This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Why are we saying 'sorry' to the aboriginals?!

My mate Rangi has just turned up we're going fishing, say's he's going over to Aus there's easy money to make out of gullible Aussies. Reading some of these posts he's right. porkpie

what's that joke about the garbo asking Rangi ...

"where's you been" "I's been in Australia"
"no where's you weely been"
"well ok, I's weely bin in jail, but I didn't want to tell anyone"

porkpie - suggest you look after NZ problems - and we'll look after ours.
And we have plenty of your kinsmen already lol. - helps keeps things friendly
 
interesting debate on "sorry" this morning ABC program
point made was:
1) 40yrs ago white-ees Intervened in apauling native living conditions of children and took them away from bad infulences
2) bi-partisan support today for another round of intervention because of apauling conditions (it IS happening now, including removing darkies from their parents at a rate significantly more than pro rata for whitie-ees
deja vue
how long before we will need to apologise again - this time for current intervention??
why not make sorry statement "in perpetuity"??
 
I saw an aboriginal family on Elizabeth Street in Melbourne a few days ago, and they were a very rare sight indeed. They do not form part of our mainstream communities and culture and why is this so? Why are they so isolated?

If they are not living in Melbourne, then that is their choice, isn't it?
No one tells anyone in this country where they may or may not live as far as I know.
 
Julia that is hafl the problem. Alot of mainstream Australians have not witnessed what the other half have to put up with. Spend sometime in WA or NT.

Any this scares me:

The National Aboriginal Alliance says the Federal Government should go further than this week's apology to Indigenous Australians and award compensation.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has ruled out financial compensation for members of the Stolen Generations, despite a recommendation in the 1997 'Bringing Them Home' report.

Alliance spokesman Les Malezer says Wednesday's formal apology is welcome, but not enough.

"We are also concerned that the apology is not being accompanied by reparations, which is part of forgiveness, as part of admitting that the wrong thing was done," he said.

"Once the apology has been issued, and providing the apology is not qualified, we will then go on to ask the Government to now consider how it will pay compensation."

Not another cent of my well earnt is going there.

I believe K07 has stuffed this one up real bad and could have masive implications for Australia. Half my family are now expats because of what they can earn overseas. If this economy dives because of Labours focus on social issues instead of economic issues I think the expac percentange will increase, and social unrest could go anywhere.
 
I suppose they all left since the coalition got ousted?
Take a good look at history and see which side of centre inherited the truly hard decisions in this country, WW1, Depression, WW2, 70's energy crisis... Go on, I dare you...
BTW If the Coalition was so good, why are ports and rail and infrastructure lagged so badly?
 
rob (and/or coll)
1. not sure that's how it works - once the govt get their hands on it, it's not yours any more. (in any case the apology is being made under parliamentary privelege and apparently will avoid additional legal liability)

2. If he's "stuffed it up" he will face the public at the next election with a negative against him . Then again if he does something that is well and truly overdue and reconciliation and the Ab situation generally starts to improve then maybe he will do even better next election. Time will tell.

I doubt he will lose any votes from you yes? If he never had your vote in the first place that is?

3. I thought you were going to say " half overseas now, if ..... then the other half as well!" Not sure where you were going - either to which country, or with that argument. Sounds like you prefer the Ab situation to fester than to do anything about it.
 

Starts to look like possibly very expensive sorry soap opera.

Hope that part aboriginals will only be paid part sorry money, as other race stolen-rescued generation does not qualify for compensation, if they do qualify we will have another compensation saga, when currently rescued-stolen kids grow up and happen to bump into solicitor.
 
oh goody.

i eagerly await the word 'sorry' and millions in compensation sorting out all the problems in aboriginal communities and ending the rampant alcoholism and child sexual abuse that is so prevalent in aboriginal communities.

by saying 'sorry' and admitting to these horrific past wrongs im led to believe we will now be equal? does this mean we no longer pay the billions in grants and other special assistance given to aboriginal people??
 

Mark Leibler, says the 17-year life expectancy gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians is his top priority.

To close 17-year life expectancy gap should be top priority for people who experience the gap not the Government.
If I think there is something wrong with my diet and that my lifestyle can affect my longevity, I do not go to Government to give me with increased life expectancy on a plate.

If I want to be closer to better health facility, I do not ask to build that facility in my area.
Remote area farmers don't seem to make such outrageous demands.

If I want cleaner and not smashed house, I do not smash it in a first place and I also clean it and maintain on tegular basis.

I still remember pictures of smashed houses shown all over the world and appalling sanitary conditions ab had to live in.
Took me hours to explain who smashed houses and who blocked toilets and who ripped up flyscreens during my trip to Europe.

I am slowly getting sorry fatigue syndrome.
 
Suppose you are right, once unfinished sorry business is over, claim can be lodged for compensation and hours can be counted to payment.

Fatigue must have overwhelmed me, as not only I cannot take slice of that pie but also I’ll have to partially fund it.
 
How odd!
If you were one of the stolen generation you would be counting the hours.

Maybe. But on the other hand, I daresay there are many among the stolen/rescued generation who are grateful for having an education and a job, a decent work ethic and decent living standard, instead of being uneducated and living among drunkenness, violence, squalor and poverty, which is quite likely how they would have ended up if they hadn't been rescued by people who considered them worthy of a better life.
 

But that is the crux of this whole issue - these children were not necessarily taken from abusive homes; they were taken only because they were aboriginal, nothing more.

Poverty is a relative term. What if a wealthy man took pity on you because your parents were obviously way, way poorer than he was. However, your parents were still adequately providing for you, and you were loved by them. Would you be grateful if he decided to 'save' you and took you away without your parents consent?
 
"When you have to kill a man, it costs nothing to be polite."
- Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965)

Word cost nothing so why not say sorry and get it out of the way.
There maybe law suit and stuff but leave that to the court of law to determine.
 
Intervention – Sorry Mark II in the making

Intervention – Sorry Mark II in the making



"It's a racial act really. We want to be like white people, walk in [to shops] and pay for things with our own cash not half with Centrelink payment and the rest in vouchers," he said.

No discrimination, pay cash or at least make vouchers redeemable in all shops
 

hello,

yes great point B,

thankyou

robots
 
Another one joins the bandwagon (see link). This wagon must be pretty big or it's starting to get overloaded by now.

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,23200332-601,00.html

Anyway, I thought some form of indigineous history is already being taught in schools. Correct me if I am wrong here. Anyone here know how much...? So how much more is "more" here. It's probably a reasonable statement for an informed person (teacher/educator) to make but the Gee Gee is proabably just grabbing a headline here to make it appear as though he is an important person. "Sorry" for my cynacism.

I guess it would only be "modern history", as they have no written records. Of course there is the odd yarn (chinese wisper?) that has been passed down from generation to generation but how reliable are those. Hardly "history". Any other history would have to come from whitey archeologists, etc.

And by the way, dont you guys go putting words in my mouth (that I didnt say), like you did on my last post. That was just a :grenade: to see what would happen.

So here's another.....:grenade:
They called for the intervention to be overturned and an end to quarantining of welfare payments and compulsory land acquisitions.
Members of the crowd threw leaves onto the sacred fire, chanting "Stop the intervention - human rights for all".

I can feel another "sorry" comming on here, down the track a bit.......

And another...........:grenade:
Mark Lord from near Bourke in north-west New South Wales was one of the Aboriginal dancers leading the march, which began just after midday.
He says the intervention order is not the Australian way of doing things.
"It's a racial act really. We want to be like white people, walk in [to shops] and pay for things with our own cash not half with Centrelink payment and the rest in vouchers," he said.
"We human people, we are not animals.

No argument with the last sentence, at all.
So, is Mark's "own cash" just Centrelink payments without the vouchers, or is some sort of other "cash". What sort? Where does it come from?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...