Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Gold Price - Where is it heading?

Some extract from Kaplan's newsletter probbaly suggesting gold is going to be bearish!

"This is update #541 for Friday evening, January 4, 2008.



The U.S. dollar index fell sharply after the U.S. unemployment report was initially announced, but it later recovered more than 3/4 of its losses to officially settle modestly lower. Then, after the official settlement time, it continued to move higher in the late afternoon and early evening, so that the U.S. dollar index closed trading with a small net gain on the day. (Many futures contracts settle one or more hours before the stock market closes for the day.)

Historically, the U.S. dollar usually rises substantially during any global economic slowdown as it becomes a perceived safe haven from declining equities and commodities. This process has been slow to develop in recent months, since there remains a foolish but very popular myth that the rest of the world will somehow continue to enjoy double-digit growth even with the U.S. economy heading into likely recession within a few months. As this fairy tale is inevitably smashed, the U.S. dollar index will respond by rallying for most or all of 2008.

The traders’ commitments for all commodity-based currencies, including the Canadian, Australian, and New Zealand dollars, deteriorated during the past week.

In general, the pathetic recent performance of these currencies, which usually surge energetically whenever commodities are rallying, probably indicates that the January 2-3, 2008 upward spike in commodities was a two-day fluke rather than the beginning of a sustainable trend.

Today, all of the above currencies gave up several trading days’ worth of gains in a single session. If the U.S. dollar index had been based solely upon these currencies, it would have enjoyed a powerful net gain in today’s trading.

The U.S. unemployment report showed various non-cheerful data such as only 18 thousand new jobs being created in December 2007, the unemployment rate rising from 4.7% to 5.0%, wages rising 0.4% in the past month and 3.7% year-over-year, etc.

Commodities and their shares were mostly lower. HUI, the Amex Index of Unhedged Gold Mining Shares, fell to an early morning low of 439.35 before closing down 5.56 at 443.75. GDX slid to a mid-morning bottom of 49.28 before closing down 84 cents at 49.90.
Gold’s traders’ commitments saw commercials adding 16,881 contracts to their already oversized net short position, thereby yielding a total net short position of 238,412. This is notably bearish. It should be kept in mind that the traders’ commitments are not a short-term timing tool; they don’t tell you when the price is going to move, but they let you know that once it begins to go in the direction that the commercials favor””in this case, lower””how many speculators’ stop-loss orders will be triggered on the way to its final extreme. Therefore, you can tell pretty accurately how far gold will plunge, once its move gets underway in earnest. In this case, the final low for gold bullion is likely to be modestly below $700 per troy ounce, perhaps in the spring.
Silver’s traders’ commitments also noticeably worsened, with commercials adding 4,079 to their net shorts to yield a total net short position of 56,498 contracts.

The traders’ commitments for crude oil showed commercials increasing their net short position by 34,382 contracts to a total net short position of 85,087 contracts. This is a somewhat bearish development. The traders’ commitments for crude oil do not have nearly as powerful a predictive ability as they do for gold, silver, or U.S. Treasuries.

The XAU/spot ratio is equal to 186.23/860.25 or .2165. Wait patiently for this ratio to go below .19 before purchasing your favorite gold mining shares and funds including GDX."


Always do your own research (DYOR)
 
One more extract probably saying gold is going North!

"

Friday, January 04, 2008
Be on Guard With Silver and Gold for a Sudden Correction
Gold Price Close Today : 863.10
Gold Price Close December 28th : 839.60
Change: 23.50 or 2.8%

Silver Price Close Today : 15.346
Silver Price Close December 28th: 14.77
Change: 57.6 cents or 3.9%

US Dollar Index Today: 75.919


Be on guard with silver & gold for a sudden correction. Both have put in astounding performances this week, but be on guard anyway. Over the next 8 weeks or so gold ought to rally to at least $1,000 & on a spike might reach $1,200. Silver needs a swift kick to get going, although this week it hasn't danced badly. Still, this stage in a gold rally (halfway) is when silver usually begins to outpace gold.

I fear 2008 will be a tougher year for reading markets than 2007 was -- mercy. And full of bad surprises for those in stocks & real estate. Dollar will rally in the second quarter, but it won't hurt silver & gold much, as presently gold has broken out upside against the Euro (that ridiculous Frankenstein currency with more holes, scars, and stitching than the ridiculous dollar) and has almost broken out against the Yen, another preposterous fiat currency backed by -- nothing!

What does that mean? That gold, the master alternative currency, is rallying against all sorry unbacked fiat central bank currencies. Defend yourself this year by getting as liquid as possible, paying down all debt, & fleeing from stocks and central bank currencies into silver & gold. Brace yourselves for a turbulent year!

Let loose the dogs of collapse & rally!

Stocks have performed wretchedly, miserably this week. They opened the year lower. Great start. Today the Dow closed below its August low (12,846) and 1.14 points above its November low (12,799.04), the lowest price since August. What do you call a series of lower highs and lower lows? Right, a downtrend. And the poor S&P500 closed a bare 11 points above 1400 and infamy.

Against gold the Dow reached a new low in this bear market that began in August 1999: G$306.57 (14.830 oz). The Dow in Gold Dollars is also signaling like a Confederate semaphore corporal that stocks are fixing to drop much, much more against gold. Against silver the Dow sank today to 834.11 oz, down over 67% from its June 2001 high at 2,566 oz. Please, while there's still time, swap stocks for silver & gold.

The feckless US DOLLAR INDEX is behaving like a banana-republic currency trying to rally. Oh, it probably will rally later this year, but first it must torture all the onlookers. Flee all dollar paying assets while you still have time: bank deposits, certificates of deposit, bonds, annuities, pensions. The buzzards who run the US monetary system -- no, vampires is the more precise word -- are bleeding y'all dry, yet y'all sit still for it. Why?

- Franklin Sanders, The Moneychanger"
 
The activities of other industry insiders like bullion banks don't alter the solid 36-year track record of extreme values in the commercial net short positions in gold for predicting the future direction of the gold price. In gold this indicator, while not infallible, is more reliable than in any other commodity or currency. Here is an article by a credible COT skeptic on the subject.. http://www.bearmarketcentral.com/COT.htm I'm open to all lines of argument but I've not yet heard a convincing one that it's different this time and the COT should be entirely ignored..

A large commercial short position like we have now indicates a high probability of a pullback in the gold price, typically the larger the short position, the deeper and harder the correction. Cheers Barrett

Hi Barrett,

I'll post a couple of articles on the COT situation and previous Commercial failures when i dig them out.

Cheers
 
Some extract from Kaplan's newsletter probbaly suggesting gold is going to be bearish!

"This is update #541 for Friday evening, January 4, 2008.

Historically, the U.S. dollar usually rises substantially during any global economic slowdown as it becomes a perceived safe haven from declining equities and commodities. This process has been slow to develop in recent months, since there remains a foolish but very popular myth that the rest of the world will somehow continue to enjoy double-digit growth even with the U.S. economy heading into likely recession within a few months. As this fairy tale is inevitably smashed, the U.S. dollar index will respond by rallying for most or all of 2008.

Hi Miner,

Kaplan has been basically bearish for the whole PM bull-run since 2001, he is a perenial top-caller, there has never been a $10 rally in gold without him screaming for a top, all the way to an interim top, often leaving those who listened, on the sidelines for the whole rally. Like many, he conversely never calls bottoms or advises his readers whole-heartedly to get into PMs. Sorry to say this but he a shill for TPTB. I'm not saying this to have a go, but just for your sake, so that you don't miss all the gains to be had in gold. There are plenty of decent writers with a grasp of what is going on, take a look at them.

Things have changed with the US dollar, this not like before. Its just broken 34year support levels in the last few months to all time lows and has a long way to go. The idea of a US recession is only just begining to gain traction, and that will send the USdollar much lower. They have to fund a nearly $3b a day Current Account deficit mainly with bond sales to other CBs, who are now trying to diversify out of the USD.
 
Hi Miner,

Kaplan has been basically bearish for the whole PM bull-run since 2001, he is a perenial top-caller, there has never been a $10 rally in gold without him screaming for a top, all the way to an interim top, often leaving those who listened, on the sidelines for the whole rally. Like many, he conversely never calls bottoms or advises his readers whole-heartedly to get into PMs. Sorry to say this but he a shill for TPTB. I'm not saying this to have a go, but just for your sake, so that you don't miss all the gains to be had in gold. There are plenty of decent writers with a grasp of what is going on, take a look at them.

Things have changed with the US dollar, this not like before. Its just broken 34year support levels in the last few months to all time lows and has a long way to go. The idea of a US recession is only just begining to gain traction, and that will send the USdollar much lower. They have to fund a nearly $3b a day Current Account deficit mainly with bond sales to other CBs, who are now trying to diversify out of the USD.

Thanks Refined Silver.
I did not know about Kaplan. I came to know about him only through this forum. Then I found to be available to respond my mails.
I will take your comments on board.

Regards
 
I check out the Ade Sisters occasionally and todays read is a good roundup of the current situation, if you are bullish

Quote: ''

Jan 3 2008 11:28AM

Mega Move Underway, Stay With It

Courtesy of www.adenforecast.com

As we enter 2008, gold is hitting a new record high. That’s a great way to kick off the new year and it looks like there’s a lot more to come. Why?

This commodity upmove is over six years old, yet it’s still young and it’ll likely last another decade before it’s over. The falling dollar has certainly given the commodities a boost and there’s really no reason why the dollar will strengthen next year, which is a positive sign for the commodities. ...''

as there are a number of charts within the article follow the link above for the full story
 
So, I'm curious, who thinks given the weak US employment data, fears of US recession, very likely fall of 0.5% in rates in the US, lower US dollar, etc that gold prices are only going up in the lead up to the FOMC meeting late January? Anyone else willing to buy gold, or gold stocks, in the lead up? More worried about oil falling lower on the US recession news and pushing down gold too? Anyone got any opinions?
 
Oy, gold bugs!

I was just wondering how you true-believers expose yourselves to gold? Do you go for traded stocks that represent physical gold, or mining companies?

Know of any goldies paying half decent dividends? As I only want dividend paying stocks at the moment. I'm currently leaning towards NEM, but need to do further research on their assets.


Nyden, my strategy is to keep ~60% of my portfolio, 120% of my net worth, in bullion and gold stocks at all times, I don't trade or sell them. It's mostly in the stocks, because their leverage is on average over time, 3:1 to the gold price. A gold equities fund is another option.. Fat Prophets like the Merrill Lynch one (Blackrock International gold fund I think it's called). There was an ASF thread a few months ago on buying and storing physical gold you might find useful. GOLD on the ASX is backed by physical bullion but I don't know who runs it.

I keep about 10% of my portfolio cash in a futures account which allows up to 20:1 leverage into gold. All I do is try to accumulate as many contracts as early as possible in each major (6-month) run, at max leverage. My timing was bad in 07 but the performance is still comparable to all the stocks and bullion. I find using the highest leverage makes timing the buys stressful and time-consuming. You can choose anything from 20:1 down to 1:1 leverage - choose your stress level :D The smallest gold contract is $20K though.

As Jim Rogers has said, it it is surprising that more people don't invest directly in commodities using the futures market. Futures are straightforward if you get a book on them (Donna Kline's Fundamentals of the Futures Market is decent). And transactions can be done in about twenty seconds, 24 hours a day. At $12 per $100K gold bought or sold, I think this brokerage is damn good value compared to stocks or paying big dealer margins/storage when you buy physical gold and especially silver.

Others know more than me about the risks of 'paper gold', certainly having it in a bank vault is more secure and I have some stored that way, but I'm willing to take a risk that the futures market will not collapse at this stage. When it turns into a mania I will redirect more into vault bullion since counterparty risk etc. will that much greater.

On the miners, none I know of pay any substantial dividend at the moment other than TRY.
Base metals are up 3-400%, good base metal miners are paying huge dividends.
When gold does the same, so will the gold miners.
My advice would be to concentrate on those with the biggest potential for quickly increasing cash flow/market cap and you should get your dividend in due course. LGL's a good example, cash costs declining, production increasing. Give it a year or two with a much higher gold price and barring a catastrophe they will be swimming in cash like Zinifex was last year and they'll need to do something with it. Probably give back to shareholders in large amounts as many gold producers did in the late 70s.

NEM gives no dividend yield to speak of at the moment but the potential is there, the dividend should rise.. that's if their cash costs didn't rise faster than the gold price again this quarter :p: If you have a long term time horizon I would also strongly recommend LGL and to a lesser extent NEM. In the midcaps RSG and OGD are some favourites of mine on ASX but my holdings are mostly Canadian-listed because of the limited choice on ASX particularly in silver miners.

good luck with your gold investments
barrett
 
Silver..
I subscribe to Kaplan, and he’s kept subscribers out of the market since August 07, that’s true. He insists that the gold price will experience a sharp correction, and that a similar buying opportunity to August 07 will appear around May-June 08. Does Kaplan have any credibility? Let’s have a look at his track record.

Kaplan has been basically bearish for the whole PM bull-run since 2001 ...
Like many, he conversely never calls bottoms or advises his readers whole-heartedly to get into PMs.

Kaplan correctly picked all three major interim bottoms in this bull market 2002- July 2007 and advised subscribers that "the bottom is in" or “buy” or “buy aggressively” on each occasion. Nearly as importantly, he has advised not to buy at all of the less opportune times. As a long term buy-and-hold gold investor I don’t know of any other service with this track record. For those interested I have pasted in at the bottom the notes I made in July 07 when I subscribed, re his track record. These have links to what he wrote in the open access web pages at each call.


, he is a perenial top-caller, there has never been a $10 rally in gold without him screaming for a top, all the way to an interim top, often leaving those who listened, on the sidelines for the whole rally.
You’re exaggerating here but I’ll grant you his record on calling tops is not as good as bottoms. He has called two interim tops almost to the day, but most notably he called the top too early in late 2006, as many gold timers did. Personally as a believer in this gold bull market, selling is not an option. If Kaplan can get me in at the best possible times, I’m happy.

I'm not saying this to have a go, but just for your sake, so that you don't miss all the gains to be had in gold.

I agree – don’t let Kaplan discourage you from buying gold. And in my opinion, do not let anyone convince you to sell. We are in the early stages and the people buying and holding now will be long-term winners. Kaplan is just very fussy about trying to work out the very best buy times. Since I already hold a lot of gold stocks that's what I want.

There are plenty of decent writers with a grasp of what is going on, take a look at them.
Can you recommend one with a better track record than Kaplan for picking interim bottoms?
Cheers
B

My personal notes on Kaplan's newsletter for anyone interested please note they were made in July 07:

” He has picked all three major bottoms very precisely since 2002, and picked two of the four major tops very precisely:

(no articles available pre 2002)

Called the major top exactly on May 29 2002:
http://truecontrarian.com/02_05_29.htm

Called the subsequent major bottom exactly in March 2003
http://truecontrarian.com/03_03_13.htm
“My current outlook for gold mining shares has improved once again, and is now STRONGLY BULLISH”

Went incorrectly 'modestly bearish' on gold stocks in July 2003 - strong rally of a further 30% in the XAU occurred until end of November 2003. To his credit, he did not capitulate and try and buy back in at the top as I have seen other newsletters do.

Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_05_23.htm

Called the subsequent exact major top in November 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_11_14.htm

Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2005:
"CONTINUE TO CONSISTENTLY AND VERY AGGRESSIVELY PURCHASE GOLD MINING SHARES (May 2, 2005): "
http://truecontrarian.com/05_05_02.htm

Early December 2005 saw a repeat of the July 2003 mistake of calling a top midway through the bull run, at the false top. Many other commentators like Frank Barbera were also calling a top at the time, and yet the bull run continued with a further 45% in the XAU through to the peak in May 06.

Truecontrarian has been consistently bearish on the gold equities since then, though recognising that gold is one of the most undervalued assets and remains in a long-term 10-15 year bull market.

So he has consistently called three major bottoms in this bull market, each one almost to the day. “
 
Some extract from Kaplan's newsletter probbaly suggesting gold is going to be bearish!

Having defended some of Kaplan's past calls, let me say that I reckon this current rally will make a fool of him for a little longer yet. This wave 5 I am expecting through into February, I expect gold will be in the news as one of the only performing assets. If Kaplan's correction materialises, it would have to wait at least until after that.

Right now aside from the massively bullish long term fundamentals for gold there are the many short-term bullish factors that have been mentioned,

-gold breaking out in multiple currencies (very very bullish)
-gold newsletter sentiment only 66.1% according to Hulbert Gold Newsletter Sentiment Index, as at last Monday - not yet the sort of heavily bullish reading you get at a top.
- the movement of gold opposite the broader market indices

I am hoping to pick up some more comex contracts at around the 840 mark before the next upleg, but I may have to settle for a higher price......
Let's not forget Jan 9th sees the Shanghai exchange start trading gold futures , the reported 300 g contract is actually a 1000g contract , said to have been risen to discourage individual investors .......... :rolleyes:
 
Fwiw Mineweb readers see a fairly modest rise in POG this year after a pretty good estimate/guestimate last year.

How do these numbers stack up against your other forecasts?

Prediction: 2008 gold price high of $1088?
Mineweb readers to date are looking, on average, for a gold price high of $1088.6 in 2008. Last year they got within 1% of the closing LBMA figure. Enter this year’s gold price prediction competition now.

Author: Lawrence Williams
Posted: Monday , 07 Jan 2008

LONDON -

The first twenty entries for this year's Mineweb Readers' Gold Price prediction competition are in and the average estimate to date is for a High of $1088.60, a Low of $783.35, a year end figure of $1022.90 and an average price for the year of $904.80.
http://www.mineweb.com/mineweb/view/mineweb/en/page34?oid=43779&sn=Detail
 
More short term doom and gloom posts and yet gold keeps on with the (overall) up trend of the last 30 days.
 

Attachments

  • nygold.gif
    nygold.gif
    7.5 KB · Views: 110
Does Kaplan have any credibility? Let’s have a look at his track record.

Kaplan correctly picked all three major interim bottoms in this bull market 2002- July 2007 and advised subscribers that "the bottom is in" or “buy” or “buy aggressively” on each occasion. Nearly as importantly, he has advised not to buy at all of the less opportune times. As a long term buy-and-hold gold investor I don’t know of any other service with this track record.

Can you recommend one with a better track record than Kaplan for picking interim bottoms?
Cheers
B

” He has picked all three major bottoms very precisely since 2002, and picked two of the four major tops very precisely:

(no articles available pre 2002)

Called the major top exactly on May 29 2002:
http://truecontrarian.com/02_05_29.htm

Called the subsequent major bottom exactly in March 2003
http://truecontrarian.com/03_03_13.htm
“My current outlook for gold mining shares has improved once again, and is now STRONGLY BULLISH”


Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_05_23.htm

Called the subsequent exact major top in November 2004:
http://truecontrarian.com/04_11_14.htm

Called the exact major bottom for gold mining shares in May 2005:
"CONTINUE TO CONSISTENTLY AND VERY AGGRESSIVELY PURCHASE GOLD MINING SHARES (May 2, 2005): "
http://truecontrarian.com/05_05_02.htm

Early December 2005 saw a repeat of the July 2003 mistake of calling a top midway through the bull run, at the false top. Many other commentators like Frank Barbera were also calling a top at the time, and yet the bull run continued with a further 45% in the XAU through to the peak in May 06.

Truecontrarian has been consistently bearish on the gold equities since then, though recognising that gold is one of the most undervalued assets and remains in a long-term 10-15 year bull market.

So he has consistently called three major bottoms in this bull market, each one almost to the day. “


Hi Barrett,

Firstly congrats on being fully invested and long gold, despite newsletter recomendations to the contrary.

This will most likely be part I of the answer, and relates to Kaplan's record.

Firstly, did he even recognise this a long term bull market in advance? Many writers called $800 gold and a lot higher in 2000 and 2001/2002, they also called each major advance. A bull market is called such, because it bucks off most riders, very very few hold all the way to the top. If Kaplan hasn't got the most basics right, that this a long term bull, all his other calls are useless. (Anyone can say begrugingly admit this is a bull by looking back at the charts, but most will say its over/risky/overbought/bubble-like/speculative etc now) I have copied the below from the links you provided, but as you can see, every single call was bearish until March 2003, that means he missed the first 2.5 years and a five-fold run up in the HUI!!!

(I will post it separately as the post was too long to be accepted)

Secondly, given the his virtual perma-bear status, calling tops every $10 (admittedly an exageration but you get the point), of course he has called most tops, his problem is that he was bearish way before the top, and sometimes even before the rally started.

Thirdly, his bottom picking such as May 2005, - he capitalises "SHORT-TERM rally", what followed was a massive 12 months rally, how many times did he get people out in this time or call tops? (In his May 2002 top call he also advises that gold shares will likely still be lower in 8-9 years!!). You say he called the top early in Dec 05, thus missing over half of the rally, was this his first top call?

Fourthly, his rationale for most calls shows a total lack of understanding of what the prime movers are for this gold bull. Even the technical tools he uses HUI/Au spread, cycles in days, etc, are very poor indicators with very poor records for this 8 bull.

I could go on, but to summarise, his fundamental understanding is non-existent, his TA tools are just plain wrong for this market, in the 5 major (share) rallies of this bull, he was bearish for the whole of the first 2, at best called the top well before half-way in rallies 3 and 4 - thus missing 60-70% of the both rallies, and for the 5th major upleg which we are currently in, he has been on the sidelines the whole time!!!

Like I said, listening to him will ensure no money is made in this gold market. But kudos to you for managing to stay invested, a very brave and courageous effort in the circumstances.
 
From one of the newsletters you posted, this a copy (part 1)of Kaplan's recommendations to that point.
Wednesday, May 29, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and gold mining shares has deteriorated to VERY STRONGLY BEARISH, reflecting incredible speculation in junior money-losing producers, as well as juniors’ share prices far outperforming the seniors, as is typical of a peak in any equity sector group. Insider selling is also more pronounced, as is insider issuance of new shares and other new security offerings by gold producers.

Wednesday, May 29, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has fallen from STRONGLY BEARISH to VERY STRONGLY BEARISH, as commercials are now at or very close to their heaviest short position since February 1996.

Wednesday, May 1, 2002: The insider stock transaction activity indicator for gold has dropped from MODESTLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as the frequency of insider sales and registrations for intended sales by gold mining executives has risen sharply over the past few weeks. Corporate announcements about new secondary share offerings have also suddenly risen over the past several trading days.

Monday, April 8, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator for gold has improved from MODERATELY BEARISH to MODESTLY BEARISH, as the high concentration of call buying on individual gold mining shares has somewhat abated in recent days.

Monday, March 25, 2002: The outlook for gold mining shares has deteriorated to STRONGLY BEARISH, as an enormous concentration of call trading and sparse put trading in individual large-cap gold shares is indicating that a peak in gold share prices is imminent.

Monday, March 25, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator for gold has fallen from MODESTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, also reflecting the speculative fever in gold mining shares in recent trading days.

Monday, March 25, 2002: The gauges of future inflation indicator has improved from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODESTLY BEARISH, as both measures of future inflation’s growth rates have turned noticeably less negative.

Monday, February 11, 2002: The overall outlook for gold, gold collectibles, and gold mining shares has worsened from SLIGHTLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as gold’s price rise to above $300 spot has encouraged recent purchasers who are completely uncommitted to the yellow metal unless it is rising, and who will therefore bail out given even modest unfriendly price behavior. Bearish traders’ commitments and overbought technicals support this view. Also, the first true rally stage of any real bull market needs its corresponding retracement.

Monday, February 11, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has deteriorated from MODESTLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH, as commercials are currently net short about sixty thousand contracts.

Monday, February 11, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator for gold has deteriorated from SLIGHTLY BULLISH to MODESTLY BEARISH, as unusually heavy gold share call buying is probably marking a short-term peak for the yellow metal and its shares.

Monday, December 24, 2001: The overall outlook for gold, gold collectibles, and gold mining shares has risen from MODERATELY BEARISH to SLIGHTLY BEARISH, as the pivot price for gold has risen from $271 to $276 spot, while gold commercials remain highly responsive to modest moves in either direction, and currency commercials are generally short those currencies which correlate significantly with the gold price.

Monday, December 24, 2001: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has improved from MODERATELY BEARISH to MODESTLY BEARISH.

Monday, October 29, 2001: The overall outlook for gold, gold collectibles, and gold mining shares has improved from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as the traders' commitments have noticeably improved, though still show commercials markedly net short.

Monday, October 29, 2001: The traders' commitments indicator for gold has improved from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as commercials are more aggressively covering their short positions on all dips in the gold price.

Tuesday, October 23, 2001: The overall outlook for gold, gold collectibles, and gold mining shares has improved from STRONGLY BEARISH/VERY STRONGLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as the gold price has dropped substantially.

Tuesday, October 23, 2001: The traders' commitments indicator for gold has improved from VERY STRONGLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as commercials grudgingly, but steadily, are covering their net short positions on all price declines. [/I]
 
Part II.

Even though gold stocks bottomed 1 month after the May 2002 top as you can see, Kaplan stayed bearish, advising readers to sell out at lows (those that hadn't done so already), From the low in July 02 to March 03 was choppy but still with an upward trend.


Thursday, March 13, 2003: The overall current outlook for gold mining shares has improved from MODERATELY BULLISH to STRONGLY BULLISH, as the HUI appears to have completed a very bullish double bottom at 112.61 with its November 22, 2002 nadir of 112.66. The overall current outlook for gold itself has improved from SLIGHTLY BULLISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BULLISH, as commercials appear to be have gone exactly net neutral Comex gold futures this morning, thus removing the threat of a serious triggering of stale speculator longs’ sell stops.

Thursday, March 13, 2003: The price/volume statistics indicator has improved from SLIGHTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BULLISH, as the HUI completed a potential strong double bottom at 112.61, gold itself is close to its 200-day moving average, and there was a recent surge in put buying on individual gold mining shares.

Tuesday, March 11, 2003: The overall current outlook for gold mining shares has improved from MODERATELY BEARISH to MODERATELY BULLISH, reflecting their recent sharp price decline. The overall current outlook for gold itself has improved from MODERATELY BEARISH to SLIGHTLY BULLISH, since the above-average spread between HUI and the spot gold price demonstrates that there is a real danger of a final sharp short-term drop in the price of the yellow metal before it is able to rally once again.

Tuesday, March 11, 2003: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has improved from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as commercials have reduced their huge short position by about half over the past five weeks.

Tuesday, March 11, 2003: The price/volume statistics indicator has improved from MODESTLY BEARISH to SLIGHTLY BEARISH. Since HUI broke below its 200-day moving average and collapsed, the risk of its continued decline has been proportionately abated.

Tuesday, February 25, 2003: The overall current outlook for gold and its shares has improved from STRONGLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as gold and its shares have declined substantially, putting us closer to the eventual nadir.

Tuesday, February 25, 2003: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has improved from STRONGLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as commercials have continued to reduce their net short position significantly from its recent 22-year peak of 127,047 net short.

Tuesday, February 25, 2003: The price/volume statistics indicator has declined again from SLIGHTLY BEARISH to MODESTLY BEARISH, as the HUI is about to struggle with its 200-day moving average, and gold itself has a significant amount to drop before testing its own 200-day moving average. The shares are consistently underperforming the metal, and the intraday trading behavior shows gold mining shares repeatedly moving higher in the morning and then lower later in the day. Both of these patterns are bearish for gold and its shares.

Thursday, December 19, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and its shares has dropped from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH. Gold mining shares, especially those of senior producers, continue to underperform the gold price, while investor sentiment has turned euphoric. This is a profoundly bearish combination.

Thursday, December 19, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator has fallen from NEUTRAL to SLIGHTLY BEARISH, as the HUI, which failed to approach its June 4, 2002 peak, is negatively diverging from spot gold, which easily set a new 5-1/2-year high.

Monday, December 16, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and its shares has plummeted from MODESTLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH. Commercials are at an extreme net short position. There is very little put buying on gold mining shares, and lots of call buying. The media has turned bullish on gold. Senior gold shares are far underperforming bullion, while juniors have been surging.

Monday, December 16, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has fallen from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH, as commercials have been aggressively adding to their net short position into all rallies.

Monday, November 11, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and its shares has risen from MODERATELY BEARISH to MODESTLY BEARISH. There is not as much insider selling now as in September when the HUI was in the mid- to upper-130s, and seniors are beginning to outperform relative to juniors, both of which are positive developments. On the negative side, the traders’ commitments for gold are still unencouraging, and the traders’ commitments for currencies which correlate closely with the gold price are at multi-year extremes, indicating the likelihood of a U.S. dollar rally which will likely depress the gold price.

Monday, November 11, 2002: The insider stock transaction activity for gold has improved from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as the intensity of insider selling has noticeably abated, as one would expect given the decline in gold share prices since the middle of September. No important insider buying has yet emerged.

Thursday, September 19, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and its shares has fallen from MODESTLY BULLISH to MODERATELY BEARISH. The pessimism toward gold that was rampant in late July has been replaced by an optimism nearly as pronounced as what was experienced in the spring. Juniors are far outperforming seniors, put buying has all but vanished, and commercials are once again more than 60 thousand contracts net short in COMEX gold futures. I would be more bearish, except that gold share valuations are not as overextended as they were in late May or early June, so they have less to decline in percentage terms.

Thursday, September 19, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has plummeted from NEUTRAL to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as commercials have shown a strong eagerness to heavily re-establish short positions at any price above $315 spot, whereas small speculators are again more than 5:1 net long as they were in late May and early June.

Thursday, September 19, 2002: The insider stock transaction activity for gold has deteriorated from MODERATELY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH, as insider selling by gold mining executives has picked up after a brief interval of insider buying in late July that quickly dried up after share prices rebounded.

Thursday, September 19, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator for gold has worsened from MODESTLY BULLISH to NEUTRAL, as the 200-day moving averages are too far away to be useful as short-term support, while put trading on individual gold mining shares has plummeted, indicating very little fear of a short-term drop in the gold price.

Tuesday, August 6, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and gold mining shares has improved substantially from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to MODESTLY BULLISH, as commercials covered more than half of their net short position, and gold mining shares are not far from completing a bottoming pattern.

Tuesday, August 6, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has improved from STRONGLY BEARISH to NEUTRAL, as commercials heavily covered from July 23 to July 30, and were likely very close to net neutral when gold bottomed at $298 spot on August 1.

Tuesday, August 6, 2002: The price/volume statistics indicator for gold has improved from MODESTLY BEARISH to MODESTLY BULLISH, as both HUI and the gold price itself tested and held above their respective 200-day moving averages on July 26, while the heavy concentration of call trading in gold mining shares seen in the spring has now led to only tentative gold trading, with put trading remaining roughly constant throughout.

Tuesday, August 6, 2002: The gauges of future inflation indicator has improved again from MODESTLY BULLISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BULLISH, as both indices are showing double-digit growth rates.

Wednesday, July 31, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and gold mining shares has improved again from STRONGLY BEARISH to SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH. Given the recent substantial drop in price, there is less of a decline remaining.

Wednesday, July 31, 2002: The insider stock transaction activity for gold has improved from STRONGLY BEARISH to MODERATELY BEARISH, as the recent sharp drop in gold mining share prices has discouraged further selling of these shares by top executives.

Tuesday, July 9, 2002: The insider stock transaction activity for gold has deteriorated from SIGNIFICANTLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH, as the rate of recent insider selling by gold industry executives has exceeded the peak of February 1996, and is now approaching (but has not quite reached) its level from the summer of 1987.

Tuesday, July 9, 2002: The traders’ commitments indicator for gold has improved from VERY STRONGLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH, as commercials are slowly covering their short positions when the gold price declines.

Tuesday, July 9, 2002: The gauges of future inflation indicator has improved from NEUTRAL to MODESTLY BULLISH, as important leading indices of inflation are now showing positive rates of growth.

Tuesday, June 11, 2002: The overall current outlook for gold and gold mining shares has improved from VERY STRONGLY BEARISH to STRONGLY BEARISH, reflecting the recent sharp drop in the price of gold and gold share prices, especially those of money-losing junior gold miners which had fallen over 30%.

Tuesday, June 11, 2002: The gauges of future inflation indicator has improved from MODESTLY BEARISH to NEUTRAL, as important leading indices of inflation have moved from 26-year lows just a few months ago to near neutral today.
 
We'll almost certainly see $1,000 gold in 2008. But, we may have a correction first.

Nothing goes up in a straight line, and the US dollar is due for a counter-trend rally.

But there are good investments to buy, regardless ...

Send me a Private Message for a free report on a ...

Gold Investment That Pays Over 7% Yield While You Wait for the Price to Explode Up.

Or, a ...

Gold Company Immune to Rising Mining Costs
 
Well I dont' know about anyone else or all the pontification and argument of late on this thread. If you like to go back and read the substancial evidence I do not understand how there can be doubters.

The gold price is on a new uptick and it is in new territory, and it is happening now.
 

Attachments

  • gold.gif
    gold.gif
    19.9 KB · Views: 73
Top