- Joined
- 14 February 2005
- Posts
- 15,183
- Reactions
- 17,171
There is anecdotal evidence that all is not well pretty much everywhere IMO. A bull market in precious metals, high oil prices, ridiculously low yields on real estate, houses sitting empty and so on.phoenixrising said:I can't post a link for this, have to take my word on it.
Paddington in Sydney is upmarket and has 7 or 8 pubs that people come to from the very top end of Suburbs and City. A stop of before and after a game at SCG or Rugby. Biz lunches, deals to be done, etc.
Yet one of the pubs is thinking of closing at 11pm (lisenced to 12) because it's so quiet. Why would that be? I don't know, but something is happening.
Certainly housing affordability (or lack thereof) is part of it. I see a lot of buildings not getting maint anymore as a backlash.
OK WA is powering on, QLD doing well, but just as the US is a world guide, Sydney is an OZ guide to a degree and is looking uncomfortable imho.
I'm not wishing for a recession but I do think it's prudent to acknowledge that a 14 year economic expansion is unusually long and it's running into some pretty strong winds right now.
NSW economic growth is at a virtual standstill. More consumers and general business activity than anywhere else and yet its economy is going basically nowhere. I consider this highly relevant since (1) Sydney boomed before the other major cities and (2) this is happening at a time when the national economy is benefiting from the commodities boom which ought to bring at least some minor benefits to NSW. It's arguable that without the flow on benefits from the commodities boom benefiting other states, NSW would be literally in recession since it's so close already.
Only Tasmania is still achieving strong growth but that is heavily propped up by one-off capital works relating to energy. Look beyond that and there's plenty of empty houses and tourism is visibly struggling. It's unusual that Tasmania's economic growth tops the nation, but when it's done so in the past it's been due to deteriorating conditions in the other states rather than genuine local strength and it's the same this time.
Just as NSW tends to lead, Tas tends to lag. When the leading state is on the edge of recession and the lagging one is the strongest performer I think that ought to be sounding all sorts of alarms about what lies ahead.
I don't wish for a recession but IMO the warning signs are very much there and it is prudent to consider the possibility. If people are staying away from pubs etc then that's another piece of evidence which points in the same direction.