Magdoran and here is the crux of this thread. People are interested to see if Gann "honestly, is it a good basis for trading". Its fair enough that someone who has some interest in the method should ask those pimping it to prove that it can actually be applied profitably in the market.
In an honest fashion.
But they don't or can't. Is that honest? Are they being plainly fraudulent claiming something that they don't actually do? We never get the answer to these questions. Just replies that we are beneath your superior understanding.
This is what gives me the right. I helped a trader that came to me after losing a large amount of money by trading his account back to profit in weeks so he could start again with some reasonable cash. After being set out to find his own way he sent an email to me saying he had been following Trader Pauls astro stuff !! I was furious and just plainly gobsmacked!! He was amazed to find that Trader Paul doesn't actually trade and he had wasted MUCH time reading his post following something that clearly the author hasn't the confidence to trade
Thats what gives me the right. I have ACTUALLY traded at least 10 peoples accounts on ASF into Significant profit so they have a basis to start to learn. If I can stop them and other newbies wasting a huge amount of time and good money and effort following a unproven empty method I will put up with arguments with the likes of you.
... well, this self-proclaimed trading guru th, has made these same assertions
previously ..... assertions, that are totally, unfounded ..... !~!
His "client" and th have both obviously been misinformed about my own
trading ... and it would be nice to know, where such misinformation
originated ... certainly, not from anybody who knows me, personally ... !~!
..... NOTHING gives you the right to bad-mouth somebody, that you
do not know, especially, when it's based on fabricated information.
So, maybe it's time for th (or anybody else) to put up the "proof",
where he has established, that i do not trade, period .....
..... (leave off trading for a living) .....
..... show me and everybody else here.
over to you
paul
=====