- Joined
- 2 May 2007
- Posts
- 4,737
- Reactions
- 2,992
The activities of other industry insiders like bullion banks don't alter the solid 36-year track record of extreme values in the commercial net short positions in gold for predicting the future direction of the gold price. In gold this indicator, while not infallible, is more reliable than in any other commodity or currency. Here is an article by a credible COT skeptic on the subject.. http://www.bearmarketcentral.com/COT.htm I'm open to all lines of argument but I've not yet heard a convincing one that it's different this time and the COT should be entirely ignored..
A large commercial short position like we have now indicates a high probability of a pullback in the gold price, typically the larger the short position, the deeper and harder the correction. Cheers Barrett
Some extract from Kaplan's newsletter probbaly suggesting gold is going to be bearish!
"This is update #541 for Friday evening, January 4, 2008.
Historically, the U.S. dollar usually rises substantially during any global economic slowdown as it becomes a perceived safe haven from declining equities and commodities. This process has been slow to develop in recent months, since there remains a foolish but very popular myth that the rest of the world will somehow continue to enjoy double-digit growth even with the U.S. economy heading into likely recession within a few months. As this fairy tale is inevitably smashed, the U.S. dollar index will respond by rallying for most or all of 2008.
Hi Miner,
Kaplan has been basically bearish for the whole PM bull-run since 2001, he is a perenial top-caller, there has never been a $10 rally in gold without him screaming for a top, all the way to an interim top, often leaving those who listened, on the sidelines for the whole rally. Like many, he conversely never calls bottoms or advises his readers whole-heartedly to get into PMs. Sorry to say this but he a shill for TPTB. I'm not saying this to have a go, but just for your sake, so that you don't miss all the gains to be had in gold. There are plenty of decent writers with a grasp of what is going on, take a look at them.
Things have changed with the US dollar, this not like before. Its just broken 34year support levels in the last few months to all time lows and has a long way to go. The idea of a US recession is only just begining to gain traction, and that will send the USdollar much lower. They have to fund a nearly $3b a day Current Account deficit mainly with bond sales to other CBs, who are now trying to diversify out of the USD.
Thanks Refined Silver.
I did not know about Kaplan. I came to know about him only through this forum. Then I found to be available to respond my mails.
I will take your comments on board.
Regards
Oy, gold bugs!
I was just wondering how you true-believers expose yourselves to gold? Do you go for traded stocks that represent physical gold, or mining companies?
Know of any goldies paying half decent dividends? As I only want dividend paying stocks at the moment. I'm currently leaning towards NEM, but need to do further research on their assets.
Kaplan has been basically bearish for the whole PM bull-run since 2001 ...
Like many, he conversely never calls bottoms or advises his readers whole-heartedly to get into PMs.
You’re exaggerating here but I’ll grant you his record on calling tops is not as good as bottoms. He has called two interim tops almost to the day, but most notably he called the top too early in late 2006, as many gold timers did. Personally as a believer in this gold bull market, selling is not an option. If Kaplan can get me in at the best possible times, I’m happy., he is a perenial top-caller, there has never been a $10 rally in gold without him screaming for a top, all the way to an interim top, often leaving those who listened, on the sidelines for the whole rally.
I'm not saying this to have a go, but just for your sake, so that you don't miss all the gains to be had in gold.
Can you recommend one with a better track record than Kaplan for picking interim bottoms?There are plenty of decent writers with a grasp of what is going on, take a look at them.
Some extract from Kaplan's newsletter probbaly suggesting gold is going to be bearish!
Let's not forget Jan 9th sees the Shanghai exchange start trading gold futures , the reported 300 g contract is actually a 1000g contract , said to have been risen to discourage individual investors ..........
Prediction: 2008 gold price high of $1088?
Mineweb readers to date are looking, on average, for a gold price high of $1088.6 in 2008. Last year they got within 1% of the closing LBMA figure. Enter this year’s gold price prediction competition now.
Author: Lawrence Williams
Posted: Monday , 07 Jan 2008
LONDON -
The first twenty entries for this year's Mineweb Readers' Gold Price prediction competition are in and the average estimate to date is for a High of $1088.60, a Low of $783.35, a year end figure of $1022.90 and an average price for the year of $904.80.
http://www.mineweb.com/mineweb/view/mineweb/en/page34?oid=43779&sn=Detail
Does Kaplan have any credibility? Let’s have a look at his track record.
Kaplan correctly picked all three major interim bottoms in this bull market 2002- July 2007 and advised subscribers that "the bottom is in" or “buy” or “buy aggressively” on each occasion. Nearly as importantly, he has advised not to buy at all of the less opportune times. As a long term buy-and-hold gold investor I don’t know of any other service with this track record.
Can you recommend one with a better track record than Kaplan for picking interim bottoms?
Cheers
B
” He has picked all three major bottoms very precisely since 2002, and picked two of the four major tops very precisely:
(no articles available pre 2002)
Called the major top exactly on May 29 2002:
http://truecontrarian.com/02_05_29.htm
Called the subsequent major bottom exactly in March 2003
http://truecontrarian.com/03_03_13.htm
“My current outlook for gold mining shares has improved once again, and is now STRONGLY BULLISH”
Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_05_23.htm
Called the subsequent exact major top in November 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_11_14.htm
Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2005:
"CONTINUE TO CONSISTENTLY AND VERY AGGRESSIVELY PURCHASE GOLD MINING SHARES (May 2, 2005): "
http://truecontrarian.com/05_05_02.htm
Early December 2005 saw a repeat of the July 2003 mistake of calling a top midway through the bull run, at the false top. Many other commentators like Frank Barbera were also calling a top at the time, and yet the bull run continued with a further 45% in the XAU through to the peak in May 06.
Truecontrarian has been consistently bearish on the gold equities since then, though recognising that gold is one of the most undervalued assets and remains in a long-term 10-15 year bull market.
So he has consistently called three major bottoms in this bull market, each one almost to the day. “
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?