Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Is it still worth getting in on this?

This stock has been analysed to death on this thread. Make up your own mind. I just posted how undervalued it was. I'm surprised you are unsure re: the value.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Looks too cheap. SMM takeover is over 1300m+ valuation of SMM, and it has 65million pounds 50% owned, approx $37 a pound valuation

MTN if it was valued even at half of SMM's valuation would be worth $1.4billion, or around $15 a share right now.

JWBH This is pretty accurate... It's important when you evaluate a company evaluate their competitors... Once you've done that you'll be a better judge...
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

I am confident the management will reject any offer under one billion $. The directors controls more than 20% shares.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

I am confident the management will reject any offer under one billion $. The directors controls more than 20% shares.

Yep no takeover until at least $15 a share. A JV is not out of the question.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Looks too cheap. SMM takeover is over 1300m+ valuation of SMM, and it has 65million pounds 50% owned, approx $37 a pound valuation

MTN if it was valued even at half of SMM's valuation would be worth $1.4billion, or around $15 a share right now.
I don't think this is an accurate comparison Halba. SMM is more than just the IUJV. The rest of their deposits must be taken into consideration, plus the Georgia Basin Project and it has some Fe projects. While their recent JORCs on Anderson's etc were small, they are open. Can't compare this with MTN that simply. MTN have more than Mt Gee too, so it's difficult to do either justice I feel.

Having said that, I would be happy to say that MTN looks relatively cheap by comparison, but it's impossible to put a figure on it.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

I don't think SMM's other deposits and open add much???

MTN has other deposits as u say.

I'm merely comparing them like for like.

All of the bidding for SMM is just coz of Valhalla
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

i don't think smm's other deposits and open add much???

MTN has other deposits as u say.

I'm merely comparing them like for like.

All of the bidding for SMM is just coz of Valhalla

I'm trying to figure out which is better to top up at the moment PNN or MTN.
I wouldn't add any more positions with smm given the conference is coming up
Haven't seen much analysis on PNN so difficult to compare. MTN seems more undervalued but PNN has sino and earlier production schedule with less issues concerning extraction.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Well, we can agree to disagree there. :) SMM is more than Valhalla IMO. That's why the interest.

Unfortunately as of today 12/04/07 over 90% of SMM's resources are at Valhalla. To imagine other deposits is pure fiction.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

I'm trying to figure out which is better to top up at the moment PNN or MTN.
I wouldn't add any more positions with SMM given the conference is coming up.
Haven't seen much analysis on PNN so difficult to compare. MTN seems more undervalued but PNN has sino and earlier production schedule with less issues concerning extraction

lol Uraniumlover time for some lovin of MTN. PNN has 19mil pounds(40% owned), and MTN has 80-90mil pounds of u 100% owned?
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

lol Uraniumlover time for some lovin of MTN. PNN has 19mil pounds(40% owned), and MTN has 80-90mil pounds of u 100% owned?

i think the fact is SMM has had excellent mgt the whole way through the process. they have some great deposits and some huge areas of exploration.

why do you think PDN is going after SMM and not MTN????

that is the big question everyone should be asking. i personally think it has to do with heritage area of mt gee and the yellow footed rock wallaby!
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

i think the fact is SMM has had excellent mgt the whole way through the process. they have some great deposits and some huge areas of exploration.

why do you think PDN is going after SMM and not MTN????

that is the big question everyone should be asking. i personally think it has to do with heritage area of mt gee and the yellow footed rock wallaby!

Good point. why did Sino pick PNN instead of MTN?
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Umm guys china CITIC is invested in MTN... Point is MTN is selling for 1/10 of the valuation of SMM, that sort of difference is a joke really.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Unfortunately as of today 12/04/07 over 90% of SMM's resources are at Valhalla. To imagine other deposits is pure fiction.
:confused:

The uranium they have defined is predominantly Valhalla, yes, but I suppose I should have explained my point better. They have numerous projects that have potential for greater resources and not just uranium. The Areva and PDN offers are not just for a stake in Valhalla.

They have numerous U deposits which are open, and the other U prospects which still being drilled, the new Georgia Basin U prospect, Base Metals, Iron Ore and Phosphate.

Perhaps you should have alook at their web site to see that they actually have. I think these other projects actually do exist.

http://www.summitresources.com.au/

(not holding SMM)
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Good point. Why did Sino pick PNN instead of MTN?

I think PNN arranged a contract to sell uranium well below the current value that's why Sino are desperate to mine... so they can get uranium for a fraction of the price... can someone confirm it please?
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

:confused:

The uranium they have defined is predominantly Valhalla, yes, but I suppose I should have explained my point better. They have numerous projects that have potential for greater resources and not just uranium. The Areva and PDN offers are not just for a stake in Valhalla.

They have numerous U deposits which are open, and the other U prospects which still being drilled, the new Georgia Basin U prospect, Base Metals, Iron Ore and Phosphate.

Perhaps you should have alook at their web site to see that they actually have. I think these other projects actually do exist.

http://www.summitresources.com.au/

(not holding SMM)

Kennas I know these deposits. They are small 3-5mil pounds same as Watta and Andersons.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Umm guys china CITIC is invested in MTN... Point is MTN is selling for 1/10 of the valuation of SMM, that sort of difference is a joke really.

I reckon it's because Summit is now an average Joe Share. It gets far more media coverage than a share like MTN. For instance today Summit was in the business section of the local paper, the business section of sky news on Foxel. It's portrayed as the next uranium mine in Australia to go prod.
Always in Fin market wrap due to it's good returns when compared to non uranium shares like MTN which doesn't get mentioned.
 
Re: MTN - Marathon Resources

Always in Fin market wrap due to it's good returns when compared to non uranium shares like MTN which doesn't get mentioned

MTN a non-uranium share ? :eek:

Oh thats right, you were the guy that wanted to buy BMNOs !! :rolleyes:
 
Top