This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

The Top of the market is Looming?

I see that CommSec has announced on 3 August that limits on trades without a cash deposit will be reduced from 4 September 2021.



Details aside, I do see it as potentially of relevance that the country's largest broker (at least they claim to be) is tightening up on risk management (from their own perspective) at this point in time.

My thinking isn't so much about what they're doing, the idea of requiring that someone actually has the $ to pay for the stocks they're buying doesn't seen an unreasonable concept to me, but it's more about what triggered the decision? What information do they have or what conclusions have they come to which lead them to take this action?
 
One of the advantagese of commsec is that you can have $0 cash left and put orders saying
Sell $7k of BHP and buy $7k of CSL at open tomorrow morning.
Bell Direct does not allow this.
If this restriction is happening as i understand it, systems traders might be impacted.. Mr Skate? @Skate
My solution is twisted: i have a small buffer and on big trading days, i have to be on the screens at open time, only pre order the buys from the start of the alphabet while waiting for the sell of the first batches to be completed and free the cash for the end of the alphabet buys...
A pain..i am not aware of these restrictions but could just have missed them
 
A pain..i am not aware of these restrictions but could just have missed them
The details are on the CommSec site so worth looking for those who need to know.

I haven't studied the detail but it does say something to the effect that shares you already own are counted. Worth reading it carefully for those who need to know.

What intrigues me more however is the "why now?" question.
 
I'm sure that this new restriction by CommSec is due to the need for cost savings by them, as I'm sure that removal of the forum was for the same reason.

As far as I am aware, no other retail broker allows trading unless funds are already in a cash account. CommSec, with the piddly little $5,000 for 10 stocks, and $1,000 for everything else, is still the exception to the rule.

KH
 
an interesting decision by Commsec

brought in about the time i MIGHT have increased buying activity ( during a crash )

but yes Bell Direct requires the cash in the holding account before you can place a buy order but offsets that by a better brokerage structure for buys over $1,000

and for really big buys i still have that account for the full service broker ( at a straight percentage system )

is Commsec preparing for the big meltdown ??
 
CommSec/Commonwealth Bank of Australia reserves the right to vary the above list of securities at any time without notice and at its total discretion. CommSec/Commonwealth Bank of Australia or any member of the Group does not make any recommendations (express or implied) about any securities listed above or give any guarantee as to the payment of income or repayment of capital. This list has been prepared without taking account of the objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular individual. For this reason any individual should, before acting on the information, consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to the individual’s objectives, financial situation and needs and, if necessary, seek professional advice. CommSec/Commonwealth Bank of Australia do not accept any liability for losses resulting from a reliance on this information.


and what an interesting list

in the event of a major meltdown only BHP and MQG MIGHT be targets of my buying spree ( that appear on that list )

looks like Bell Direct ( i hold BFG ) just got a free kick
 
Chamath Palihapitiya... He pops up from time to time when I'm researching various investments. He sells an almost perfect "American Dream" story: a son of immigrants who lived in poverty was abused as a child by an alcohol father and then made it big in Silicon Valley... Surprised he's not been referenced here more often (probably a good thing). In Australia we have those who always seem to make money off losing junior miners. In the US they have those who always seem to make money off losing tech.

To my knowledge (which is really Wikipedia's knowledge?) he's been involved with 4 companies listing. Virgin Galactic, Opendoor (online realestate), clover health (health insurance), and sofi (share trading/personal finance). Chart below. sofi is the only thing which has not completely collapsed, and sofi's loanbook... I certainly wouldn't want to be investing in a company which has 90% of its loans listed as 'student' and 'personal' especially since most are assuming the US economy is going to struggle for the next 12 months (if not longer)




 
I'm sure he invested in Tesla and sold at the heights last year. I watch a lot of his youtube stuff as he has some interesting insights.
 
I can hear the last gasps of the equities market bull and believe that the top of the market is just about in. The recent bullish gold and silver price has confirmed this view for me. I don't think that there is any more bullish fuel left and as the real state of the US economy comes into sharp focus I think the real selling will begin and the bears will take control of the market.

High interest rates, sticky inflation, an unprecedented amount of public and private debt that is increasing at unsustainable levels, commercial and residential property markets in decline, retail spending in the toilet and personal and business insolvencies on the increase.

Western Europe, the UK and Australia are in a similar economic position. China is looking very shaky and there is war and heightened geopolitical tensions around the world.

The short to medium term economic future looks grim.
 
it seems the funny money is chasing the stories, rather than the results.. probably based on lower interest rates


The short to medium term economic future looks grim
... lots of headwinds
 
it seems the funny money is chasing the stories, rather than the results.. probably based on lower interest rates

View attachment 177244

... lots of headwinds
Lots out there chasing the narrative of rate cuts but barely a Financial Professional under 40 has lived in a true rate cut cycle and it's a careful what you wish for scenario . The " pivot " crew is convinced rate cuts fuel a super bull , not much precedent supporting this view . A 40yr downtrend in Bond Yields has been broken . A paradigm shift that many are failing to recognize leave alone grasp . Timing market tops is much harder than lows . Tops are a process whereas lows are an " event " . Price is king , follow price , it's dynamic . Day/short term traders are going to be the kings of alpha once the top is finally printed . If/when a bear starts it's going to be a slow motion one to begin with . DYOR and good luck to all

Edit ....... Competent Day/short term traders are always the kings of alpha anyway but moreso in secular bears
 
Last edited:
During 1966 the Us10y broke 5% for the first time in decades , go check SP500 returns from '66 to '83 . 1983 is the year the Us10Y uptrend broke . Illuminating to say the least , they say this time is different but is it ever really that different ?
 

Buffett Calls The Top: Berkshire Dumps 100 Million Apple Shares As Unprecedented Selling Spree Boosts Cash To Record $325 Billion Dollars | ZeroHedge

ZeroHedge - On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero
www.zerohedge.com

the ZeroHedge version

the problem for me is , if i sell down a lot , where do you park it

several stocks i would like to buy would need to drop more than 60% to be attractive

betting on a 60% plus plummet ( in the stocks you want ) is a bit of a gamble , when the market goes crazy over a 40% drop ( and the government is liable to step in and 'pick winners ' aka loans/grants/contracts )
 

How the stock market is likely to react to the election outcome

Published Tue, Oct 29 2024 CNBC
 
Yeah, not much worse than being priced out of the market when you need to get back in but if you need to preserve capital it's your only choice.

When you keep seeing market indexes break record highs you always wonder where and when the breaking point will be.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...