirements before it can go on sale locally, it is yet to be assessed by the independent safety authority ANCAP (Australasian New Car Assessment Program), which sets a higher safety bar.
Representatives for BYD in Australia say the BYD Atto 3 will launch locally with a five-star safety score.
However, it may initially go on sale "un-rated" until ANCAP completes a series of crash tests and collision-avoidance assessments.
Some car companies complete ANCAP crash tests before a newly introduced vehicle arrives in local showrooms, so they can advertise a five-star score from day one.
And some car companies wait several months after a newly-introduced car has gone on sale locally – due to production or development delays – before a vehicle is submitted to ANCAP tests and issued with a star rating.
 
Shows the versatility of Ev’s doesn’t it, much better than a standard ICE vehicle, because that Tesla can run on both Diesel, Unleaded and also coal, crude oil, natural gas, solar, Wind, Hydro, Nuclear, Bio mass, Land fill methane and many others. ?

Such flexibility in fuel source is going to be increasingly attractive. As we speak we have a beautiful sunny day in Qld and my car is charging directly from my solar panels replacing the 35% of my battery a used last night ? energy independence has long been a dream for people, and It’s finally possible, in fact even though I am charging my car and doing a load of washing, I am still exporting electricity to the grid and earning some tax free $$$.
 
Can't argue that one

The vid I put up in the energy thread talks a bit about that
 
Can't argue that one

The vid I put up in the energy thread talks a bit about that
As i get more technically involved in the EV area, i can not help seing the analogy between EV and Europe energy crisis.
If China takes over Taiwan, Tesla goes bankrupt, EV from Europe have no batteries,and my MG or BYD EV order will be blocked by our governments
How to shoot oneself in the foot.and fxxk oneself all in one go..
Replacing oil dependence by Chinese interest..what can go wrong..do you prefer "persuading" BJ or Venezuela/Koweït ?
 
I see a future for electric....
Now we are talking.
We shall see in 2024, allegedly....
 

Attachments

  • renault-5-2.jpg
    87.2 KB · Views: 7
I see a future for electric....
Now we are talking.
We shall see in 2024, allegedly....

Agreed, unless someone comes up with a non-polluting petrol/diesels alternative that is dirt cheap to produce, sell, and can distribute huge quantities across the globe in less than 5 years. I strongly doubt that any such fuel is coming.

The headline grabbers will learn that soon enough, read more than one article before jumping.

 
The EV charging trials, that have been going on over the last year or two, are starting to get useful data.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-06...ic-car-increase-demand-origin-arena/101156686
From the article:
Electric cars could increase demand on the power grid during the evening peak by at least 30 per cent unless households adopt smart charging, a new trial shows.
"At the moment our electricity grid is not coping at all," she said.

"If we were to add another 30 per cent of peak load to the grid during those periods of high prices and constraints on the network, this would require significant investment to increase capacity."

To manage the looming threat, Origin and ARENA have been trialling "smart charging", with results published yesterday.

Smart chargers, costing between $2,000 and $3,000, were installed in homes of 150 EV users and baseline data was captured.
It found that without intervention, 30 per cent of charging was done in the evening peak, between 3pm and 9pm.
Trial one saw participants given a 10-cent-per-kilowatt-hour credit on their electricity bill for charging off-peak.

That reward reduced charging in the evening peak to 10 per cent, or a 67 per cent decrease from the baseline.

Trial two saw Origin take the reins of charging times to limit it to mostly off-peak through a "plug-in and forget" method.

They could even nimbly respond to "critical peak events", as seen early last week, to switch off any charging.

This method reduced the evening peak usage to only 6 per cent, or an 80 per cent decrease from the baseline.
Despite the incentives leading to significant behavioural change, EV drivers still charged in the evening peak between 6 and 10 per cent of the time.

"If that 6 per cent is all located in one network patch, then that will have a magnified impact on that local substation or the local connection," Mrs Le said.
Mrs Le said the third part of the trial, which is ongoing, would see Origin work with power distributors (Citipower, Powercor and United Energy) to understand if the grid would need to be upgraded to meet the baseline usage seen in the trials, once mass adoption of EVs takes place.
Mrs Le pointed to research that showed that if EVs made up 80 per cent of new car sales by 2030, and all were plugged in the evening peak, the instantaneous load would double peak electricity demand.
The final paper of the trials is due in December, but Mrs Le said early results demonstrated that financial rewards worked to get drivers to charge off-peak.
 
And obviously,if you need to go for a long trip tomorrow morning,you can not wait past the peak to charge and need that 7h full charge...more or less the standard full charge from empty .
So it should not be acceptable to be forced off without overriding option.
 
What may happen to cover that scenario, may be you will have to go to a paid charge point e.g a fuel station that has E.V charging. They may be required to have generator backup, there is one thing for sure, certain areas will face the issue, as weaknesses in the LV(low voltage) distribution system are highlighted by the increased demand.
They wont all be able to be sorted at once, so a stop gap fix will be required, it will all depend on how fast the uptake of EV's is and how concentrated the uptake is.
These issues are what a lot of people don't understand, not only are we trying to replace the power stations at the front end of the H.V(high voltage) system, we are also changing the demand and strain on the LV side of the system, the issues can't be fixed with a magic wand.
IMO it will take a lot of manhours and money before this is bedded down.
 

I almost signed up for one of those trials, it was through AGL. They offered me a free EV charging system and free installation, but my solar feed-in tariff rate would have dropped to $0.05. I wasn't happy with that, since I have one of the highest because I was an early adopter.

The free system was a nice incentive but having the Tesla charge overnight with the supplied adapter has not been a problem. Yes it takes longer than the system that they would have supplied, however, that is not a problem because I plug in 3 or 4 times a week.

Charging an EV using the home 10A plug is similar to having a fridge or freezer on. Whereas a fast charger is similar to a large ducted reverse cycle air conditioner.

I set up the Tesla to charge between about 10pm to 6 am.

My next purchase will be the Tesla home battery system. It is independent of the grid, so no black outs, charges from the solar and tops up from the grid if required and off peak, if things get dire it can use the power from the EV. I'm looking forward to when supply catches up to demand.
 
Smart chargers are obviously a great idea, however I think even just communicating with EV owners and asking them to set their cars to charge at midnight would be a good start.

In the 3 years I have owned my car the power company has never contacted me or send an communication at all informing me about the need to charge my car during lower demand times, So the majority of Ev owners probably don’t even know it’s a problem.

Of course I understand it due to my own research and discussions here, but the average Joe wouldn’t.

Also, smart chargers controlled by the power company are going to be a great asset allowing the power company to time charging with periods of rock bottom power pricing, so I think it shouldn’t be 100% the cost of the ev owner, either the chargers should be subsidised by the power company, or the low rates past along to those people that invest in smart chargers.
 
The 10amp charger is more like running a heater or boiling a kettle than it is running a fridge.

It pulls about 2000 watts/H where as a fridge uses about, 50watts so charging the Tesla is like running 40 fridges.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...