Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Gann, honestly, is it a good basis for trading?

Jump to new
prawn_86 said:
Also, note how SeekandFind wants to 'start' from 4 months ago. Probably has made some money at the start of this year so thinks he/she will have a head start... :p:
Click to expand...

well noted Prawn --- you'll make a moderator on this site one day with perceptive powers like that !!! ---

What --- your already a Mod !!!! --- Why the hell wasnt i asked --- bludy young upstarts !!! :D :)

Seriously though SeekandFind, you want a competition where you already have a few runs on the board to give you an advantage ??

That being the case I'll only give you evens ---- and i'm still on TH !!!! and i dont know how much in front you are !! :eek:

(if you want to start from scratch, i'll give you 2-1 !!!) ------ 5 grand up (im not a big punter sorry)
 
prawn_86 said:
Also, note how SeekandFind wants to 'start' from 4 months ago. Probably has made some money at the start of this year so thinks he/she will have a head start... :p:
Click to expand...

Prawn well spoted but T/H has said he would like to start now or in a couple of weeks .
Read SeekandFinds first post , I'm very suspicious :bs: notice the phraseology , will apologize if I'm wrong .
 
Prawn,

Are there any legal implications regarding setting up this sort of trader v trader thing on an internet forum?
 
prawn_86 said:
I am happy to 'moderate' this challenge if you guys desire that. I think it would be good to be in the public domain, but understand if you dont want to make $ figures shown.

Also, note how SeekandFind wants to 'start' from 4 months ago. Probably has made some money at the start of this year so thinks he/she will have a head start... :p:
Click to expand...

well spotted....

that's not fair and should not be included.

both should start from0 and go for a agreed a length of time, equal open balance.

let the games begin!
 
Trembling Hand said:
Magdoran and here is the crux of this thread. People are interested to see if Gann "honestly, is it a good basis for trading". Its fair enough that someone who has some interest in the method should ask those pimping it to prove that it can actually be applied profitably in the market.

In an honest fashion.

But they don't or can't. Is that honest? Are they being plainly fraudulent claiming something that they don't actually do? We never get the answer to these questions. Just replies that we are beneath your superior understanding.

This is what gives me the right. I helped a trader that came to me after losing a large amount of money by trading his account back to profit in weeks so he could start again with some reasonable cash. After being set out to find his own way he sent an email to me saying he had been following Trader Pauls astro stuff !! I was furious and just plainly gobsmacked!! He was amazed to find that Trader Paul doesn't actually trade and he had wasted MUCH time reading his post following something that clearly the author hasn't the confidence to trade :eek:

Thats what gives me the right. I have ACTUALLY traded at least 10 peoples accounts on ASF into Significant profit so they have a basis to start to learn. If I can stop them and other newbies wasting a huge amount of time and good money and effort following a unproven empty method I will put up with arguments with the likes of you.
Click to expand...

:)

... well, this self-proclaimed trading guru th, has made these same assertions
previously ..... assertions, that are totally, unfounded ..... !~!

His "client" and th have both obviously been misinformed about my own
trading ... and it would be nice to know, where such misinformation
originated ... certainly, not from anybody who knows me, personally ... !~!

..... NOTHING gives you the right to bad-mouth somebody, that you
do not know, especially, when it's based on fabricated information.

So, maybe it's time for th (or anybody else) to put up the "proof",
where he has established, that i do not trade, period .....
..... (leave off trading for a living) ..... :)

..... show me and everybody else here.

over to you

paul

:)

=====
 
LOL well I will unreservedly apologize if I have been misinformed but it was actually from someone on your side of the fence. I will dig up the PMs tomorrow and forward them.

Of course you could always post up some statements of your great gann trading and prove me wrong.
 
This will be great to see
I'd love to see T/H go from 1k to 50k in a week again :)

He makes trades in the time it takes me to finish eating my weetbix in the morning than i make in a year :eek:

Cheers
Brad
 
Trembling Hand said:
Magdoran and here is the crux of this thread. People are interested to see if Gann "honestly, is it a good basis for trading". Its fair enough that someone who has some interest in the method should ask those pimping it to prove that it can actually be applied profitably in the market.

In an honest fashion.

But they don't or can't. Is that honest? Are they being plainly fraudulent claiming something that they don't actually do? We never get the answer to these questions. Just replies that we are beneath your superior understanding.

This is what gives me the right. I helped a trader that came to me after losing a large amount of money by trading his account back to profit in weeks so he could start again with some reasonable cash. After being set out to find his own way he sent an email to me saying he had been following Trader Pauls astro stuff !! I was furious and just plainly gobsmacked!! He was amazed to find that Trader Paul doesn't actually trade and he had wasted MUCH time reading his post following something that clearly the author hasn't the confidence to trade :eek:

Thats what gives me the right. I have ACTUALLY traded at least 10 peoples accounts on ASF into Significant profit so they have a basis to start to learn. If I can stop them and other newbies wasting a huge amount of time and good money and effort following a unproven empty method I will put up with arguments with the likes of you.
Click to expand...

TH dont you need a AFSL to manage other peoples money??

I would be very careful my friend! (ASIC)

cheers
 
Bobby said:
Thats a stupid thing to say , anyone can give advise to a friend & help them trade , what Pandora's box are you tying to open :mad:
Click to expand...

make a bet?

I am not talking about advice or factual information. I am talking about managing peoples money big diff chief........

go talk to ASIC about that mate...........
 
>Apocalypto< said:
ok now this is turning into the rookie thread on Forex Factory.

jeezzzzzzz :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Don't knock Forex Factory haha--I love that forum :p

Btw--I think Auslanco used a gann high low indicator in one of his systems and a lot of people there know how good he is as a trader. (freaking amazing).
 
alwaysLearning said:
Don't knock Forex Factory haha--I love that forum :p

Btw--I think Auslanco used a gann high low indicator in one of his systems and a lot of people there know how good he is as a trader. (freaking amazing).
Click to expand...

yeh mate its a great forum......

I have picked up so much from some of the posters there.

Yeh read Auslanco, great stuff, I am not a gannist nor ever want to be but i respect the skilled practitioners.

check out Igork he is a freak! Top mind as well

cheers
 
beamstas said:
This will be great to see
I'd love to see T/H go from 1k to 50k in a week again :)

He makes trades in the time it takes me to finish eating my weetbix in the morning than i make in a year :eek:

Cheers
Brad
Click to expand...

Bobby said:
What a crap statement , T/H has proved his !!!!!!!!!

Hey were are yours :sheep:
Click to expand...


Haha ------ the real deal is not hard to pick is it !!!

We are privileged to see how a "real trader' operates ----- If i had more cash on hand i'd up my anti to 3-1 on TH, but MM needs to be employed to protect capital lol ---- or does it !!

stuff it ---- i'm in for 10 ---- (i'll take a loan for the rest ------ actually if its over 12 months i'm in for 20 grand ----- money in the bank i reckon ;) ---- and im serious ---- i'll legitimately put 20 grand up on an even money bet if this is serious !!!!!!!!!!!!!! and if its on a "fresh" start date where both parties are starting equally, ill put up 50K !!!

In the words of the famous Mike Tyson ----- "sign the contract big boy, sign the contract" ------ i repeat, im serious !!!! ---- backing TH is a lot safer than letting me trade on my own for 12 months lol ----- bring it on !!!!
 
>Apocalypto< said:
make a bet?

I am not talking about advice or factual information. I am talking about managing peoples money big diff chief........

go talk to ASIC about that mate...........
Click to expand...

I took that as an attack on T/H , got it wrong , sorry Apocalypto :)
 
Trembling Hand said:
LOL well I will unreservedly apologize if I have been misinformed but it was actually from someone on your side of the fence. I will dig up the PMs tomorrow and forward them.

Of course you could always post up some statements of your great gann trading and prove me wrong.
Click to expand...

:)

So you admit, that your attacks on me were based on gossip then, th ... ???

Any time you are ready ... i am awaiting your unreserved apology, as
PMs from anybody prove NOTHING ... except, that you are prepared to
base your posts on nothing more than gossip ... too, too sad ..... :(

waiting

paul

:)
 
Top