- Joined
- 30 June 2008
- Posts
- 15,590
- Reactions
- 7,469
Melbourne might have that but as a whole, Victoria is by far the worst performing state on a per capita basis when it comes to bringing money into the country. In next worst place is NSW.
At the other end of the spectrum is WA followed by Queensland.
SA and Tas both sit in the middle. Not great contributors but not the drain that many would imagine either. They’re muddling along, real product for export does come out of both states albeit not on the scale of WA or Qld.
There’s a divide between Australia’s economic basis and its politics.
Not intending to throw stones there as per my previous comment.
Australians need to learn to disagree better.Stereotyping people because they have different views to you, isn't the way forward either IMO.
By the way I wasn't sneering at baristas or service industry/hospitality workers, how much of the Melbourne/Sydney youth work in that sector as opposed to working for CSL/biotech/steel and aluminium? I was stating a fact.
The 10 Biggest Industries by Employment in Australia
AS for not being like America, we are certainly heading that way, the rich get richer and the worker gets screwed.
- Community Services in Australia. ...
- Consumer Goods Retailing in Australia. ...
- Temporary Staff Services in Australia. ...
- Public General Hospitals in Australia. ...
- Supermarkets and Grocery Stores in Australia. ...
- Aged Care Residential Services in Australia. ...
- Government Schools in Australia.
The statistic shows the distribution of the workforce across economic sectors in the United States from 2009 to 2019. In 2019, 1.36 percent of the workforce in the US was employed in agriculture, 19.91 percent in industry and 78.74 percent in services. See U.S. GDP per capita for more information.
I just googled it, your article shows a very similar list, manufacturing and or secondary industries don't get a mention, so as I pointed out the frustration for country people constantly being bombarded with Sydney/Melbourne affordability is understandable, the main employer are either service industry or Government which in turn is the taxpayer.Is this the source of your information SP ? The one I found gave more detail and is similar but with some big differences.
IBISWorld - Industry Market Research, Reports, and Statistics
Expert industry market research to help you make better business decisions, faster. Industry market research reports, statistics, analysis, data, trends and forecasts.www.ibisworld.com
Just keep cranking the interest rates, put a hold on negative gearing and only allow losses to be carried forward against future capital gains. Sydney/Melbourne would soon have a correction.
So then we have to start giving subsidies, so that someone can a fford a house, they cant really afford. Sounds like giving a gambler a loan, on the hope they have a win and can pay you back.Yes, but as we know the politics are that more people own houses than want to buy them, so most of us want prices to stay high or go higher.
It's self defeating in the end, because we can't move to cheaper places these days because there aren't any, even in the regional areas.
So then we have to start giving subsidies, so that someone can a fford a house, they cant really afford. Sounds like giving a gambler a loan, on the hope they have a win and can pay you back.
The great thing about housing affordability which I think is impacting enormously is, you can’t create conservatives if they have got nothing to conserve. If you don’t own a house, you can’t conserve. That’s our natural constituents and we need to get back to that
I agree, this was a very good election for Morrison to lose. Luckily, the left is commonly elected to handle volatile situations. Scullin, Curtin, etc. Even Rudd, who admittedly wasn't elected during a crisis, responded appropriately during the GFC....and Morrison mimicked him during the pandemic because he recognised that it was the best way to handle it.The greatest challenge for the new government in my view will be to keep the lights on and I mean that metaphorically rather than electrically, although it applies to that too. There's an awful lot of things right now where the wheels look to be coming off:
Debt / interest rates
Building industry
Energy industry
Inflation / cost of living
Globalisation as a concept
Supply chains physically
Relations with China and others
Less certain but I strongly suspect the tertiary education sector belongs on the list too.
Or in other words, I'm seeing a greater change in society and that the past few decades' trend of living like kings with no real thought to the consequences is at an end. Time will tell but that's my reading of it, broader change is afoot far beyond just a change of government.
Anyone who thinks we're about to see a boom is in for a shock in my view. There's a lot of issues to be sorted and that's going to take a long time to work through. Many are in for a shock I expect.
To a large extent yes.The economic basis Smurf is highlighting would be (I guess) the huge iron ore, oil, gas and minerals projects. Our manufacturing industry has certainly collapsed. It would be interesting to see how much employment has been generated by the resource industry in relation to it's size.
To a large extent yes.
WA and Qld exports are dominated by mining and exporting essentially unprocessed materials.
NSW and SA it's mixed. Mining's a very definite thing but those two states also have the only steelworks in Australia, they also have other industries of all sorts. There's mining but it's not the only show in town.
Tasmania's somewhat different in that whilst the state does have a mining industry, to the extent the state has a heavy industrial presence it's far more about refining and other forms of value adding.
Iron ore mined at Savage River is transported by pipeline (yep, pipeline not road or rail) to Port Latta, then pelletized prior to shipping. So it's a value added product, not just the ore, being sold.
The third largest electrolytic zinc smelter in the world is in suburban Hobart and that alone is a $1.5 billion a year operation in terms of exports. Right next to that is a fertilizer manufacturing plant, and next to that is the Incat shipyard which exports globally.
Or at the other end of the state Bell Bay is essentially about shipping in raw materials, refining, and shipping out the products and even at lot of that is further processed. Eg alumina shipped in, refined to aluminium most of which is then cast as alloys or used in the production of aluminium powder, then shipped out. Same with manganese. Ship the manganese in, refine it, ship out silicomanganese and ferromanganese. The product shipped out is worth far more than the ore it came from.
Now of relevance politically, well if we just refined all bauxite presently mined in Australia to aluminium, rather than exporting it in raw form or as just alumina as is presently done, well that would completely replace the export value of coal. In round figures, it's an equal value there that we're presently failing to capture.
Much the same with other minerals. The ore just isn't worth that much, the real economic benefit's in refining it or, even better, then using that refined product to actually build finished products.
We could do a lot better economically than just digging up the ground in WA and loading it onto ships bound for wherever. That's not about profit per se, but if you've got $1 billion coming into the country instead of $50 million, and that is indeed the ratio for some minerals, well that additional $950 million is coming into the country and ending up in the hands of workers, contractors, suppliers government, shareholders and so on but it's all ultimately money coming into the local economy from outside.
We could do a lot more than just being a quarry.
The 3 things we will never hear the end of for the next 3 years.Albo reckons he wants to make more things here, so lets see what he can do.
No problem there. Aussie PM's have been making things up for decadesAlbo reckons he wants to make more things here, so lets see what he can do.
No problem there. Aussie PM's have been making things up for decades
The senate looks interesting. If Eric Abetz looses to one of Jackie's jockeys it could be that ALP / Greens / JLN hold 39 seats. That gives the Govt a far less hostile senate than in the past.
While I've never supported a Govt having control of both houses it may need to happen this time if the opposition under Peter Dutton is obstructionist like it was under Tony Abbott when they said NO to everything purely to gain political mileage.
Gotta admit one gets a sense of satisfaction reading this article.
The anti Labor trolls are reacting like they've had their backsides handed to them.In shock and anger over Liberal defeat, Sky News commentators urge party to shift right
Sky After Dark regulars say the Liberal party must distinguish itself by appealing to ‘conservative values that Labor have abandoned’www.theguardian.com
Hoisted by their own petard
How couldn't they see that they were going to lose?Gotta admit one gets a sense of satisfaction reading this article.
The anti Labor trolls are reacting like they've had their backsides handed to them.In shock and anger over Liberal defeat, Sky News commentators urge party to shift right
Sky After Dark regulars say the Liberal party must distinguish itself by appealing to ‘conservative values that Labor have abandoned’www.theguardian.com
Hoisted by their own petard
How couldn't they see that they were going to lose?
They sht all over their base. If they stick Dutton in as leader then they learnt nothing.
Indeed. They are certainly on the same page as Genghis Kkan and if they had their way they would drag One Nation, UAP, anti vaxxers and the rest of the splinter right wing extremists into the party. I thought some of the comments made these commentators was enlightening. As usual Andrew Bolt was at his spitting, snarling bestFor sure, replace one bulldozer with another and they are asking for trouble.
The Sky News people are not Liberals (as media they shouldn't be anything), they are far Right Wing, just short of Neo Nazis.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?