- Joined
- 23 June 2005
- Posts
- 608
- Reactions
- 3
Rafa said:Protest what exactly Analyst....
1. Hizbollah not pulling out to the Litani River.... Last I checked, Hisbollah are funded by Syria and Iran... Lebanon haven't the army or the resources to stop them!
2. No agreement on prisoner swap... two soldiers vs hunders of civilians being held in israeli jails without charge! hmmm...
3. Or the sending of Lebanon back 50 years, 350 dead and 1500 wounded for no fault of their own...
Analyst... i've read your posts in this thread.... you are a joke... stick to posting about stocks...
Rafa said:tho hang on a sec... i've seen your posts on GTP.... enuf said!!!
PS: For the record, i am fully symathetic to plight of Israel... but what they are doing to Lebanon is plain wrong, and will not solve anything... They are blowing up civilians when the real problem is Syria and Iran...!
Rafa said:PS: when you quoted me, you stuffed up and inserted your comments within the quote... please ammend if you can... thanks...
the_godfather4 said:Anyone seen these guys?????
www.nkusa.org/
they barely rate a mention on our news coverage.....yet they r well known in many parts of the world......they will probably get labelled anti-semetic
wayneL said:Important topic this.
Not all Jews are zionists. And not all zionists are Jews. There are Christian Zionists as well.... they are the ones with the red button
Snake Pliskin said:Not all people are prejudiced and not all prejudiced are wrong
Yes an interesting link. It appears all religions have their differences.
The other day Orthodox and (straight) jews were all bonded together supporting Israel in its action of late. So it appears those orthodox jews don`t all agree unlike the zionists.
Wayne I would like to hear more about the Cristian zionists. I am truly interested. I`m not aware of any in Australia, but what about the US?
Greg Sheridan: Bad move by Israel
We should lament the probable destruction of the brightest star on the Middle East horizon, writes Foreign editor Greg Sheridan
July 27, 2006
THE missing voice in all the words written and spoken about the war in the Middle East is the Lebanese voice.
Australian coverage of Lebanon has concentrated on our own citizens, which is entirely natural. There can be no criticism of Lebanese Australians who, in deep distress, urged the Government to get them out of the war and home as quickly as possible. If you doubt that, just think how you would feel if it was your mother, your wife, your child trapped in a war.
Similarly, there were many scenes of Lebanese Australians returning via Sydney airport and their first response was "thank God for Australia" or "thank you, Australia".
This is a sentiment we should all feel with some humility, simple gratitude at living in a peaceful and prosperous country. The Howard Government seems to have acted as quickly as possible to help distressed Australians and our diplomats did good work in exceptionally difficult circumstances.
Meanwhile, the Hezbollah spokesmen we occasionally see in threatening sound bites are not the whole of Lebanon, or even the main Lebanon.
Like anyone who grew up in Sydney's western suburbs, I had loads of Lebanese friends at school. Lebanese families I knew were fecund and rambunctious and, above all, cooked magnificent food. There was always a largeness and a grand hospitality about them, which was irresistible.
Lebanon has been a land of many tragedies but there was another side to it. Beirut was for many years the Paris of the Middle East. More recently, both before and after the departure last year of Syrian forces, Beirut had been reborn, to some extent rebuilt by prime minister Rafik Hariri.
It was the most cosmopolitan, democratic, livable and successful Arab society in the Middle East. The Cedar Revolution last year led to the departure of the Syrians. This was a wonderful human triumph, participated in by Lebanese Christians as well as Muslims. But it also had a huge political import. In Washington recently, several analysts told me their most fervent hope was that one day Iraq would come to resemble Lebanon: a bit of chaos, a bit of disorder, a few militias with too many weapons, but the energy of the street, the instinct of the trader, the growing national pride pulling it through to something better.
In other words, the success of Lebanon was the brightest star on the Middle East horizon.
Lebanon, before the recent campaign, was still a weak state but an increasingly successful society. We all had a stake in Lebanese success.
Lebanon is exceptionally complex, even by Middle East standards. At the time of independence in the 1940s, it was a majority Christian society. Today the percentage of Christians has been reduced to about one-third. Somewhat more than this percentage are Shiites, the next biggest group is Sunnis and then the Druze.
The decline of the Lebanese Christian community is part of the tragic and profound decline of Christian communities all across the Middle East, a historic tragedy of epochal proportions, mourned in some detail in the English travel writer William Dalrymple's absorbing book From the Holy Mountain, a journey among the Christians of the Middle East.
But Lebanese Christians were still playing their part, with their countrymen of other religions, in the re-creation of a new and attractive Beirut and Lebanon during the past few years.
A decade ago, a colleague of mine at The Australian, Daizy Mir, a Lebanese Australian of Christian background, made a magnificent and multi-award winning documentary, Lebanon, Imprisoned Splendour. The imprisonment referred to the activities of foreign nations that used Lebanon as a place to wage their proxy wars. But the genius of the film lay in the way it absorbed and accepted Lebanon's suffering in the civil war in particular, and yet transcended this by portraying the other Lebanon.
The film's narrative mechanism was to use the story of Mir's life and the way she worked out her identity as an Australian born in Lebanon who had at first distanced herself from it, but then in young adulthood found a new and unexpected love of Lebanon.
The film showed some of Lebanon's diversity, the scene of some of the oldest continuous human civilisation we know: the town of Byblos, from which the Bible derives its name, the town of Cana, site of Jesus Christ's first miracle. It also showed contemporary Lebanon, the Beirut of cosmopolitanism and sophistication, of an intoxicating night-life, of Mediterranean resorts and spectacular mountains.
Mir was last in Lebanon two years ago and recalls: "It was wonderful to drive around the beautiful highways, not pockmarked any more, to enjoy the cafes and night-life, the people so nice and so friendly, the place just so alive with people from all over the world." In the past few years, U2, Michael Jackson, Placido Domingo and countless other stars have performed in Lebanon. That's a pretty distinctive feature in the Arab world.
Now Mir is devastated by what's happening in Lebanon: "Israel is fighting a war against Syria and Iran and it's using Lebanese territory. This kind of tactic has never worked. All it's going to do is make things worse. It's not going to get rid of Hezbollah. The people in control (of Hezbollah) know how to move around and they've set this up."
The distress that Mir feels is something we should all feel. The probable destruction of the modern Lebanese political development is a profound loss for the Middle East.
None of this remotely excuses Hezbollah, which bears the lion's share of the blame for this situation. Its leaders probably calculated on and wanted tough Israeli action for a multiplicity of political and strategic reasons.
But in my view Israel has imposed too high a price on Lebanon for too uncertain an end. After two weeks it has captured or killed very few Hezbollah guerillas. It is extremely unlikely that Israel will succeed in getting an international military force not only on its own border but also on the Syria-Lebanon border to prevent Syria resupplying Hezbollah.
Israel certainly has the right to defend itself. But the gains from its actions are very uncertain, while the cost is certain. And enormous.
Rafa said:from The Australian...
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,19925802-601,00.html
Its quite clear that there is only one victim of this war between Syria/Iran and Israel.... and that is Lebanon and its people!
Snake Pliskin said:As far as Hezbollah goes, they are getting a good bit of woopass at the moment.
TheAnalyst said:Israel is the real victim as they did not draw first blood......how many times must the blood of the Jews be drawn before they may retaliate? Your own country and its allies have not condenmed Israel so i hope that tells you something......like for instance Rafa, God3 and WayneL that you are traitors to your country and its armed forces and think you should go live in Syria, Iran or Lebonon and dont come back as you are a high treason risk and should be placed on the ASIO security warning list.
Rafa said:Hezboullah derserve all the whoop assing it can get... so do Iran and Syria...
Analyst... I have said all along that Israel targetting the general populace of Lebanon is wrong... I have also maintained all along the complete support for Israel DISMEMBERING the Syrian and Iranian govts... That would in fact decapitate Hezbullah and Hamas...
I also believe this is broadly in line with our Govt response...
So, please retract your statement... In my opinion, your warmongering ways, and your devisive posts are more a threat to national security than my views....
(please read my posts in WW3, and other treads... before making statements such as the one you made...)
TheAnalyst said:Israel is the real victim as they did not draw first blood......how many times must the blood of the Jews be drawn before they may retaliate? Your own country and its allies have not condenmed Israel so i hope that tells you something......like for instance Rafa, God3 and WayneL that you are traitors to your country and its armed forces and think you should go live in Syria, Iran or Lebonon and dont come back as you are a high treason risk and should be placed on the ASIO security warning list.
TheAnalyst said:Ok Rafa....I take back my comments and state you are one of us on the allies side and no traitor.....but the other two are highly suspicious individuals.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?