Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Market Homework

Its been quite while since i started to incorporate VP into my sim trading after i learned how to read the order flow in the DOM. To recap, i went down this path after encouragement from TH to try and trade the bigger moves instead of scalping one or four ticks all day long and working for the broker. He didn't suggest VP, and to my knowledge he doesn't consciously use it...

VP gives me a way to structure the market and the references to value areas and price acceptance / rejection really resonate well with me. I can relate to auction market theory and its clear to me that this is what is going on in the market, any FREE market in fact. This is the entire purpose of a market is to get agreement on price so as to facilitate consistent transactions and clear inventory, fulfilling the needs of both the buyer and seller.

I should add that i have not paid for any training on VP other than 1 webinar by FT71 ($20). Everything else i have found on YT, and other places on the internet. There is allot of good quality information on VP freely available...

VP also helped me to put together a daily trade plan. Although it cannot be exact, as we wait for certain cues after the market opens and establishes an 'initial balance area'. Basically we look to sell levels above current value and buy levels below current value. We don't trade in value but use it as a target area instead. Generally we plan our day by looking for areas where price has been accepted (High Volume), and rejected (Low Volume) in the recent past. These become our levels to trade off of. Once our value area for the day is established, we then look for moves away from value into our trade levels.

Indicators - the only true indicator i use is the VWAP. This and the first standard deviation serve as our moving value area and we only use this as a guide of where NOT to trade. We want price outside of this range to take trades at. I use a volume balance chart so i can see if the order balance is supporting a momentum move or not, If not then i could have a chance for a trade IF its at one of my levels, outside of my value area. Also, I use the change in cumulative bid/ask (delta), in order to see if the flow of order to one side or the other is continuing or not.

Then, i use the DOM, as well as a volume ladder to see when the orders peak or bottom out and sellers/buyers are discovered again. It here where we can decide whether or not to hit the big or offer and get into the market. We then can use the value area as a target, while keeping a runner on for a bigger move.

Typically trends begin outside of value, where there are buyer or sellers that aggressively disagree with the current price and snap up allot of volume, as its seen as a 'bargain'. This can typically start a new trend, or finish an old trend. Trends also get started and continued with the entrance of a participant from another time frame with deep pockets. They can shift the balance in the market and drive prices continually in one direction for longer periods.

The index futures markets are typically mean reverting, bracketing range bound for the majority of time. VP and this style of trading suits this well to me and this style of interpreting the markets information is very well suited to discretionary index day trading.

All of this said, success in a real account will be a little elusive for me until i establish the discipline to take only the trades that my plan and the market give me, and i can recover from a 'normal' loss and get on the horse again quickly. Losing trades happen no matter how good the setup may be. This side of the game is the most difficult for me. Still, this has been the most rewarding experience since my interest in trading took me on this road 7 years ago.

I will post the visual tools i use later on so people can see what i see and how i can make my trade decisions.

Most of what i learned freely on how to use VP to establish a trade plan came from many good videos by Kam Dhadwar from L2ST. I haven't joined his trade room and probably won't be for a while as i will take a break from this and start work again at a large Chinese Food business. He trades the DAX as well as the US markets so that has me interested and i think a month i the trade room would be worthwhile.

Enjoy the weekend folks!

CanOz
 
Notes on the chart...
 

Attachments

  • HSI Homework aug 19.jpg
    HSI Homework aug 19.jpg
    156.4 KB · Views: 15
Well that wasn't expected! A nice little drop to close a gap from the 1st of August provided several fade opportunity's as it retraced. Now we have a new value area just under 20000.
 

Attachments

  • HSI big drop.png
    HSI big drop.png
    29 KB · Views: 136
Today saw a big push lower to test yesterdays VAL, then a clear rejection and a push back to the open, then another rejection. We're filling in a value area near Fridays VPOC. Its a real battle right now...
 

Attachments

  • HSI Value area.jpg
    HSI Value area.jpg
    174.6 KB · Views: 6
Today I dipped my toe into the HSI for the first time...but on the mini, the MHI. This will cost me a bit in brokerage but i need to work with real money on the line. I lost overall for the day, but i was happy that i could get back into a trade after a couple of losers in a row.

I sort of thought we would trade to 20k after lunch, and then i missed the short entry at the open again...As the market came into 20k i got in when i thought the buyers were hitting hard enough, but i underestimated the strength of the sellers:eek:. I enter three times, getting stopped out on the first two before i picked the right entry. I'm using the HSI order flow to judge the pressure, not the mini.

I did quite well on the HSI sim today, one of my best days yet, but its the heavy selling or buying that i need to get accustomed to. Strong trend days hurt, but i do well on range days . Also, having a volume histogram on my 5 minute chart would have helped me see the stopping volume although i had a feel that there had been allot of absorption. You mind works differently with money on the line. That's what i need to work on. Trading well and not worrying about the money.

CanOz
 

Attachments

  • MHI Tuesday.png
    MHI Tuesday.png
    21.8 KB · Views: 0
We had a reasonable day today after a slow start. Then i did miss the big sell off at the London open as i was doing some other work and preparing to switch over to the DAX sim...oh well. I'm ok with trading this size, it bothered me for a bit yesterday but I'm ok today, just feels like sim again. I've got to condition my self to this, even though the brokerage is costly compared to the reward, its worth it psychologically.
 

Attachments

  • MHI Wednesday.png
    MHI Wednesday.png
    21.9 KB · Views: 5
  • MHI Wed summary.png
    MHI Wed summary.png
    47.8 KB · Views: 17
  • HSI Wed aug22.png
    HSI Wed aug22.png
    112.8 KB · Views: 8
In trading they say that Psychology is blah blah % of the game. Well i don't know what % it is but its important to be able to stick with the trade and not puke it up. You've got to live with losers, but you don't need to create them yourself.

I use NinjaTrader's ATM module to manage my trades once I'm in the position. For example, lately on the DAX paper trading I've been using 8 contracts. When our order gets hit, we're in with 8 contracts, the first 6 are taken off at 8 ticks. If the market moves to 10+1 ticks in our favor then the stop goes to break even on the next two automatically. I can then adjust the targets, usually to where it looks like the market will find buyers or sellers again. This is very easy to trade as it takes the pressure off. Once those first contracts are taken off and it goes to breakeven its a free trade. If you know your market you can probably tell how far it usually moves as a minimum in a retracement. You can use this to get a few contrcts off and bank some profit, reducing the risk if it comes back against you before you can get to BE.

I do the same thing on the MHI, but i use 3 contracts.

See attached screen shot of the ATM on the DOM.

CanOz
 

Attachments

  • dax 8 strat.png
    dax 8 strat.png
    47.8 KB · Views: 3
Well the news hit the market today at 10:30 am HK time and the contract was pushed lower to the edge of the composite value area (VAL). It retraced back to the DPOC at 20090 ish. I didn't trad any of this, for various environmental reasons and to be honest I didn't see anything that jumped out at me. So now we'll take trades away from the value area as i suspect we could test the HOD if we trade above the DPOC for long.

If we head lower after lunch we could test yesterdays VPOC at 19910.

CanOz
 
I'll try and post a summary but for now all i can get is the IB trade table. Not a bad day but i wasn't quick enough to recognize the entry today and got some poor fills. Nonetheless we were profitable. 68 points all up. The broker must love me! This could be my last day of trading the MHI. I might get a couple of days in next week if I'm lucky.

CanOz
 

Attachments

  • MHI Thursday.png
    MHI Thursday.png
    26.3 KB · Views: 39
Well I hope some have enjoyed following my blog for a while. We've moved now and today I start my new position with a totally Chinese private business.

Maybe another member will take up VP and by the time I'm back at this we can share some thoughts.

Cheers,



CanOz
 
I have enjoyed your blog posts CanOz! Hopefully, at some point in the future, you will have the time to post some more. Best of luck with the new position! :)
 
Ok here's my challenge:

56 million KWN
10 days of trading (20 calendar days)
Profit target of 4 million KWN
Daily loss limit of 1.3 million KWN
5 contract limit

Plus the rules below....

A screenshot of my SIM account.Combine Scout Rules.png
 

Attachments

  • K200 SIM Shot.png
    K200 SIM Shot.png
    56.6 KB · Views: 665
Well that was a quick exit from my own comp....daily stop exceeded.
 
Top