wayneL
VIVA LA LIBERTAD, CARAJO!
- Joined
- 9 July 2004
- Posts
- 25,954
- Reactions
- 13,248
It's "tenets".Really Wayne ? For Dogs sake get a grip on yourself. Nothing in those tenants fits Biden. It only fits a relatively small number of politicians.
But the world view and working principles are well worth thinking about
Fascism is a particular comprehensive ideology, not just what the Komrades don't like.Wayne you wanted a definition of Fascism. I offered one from Robert Reich. Why not disregard his observations about Donald Trump and talk to the question of what is Fascism?
It is. And that comprehensive ideology was what Reich researched and summarised.Fas
Fascism is a particular comprehensive ideology, not just what the Komrades don't like.
We can probably mostly agree on various tenets of fascism. It's not hard, it is fairly well documented.It is. And that comprehensive ideology was what Reich researched and summarised.
My first observation was that the discussion was about the major tenets of fascism. Ok broad agreement there.We can probably mostly agree on various tenets of fascism. It's not hard, it is fairly well documented.
My arguement is in people of the left's cherry picking of certain tenets fascism and then cherry-picking various statements of whomever, Trump in this case, and piecing together on an ad hoc basis a case that someone is a fascist.
Disingenuous, and pure evil.
Why would you quote that clown?I offered one from Robert Reich.
You've been wrong for 8 years straight, so far.My first observation was that the discussion was about the major tenets of fascism. Ok broad agreement there.
With regards to Donald Trump and how he fits into the picture ? Robert Reich offered the analysis of an Authoritarian Government vs a Fascist government in the context of the current Republican Party. I do not believe he was disingenous and pure evil. If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck...
Told you! Get the definition first.Wayne you wanted a definition of Fascism. I offered one from Robert Reich. Why not disregard his observations about Donald Trump and talk to the question of what is Fascism?
Thanks for the Vox article Moxjo. It certainly highlighted the range of authoritarian and anti democratic behaviors that Donald Trump was doing up until Oct 2020. Does that give one a hint about why a similar analysis written in 2023 might differ ?Here's an article from a Trump hater that found 5 so called "experts" on fascists (that also didn't like him).
No one thought Trump was one.
https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/www...s/21521958/what-is-fascism-signs-donald-trump
Like I said it's used to liberally. So is "nazi". The nazis would shoot children because they were noisy. People doing the "salute" are better classed as idiots/white supremacists.
Example of how extreme the nazis were:
I can't remember names just the story. But one of the high level nazi officers had been sentenced to death.
One of the US jewish prosecutors took pity and went to see him in the cells to ask if he wanted to pass a message to his family before he died. The nazi officer said to him something along the lines of " We will get revenge on you US jews, you will pay a price".
Even at that moment his only thought was still hatred. The brutality was real amongst those higher up.
I have no doubt there are fascists that might be sympathetic to some Trump stances. But he is a lot of negative things, but isn't a fascists.
He is a lot of things but he isn't a fascist. Every move of Trump was scrutinised. There were also a lot of rewriting of what actually happened by the opposition.Thanks for the Vox article Moxjo. It certainly highlighted the range of authoritarian and anti democratic behaviors that Donald Trump was doing up until Oct 2020. Does that give one a hint about why a similar analysis written in 2023 might differ ?
Donald Trump attempted to overturn the 2020 election results and hold power illegally against the constitution. He inspired the January 6th riot outside Congress in an effort to force Mike Pence and Congress to not inaugurate President Biden. The rioters who led the mob into the White house and chased representatives were the "idiots/white/supremacists/fascists" you alluded to.
_____________________________
That was a very thoughtful article. Well worth checking it in full.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?