Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

TSLA - Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ)

But to me it’s more about his morals for accepting that large of a pay packet, Also he has fan boys because he built Tesla, and he couldn’t have done that without the investors (whom he later clipped)

To remedy the problem, if he really thinks his management of Tesla will build value, he should agree to not accept anymore compensation, and just accept any future value he brings will be reflected by an increase in value of that $56 Billion of shares we just paid him (plus the shares he already owned prior).

————————

Also, keep in mind that although you don’t seem to think Tim Cook has done much, he has presided over a capital gain for Apple share holders of about 5 times more than Elon did for Tesla share holders, and was paid a tiny fraction, and he donated a huge portion of his bonus to charity, and as I said Steve jobs before him worked for $1 per year.
The reason he most likely wants the money is to finance other projects. I think he likes not having public listed companies where he constantly has to bend to the rules.

There was little innovation with cook. He's a good manager. Imo he missed a lot of opportunities and backed a lot of flops. Apple is no longer at the forefront of innovative products.

Elon made a crazy deal that no one thought he would achieve and managed to pull it off. I'm not arguing it's a bad deal or his "morals" are off. Or even that he's a bit of a sht cnt. I'm saying Tesla really gets clipped if he walks.
 
In the last 5 years TSLA has had 8 100d drops of 40% , so that is nothing new , It's expected . And i think another one in next 100 days is not that improbable , actually its probable in my eyes . Everyone of these dips tests the diamond hands mentality of the cult .
His cult is seriously wide in tech circles. There's a confidence in his ability from investors. These guys buy it with every spare cent.
I'd argue that Tesla would ensure its demise if he walked. Could you imagine how far short sellers could push this down.
 
The reason he most likely wants the money is to finance other projects. I think he likes not having public listed companies where he constantly has to bend to the rules.

There was little innovation with cook. He's a good manager. Imo he missed a lot of opportunities and backed a lot of flops. Apple is no longer at the forefront of innovative products.

Elon made a crazy deal that no one thought he would achieve and managed to pull it off. I'm not arguing it's a bad deal or his "morals" are off. Or even that he's a bit of a sht cnt. I'm saying Tesla really gets clipped if he walks.

You have nailed it.

Elon Musk once considered taking Tesla private.

He is not like most people, but then how many geniuses are?

Elon has dreams that most of his investors want to see come to fruition. Including the ones that are not part of the Tesla group. Space travel, Mars colonisation, robotics, AI, Neuralink which will aid paralyzed people.

This all takes a lot of money and resources to start and continue to the end. These are projects and research that will help future generations, robotics is already seen as a way to help countries with aging populations and worker shortages.
 
The reason he most likely wants the money is to finance other projects. I think he likes not having public listed companies where he constantly has to bend to the rules.
Ok, thanks Elon for clipping Tesla shareholders equity to go finance projects without us, sounds like a great manager, he can just sell Tesla shares if he want to finance another project, like he did when he bought twitter. Tesla share holders equity is not his private piggy bank.

There was little innovation with cook. He's a good manager. Imo he missed a lot of opportunities and backed a lot of flops. Apple is no longer at the forefront of innovative products.

Innovation wasn't a metric in Elon's pay packet, it was share price gain. Tim Cook would have been paid over $200 Billion on the same basis.


I'm saying Tesla really gets clipped if he walks.
Maybe maybe not, in the short term yes, but many companies have grown a lot with their founders gone, look at Apple, Disney, Walmart, Mc Donalds and many others.
 
Apparently Bezos is trying to wrap Musk up in lawfare. I do worry it will become a side distraction. I believe the political divide is one of the biggest dangers as it gets swept into the path of biased bureaucrats.

https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/thehill.com/opinion/4757663-spacex-musk-jeff-bezos-lawfare/amp/
On the topic of Bezos, he has created much more market value than Elon also, but never come close to earning even $1 Billion in pay.

Bezos earned $1.7 Million in salary last year, sh#t we could hirer Bezos for 28,000 years instead of Musk, Hell even if we hirer Cook, Bezos, Buffet we could have a few hundred years of managers HAHAHA
 
Last edited:
Ok, thanks Elon for clipping Tesla shareholders equity to go finance projects without us, sounds like a great manager, he can just sell Tesla shares if he want to finance another project, like he did when he bought twitter. Tesla share holders equity is not his private piggy bank.



Innovation wasn't a metric in Elon's pay packet, it was share price gain. Tim Cook would have been paid over $200 Billion on the same basis.



Maybe maybe not, in the short term yes, but many companies have grown a lot with their founders gone, look at Apple, Disney, Walmart, Mc Donalds and many others.
This seems like a personal gripe?
I didn't hear this kind of talk when the deal was made.

You are talking to the wrong guy. I think musk is brilliant but his middle name is "shifty". The guy has sh1tted me for years over some of his takes.

All those other companies are in the "meh" stage, good to have in the portfolio. Tesla has robotaxi, optimus, dojo chip each could produce large windfalls.

On the topic of Bezos, he has created much more market value than Elon also, but never come close to earning even $1 Billion in pay.

Bezos earned $1.7 Million in salary last year, sh#t we could hirer Bezos for 28,000 years instead of Musk, Hell even if we hirer Cook, Bezos, Buffet we could have a few hundred years of managers HAHAHA
Bezos is a smart guy but he literally built a phallus shaped rocket. He will most likely end as the runner up in everything.

Musks companies have built a reusable rocket that's been tested over and over.
Manufactured at scale an electric car.
produced large scale battery storage.
Starlink.
Hyperloop
Neuralink
I'm sure he was working on an electric jet.
Trying to get to Mars.

None of the ceos you mentioned are worth sht in this field of innovation. I wouldn't want them just yet. At a later stage yes maybe. But there is only a handful of guys that are doing really innovative things. The list of guys you provided are not those guys. You could hire all of them and it wouldn't help.
 
Musk isn't like other CEOs working solely for the company. He is deliberately developing technologies separate to Tesla. He has little loyalty to Tesla.

This has forced shareholders to allow him to strip their wealth to keep aligned. Not nice, forced, but that's how it is.

Even now we can't be sure Musk will necessarily act in Tesla's interests if it conflicts with his own. But if you were a shareholder you would hope that, after receiving this largesse, he would, but I stress the word hope.
 
This seems like a personal gripe?
I didn't hear this kind of talk when the deal was made.

You are talking to the wrong guy. I think musk is brilliant but his middle name is "shifty". The guy has sh1tted me for years over some of his takes.

All those other companies are in the "meh" stage, good to have in the portfolio. Tesla has robotaxi, optimus, dojo chip each could produce large windfalls.


Bezos is a smart guy but he literally built a phallus shaped rocket. He will most likely end as the runner up in everything.

Musks companies have built a reusable rocket that's been tested over and over.
Manufactured at scale an electric car.
produced large scale battery storage.
Starlink.
Hyperloop
Neuralink
I'm sure he was working on an electric jet.
Trying to get to Mars.

None of the ceos you mentioned are worth sht in this field of innovation. I wouldn't want them just yet. At a later stage yes maybe. But there is only a handful of guys that are doing really innovative things. The list of guys you provided are not those guys. You could hire all of them and it wouldn't help.

Some people are so bitter that they can’t see past their hate.

There has been mention of some billionaires only receiving a token payment for their efforts.

Seriously, who believes that Warren Buffet’s pay is $100 per week, or some other billionaire pays himself $1.00, or another works for free?

Those billionaires sort their salaries so that they pay minimal taxes.

In 2023 Elon Musk paid US$11 billion in taxes.

While Warren Buffett famously stated that he pays a lower tax rate than his secretary.
 
This seems like a personal gripe?
I didn't hear this kind of talk when the deal was made.

You are talking to the wrong guy. I think musk is brilliant but his middle name is "shifty". The guy has sh1tted me for years over some of his takes.

All those other companies are in the "meh" stage, good to have in the portfolio. Tesla has robotaxi, optimus, dojo chip each could produce large windfalls.


Bezos is a smart guy but he literally built a phallus shaped rocket. He will most likely end as the runner up in everything.

Musks companies have built a reusable rocket that's been tested over and over.
Manufactured at scale an electric car.
produced large scale battery storage.
Starlink.
Hyperloop
Neuralink
I'm sure he was working on an electric jet.
Trying to get to Mars.

None of the ceos you mentioned are worth sht in this field of innovation. I wouldn't want them just yet. At a later stage yes maybe. But there is only a handful of guys that are doing really innovative things. The list of guys you provided are not those guys. You could hire all of them and it wouldn't help.
Musk rocket company has nothing to do with tesla
 
Musk isn't like other CEOs working solely for the company. He is deliberately developing technologies separate to Tesla. He has little loyalty to Tesla.

This has forced shareholders to allow him to strip their wealth to keep aligned. Not nice, forced, but that's how it is.

Even now we can't be sure Musk will necessarily act in Tesla's interests if it conflicts with his own. But if you were a shareholder you would hope that, after receiving this largesse, he would, but I stress the word hope.
Hence why I have sold off most of my shares in Tesla, and moved it to Berkshire Hathaway, they are more shareholder friendly.

I only have a token 50 shares holding, my wife has a few more than me, I am happy to hold those few as a token, because I do believe in Tesla, it’s just we can’t be sure how much of any upside we will get to keep and how much will be clipped. But we know 100% of the downside risk is ours.
 
Q
Musk isn't like other CEOs working solely for the company. He is deliberately developing technologies separate to Tesla. He has little loyalty to Tesla.

This has forced shareholders to allow him to strip their wealth to keep aligned. Not nice, forced, but that's how it is.

Even now we can't be sure Musk will necessarily act in Tesla's interests if it conflicts with his own. But if you were a shareholder you would hope that, after receiving this largesse, he would, but I stress the word hope.
I agree with the premise that Musk is a wild card. I don't trust the guy on multiple levels. But on the development and mass scale of tech then I don't think there is many on his level.
 
Musk isn't like other CEOs working solely for the company. He is deliberately developing technologies separate to Tesla. He has little loyalty to Tesla.

This has forced shareholders to allow him to strip their wealth to keep aligned. Not nice, forced, but that's how it is.

Even now we can't be sure Musk will necessarily act in Tesla's interests if it conflicts with his own. But if you were a shareholder you would hope that, after receiving this largesse, he would, but I stress the word hope.
What do you guys believe Elon think of the masses of religious like tesla fans buying cars to save the planet?
Useful cashed up tools.
Elon perfectly understand physics, does not listen to propaganda and use whatever force, assets available to fulfill his entrepreneurial spirit

Tesla job is a done job for him, seriously, what next..an incremental battery change or new tech?
Self driving is also in incremental, not revolutionary steps.
The exciting part of tesla is done.
let's move on, get as much cash and proceed to the new really exciting projects.
I 100% understand him, yes it is not in the interests of the shareholders but what should they complain about?
Go Elon and bring another new frontier down, governments can't do that anymore and only raw $ by the billions allow for both innovation and the way to push back the government mediocracy rules and tapes.
Good on him
 
Hence why I have sold off most of my shares in Tesla, and moved it to Berkshire Hathaway, they are more shareholder friendly.

I only have a token 50 shares holding, my wife has a few more than me, I am happy to hold those few as a token, because I do believe in Tesla, it’s just we can’t be sure how much of any upside we will get to keep and how much will be clipped. But we know 100% of the downside risk is ours.
You literally missed the rise.
Did this come from an ideological position on Musks politics?
When you originally mentioned it I dove in a bit to see if it was warranted and I came away bullish.
Was it just the numbers didn't stack up with the contract and rabid fan boys voting again?
Your position on Tesla has done a 180 and it feels like the contract isn't as greater deal as musk being a shtball. He was always a shtball.
What turned you from fan to foe?
Do you still like your EV I feel like this is the perfect time to actually get a good honest review from you.

I'm back to swing trades after the top blew off and agree with most of what you are saying. But optimus alone would be a game changer.
I don't agree that there is limited upside.

But the possibility of a fall from here, yes I agree with that. If democrats look like winning I think Tesla will take a hit and languish.
 
Tesla has always been a high-risk investment; most people realise this. However, it has matured and proven itself to be a leader, which has forced other companies to chase it. some of the big automotive manufacturers have failed and instead are in discussion with Tesla to purchase technology.

Musk's visions are many and varied. He sees Tesla has a company that forces the establishment to move forward with innovation and technology, Tesla got EV's into the mainstream. Before Tesla there was GM with their plans for an EV future, but they scrapped those plans out of fear and greed.

Now Tesla is more than an EV company, they are investing in AI for driverless technology, robotics for human assistance, battery technology for many and varied uses.

There are people in the world that are not able to see into the distant future, they are more into the present. Nothing wrong with that, but we can't let those people dictate, and I have faith in humanity that they won't. History has shown that we alwyas move forward, regardless of the naysayers.

Elon Musk has ideas and vision for a better future, he has created other companies to help see his plans come to fruition. Those ideas and plans need funding,

Musk uses his money to fund those projects.


each of which could potentially contribute to an extraterrestrial colony, according to the documents and the people with knowledge of the efforts.
The Boring Company, a private tunneling venture founded by Mr. Musk, was started in part to ready equipment to burrow under Mars’s surface, two of the people said. Mr. Musk has told people that he bought X, the social media platform, partly to help test how a citizen-led government that rules by consensus might work on Mars. He has also said that he envisions residents on the planet will drive a version of the steel-paneled Cybertrucks made by Tesla, his electric vehicle company.

For more than two decades, Elon Musk has focused SpaceX, his rocket company, on his lifelong goal of reaching Mars.

Over the last year, he has also ramped up work on what will happen if he gets there.

Mr. Musk, 53, has directed SpaceX employees to drill into the design and details of a Martian city, according to five people with knowledge of the efforts and documents viewed by The New York Times. One team is drawing up plans for small dome habitats, including the materials that could be used to build them. Another is working on spacesuits to combat Mars’s hostile environment, while a medical team is researching whether humans can have children there. Mr. Musk has volunteered his sperm to help seed a colony, two people familiar with his comments said.

The initiatives, which are in their infancy, are a shift toward more concrete planning for life on Mars as Mr. Musk’s timeline has hastened. While he said in 2016 that it would take 40 to 100 years to have a self-sustaining civilization on the planet, Mr. Musk told SpaceX employees in April that he now expects one million people to be living there in about 20 years.

“There’s high urgency to making life multi-planetary,” he said, according to a publicly posted video of his remarks. “We’ve got to do it while civilization is so strong.”

Mr. Musk has long tried to defy the impossible and has often managed to beat tough odds. But his vision for life on Mars takes his seemingly limitless ambitions to their most extreme — and some might say absurdist — point. No one has ever set foot on the planet. NASA doesn’t expect to land humans on Mars until the 2040s. And if people get there, they will be greeted by a barren terrain, icy temperatures, dust storms, and air that is impossible to breathe.

Yet Mr. Musk is so wedded to the idea of creating a civilization on Mars — he once said he plans to die there — that it has propelled nearly every business endeavor he has undertaken on Earth. His vision for Mars underlies most of the six companies that he leads or owns, each of which could potentially contribute to an extraterrestrial colony, according to the documents and the people with knowledge of the efforts.

The Boring Company, a private tunneling venture founded by Mr. Musk, was started in part to ready equipment to burrow under Mars’s surface, two of the people said. Mr. Musk has told people that he bought X, the social media platform, partly to help test how a citizen-led government that rules by consensus might work on Mars. He has also said that he envisions residents on the planet will drive a version of the steel-paneled Cybertrucks made by Tesla, his electric vehicle company.

MUSK-MARS-BORING-qhvk-articleLarge.jpg

Mr. Musk’s vision for Mars underlies most of the six companies that he leads or owns, including the Boring Company.

Mr. Musk, who is worth about $270 billion, has publicly declared that he only accumulates assets — which include a roughly $47 billion Tesla pay package — to fund his plans for Mars.

“It’s a way to get humanity to Mars, because establishing a self-sustaining city on Mars will require a lot of resources,” he testified in court in 2022 about his Tesla pay.

Whether Mr. Musk can achieve his vision for a Martian colony in his lifetime is debatable.

“You can’t just land one million people on Mars,” said Robert Zubrin, an aerospace engineer who has known Mr. Musk for 20 years and wrote the book “The Case for Mars.” Any colonization of the planet would unfold over decades, he said.

Mr. Zubrin added that Mr. Musk is being particularly distracted from his Mars ambitions by his recent work on X. The tech billionaire often faces criticism for being spread too thin among the companies he runs.

While Mr. Musk has spoken about Mars for years and SpaceX released two basic drawings of a colony around 2018, many specifics and the company’s shift toward civilization planning haven’t previously been reported. Mr. Musk has largely kept the colonization plans quiet because SpaceX, under a $2.9 billion contract with NASA, must first send a rocket to the moon, two people with knowledge of the company said.

The Times interviewed more than 20 people close to Mr. Musk and SpaceX about the plans for a Martian city and reviewed internal documents, emails, social media posts and legal documents. Many of the people spoke on the condition of anonymity because they had signed nondisclosure agreements.

Even they were skeptical that Mr. Musk would build a Martian city in his lifetime. Some of them said he was just trying to best Jeff Bezos, Amazon’s founder who envisions humans living in giant space stations throughout the solar system. Mr. Musk has laid out an aggressive timeline for Mars to make them work harder, others said. Drawings of the colony are sometimes referred to as a “hype package,” two of them said.

Mr. Musk and SpaceX didn’t respond to requests for comment. In a post on X after this article was published, Mr. Musk said he had not volunteered his sperm and that no one at SpaceX had been directed to work on a Martian city. “When people have asked to do so, I’ve said we need to focus on getting there first,” he wrote.

Saving Humanity​

Mr. Musk has been fascinated by Mars since reading Isaac Asimov’s 1951 science fiction novel, “Foundation,” when he was 10. In the book, the protagonist builds a colony across a galaxy to save humanity from the fall of an interstellar empire.

“They find a planet far away from the galactic center and try to preserve human knowledge and civilization there while the center of the galaxy kind of falls apart,” Mr. Musk said in a 2013 interview for a science video.

In 2001, Mr. Musk tried buying a Russian rocket to reach Mars, said Jim Cantrell, a former SpaceX employee who visited Russia with him that year. But after three trips, the Russians refused to sell, and one official spit on Mr. Musk’s shoes, Mr. Cantrell said.

In 2002, Mr. Musk founded SpaceX, a privately held company in Hawthorne, Calif. It eventually created partly reusable rockets and landed government contracts, including with NASA. In recent years, it started Starlink, a satellite internet service that has expanded worldwide.

To reach Mars, SpaceX has built Starship, a nearly 400-foot reusable rocket. Starship’s immediate purpose is to take NASA astronauts to the moon, though it might later ferry residents to Mars and could also act as a small space station.

A future version of Starship may have a living space in its nose, three people familiar with the rocket said. Plans call for several floors of living quarters, with amenities like a running track and a movie theater, two of the people said. One drawing of Starship’s interior, a version of which Mr. Musk has posted on X, shows a violinist hovering in zero gravity as she plays for a crowd.

Starship may carry 100 passengers at a time to Mars, a journey that would happen about every two years, Mr. Musk told the International Astronautical Congress in a 2016 presentation. NASA has said a trip to Mars, located about 140 million miles from Earth, would take up to nine months.

In 2018, SpaceX engineers gathered with university researchers and others for a private meeting in Colorado to discuss the technology needed to survive on Mars, according to notes of the meeting obtained by The Times. Topics included harvesting ice to make water and selecting the right area on Mars to build a colony.

By last year, the latest versions of Starship had been built at Starbase, a SpaceX facility in Boca Chica, Texas. In June, Starship successfully returned from a test flight to space for the first time.

Colony Planning​

Over the years, Mr. Musk has dropped hints about how he thinks people would live on Mars.

One theme revolves around the continuation of human life on the planet. Scientists haven’t determined whether people can have children in space. Mr. Musk has said children won’t be allowed on the first flights to Mars because of the dangers, though he expects them to live there eventually.

But Mr. Musk has a plan. In his 2013 interview for the science video, he said he hoped to create his own species on Mars, an idea that he has repeated over the years to SpaceX employees and others close to the company.

“I think it’s quite likely that we’d want to bioengineer new organisms that are better suited to living on Mars,” he said in the interview. “Humanity’s kind of done that over time, by sort of selective breeding.”

He also has a strategy for warmth. In a 2022 podcast interview, he said he would tackle the planet’s icy temperatures with a series of thermonuclear explosions that would warm the planet by creating artificial suns. Hundreds of solar panels, potentially built by Tesla, will help heat homes and create energy, three people familiar with his plans said.

Mr. Musk’s pronouncements have in recent months shifted into more concrete planning by SpaceX employees.

The industrial design team has been creating and updating renderings for a city, two people said. The colony will center on a giant dome for communal living, with smaller domes scattered around it. Discussions have lately focused on what materials to use for the domes. Mr. Musk is particularly concerned with making sure the city looks cool, two other people said.

One internal drawing obtained by The Times shows a family with young children standing in a dome neighborhood, gazing up at the stars.

In April, Mr. Musk told SpaceX employees that the Mars colony would be self-sustaining in case something happened to Earth and rockets couldn’t reach it anymore.

To achieve that, Mr. Musk plans to use Starship as sort of a Noah’s Ark, carrying plants and animals on the initial voyage, three people familiar with the plans said. Residents would then build greenhouses on Mars to grow food.

SpaceX has partnered with Impossible Foods, the plant-based alternative meat company, to provide food in SpaceX’s cafeterias, but also to test the products as a possible protein source for Mars, two of the people said.

Civilization Secured?​

Image
MUSK-MARS-gateway-qbtw-articleLarge.jpg

Starship, a nearly 400-foot reusable rocket, docked at SpaceX’s facility in Boca Chica, Texas.Credit...Meridith Kohut for The New York Times

Like Mr. Musk, many of SpaceX’s more than 12,000 employees believe in life on another planet, according to the people familiar with the company and documents viewed by The Times. Workers sometimes wear “Occupy Mars” or “Rocket Parent” T-shirts to work and post suggestions for the Mars colony on an internal site. One recent idea was to build the city on the side of a giant crater.

Some employees working on the Mars plans are based in Boca Chica, while others from the Southern California office fly in on Mondays and leave on Fridays. Many work more than 100 hours a week.

The Boca Chica site has an industrial complex called Stargate, with an office that some liken to being in a Las Vegas casino because the lack of windows makes it hard to tell if it is day or night, three people said. A new office under construction there will have more windows, they said. Current and former employees said the Boca Chica site has sometimes lacked basic safety protocols, like caution tape around dangerous equipment.

SpaceX has grappled with a lawsuit and a complaint from the National Labor Relations Board related to eight former employees who said they were fired for complaining about Mr. Musk’s behavior and for making allegations of sexual harassment and discrimination at the company. SpaceX hasn’t responded to the lawsuit and has sued the N.L.R.B., claiming it acted unconstitutionally.

Still, some employees said it was worth working there to create a Mars colony.

In a recent goodbye email viewed by The Times, a female SpaceX manager who worked on the Mars program described “brutal” hours and conditions, especially for working parents. But she also said the company was “an astonishing place” and that she would “trade this experience for nothing.”

Mr. Musk’s presence in Boca Chica has waned recently, people familiar with the company said. He visits about once a month, sometimes in the middle of the night for a few hours with his toddler son X Æ A-12, two of the people said, compared with at least once a week previously.

Yet his resolve for a Martian civilization appears unbowed.

In May, a NASA official said that the agency didn’t expect to land humans on Mars until the 2040s. That same month, Mr. Musk posted on X that it would take less than 10 years to send people there and that there would be a Martian city in about 20 years.

“For sure in 30, civilization secured,” he wrote.

 
Last edited:
I love other side opinions. Mine can be totally wrong at any moment.
It all depends on the self drive technology.
When Musk makes it work with the help of Tesla engineers, will it use the Ai chips he is developing separately? Who will own the software?
Will Tesla end up like Samsung with Android, the actual tech owned and updated separately by Musk and sold to all parties/competitors willing to pay?

I think he will look after Tesla shareholders to the extent they may double their money but I think he won't let them have much more than that. Could be wrong.
 
Simply to show the difference from the others and his ability to innovate. I'm well aware it's not Tesla
Still, what matters is whether he is building shareholder value, and so far he has built less than the other names I mentioned, but been paid 100’s or 1000’s times more.
 
Top