This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Electric cars?

Would you buy an electric car?

  • Already own one

    Votes: 10 5.1%
  • Yes - would definitely buy

    Votes: 43 21.7%
  • Yes - preferred over petrol car if price/power/convenience similar

    Votes: 78 39.4%
  • Maybe - preference for neither, only concerned with costs etc

    Votes: 38 19.2%
  • No - prefer petrol car even if electric car has same price, power and convenience

    Votes: 25 12.6%
  • No - would never buy one

    Votes: 14 7.1%

  • Total voters
    198
Or buy the cars for the Comm Car fleet and sell them later on as happens now.



 
"Furthermore, manufacturers and dealerships must explore innovative solutions to mitigate concerns about depreciation and residual values. This could involve introducing buy-back guarantees or leasing options that offer greater flexibility and peace of mind for consumers."

Or maybe "modular" designs that allow older vehicles to be easily updated with new technology.
 
"Furthermore, manufacturers and dealerships must explore innovative solutions to mitigate concerns about depreciation and residual values. This could involve introducing buy-back guarantees or leasing options that offer greater flexibility and peace of mind for consumers."
Or maybe "modular" designs that allow older vehicles to be easily updated with new technology.
Updatable products are not a good design for manufacturers to make money, haven't you noticed how you can no longer change the mobile phone battery and they have removed the memory expansion slot, in built obsolescence and subscriptions, the new legalised robbing model.

Throw away phones, laptops, tablets, subscription T.V and soon to arrive subscription cars, in the name of sustainability.
 
A seriously attractive and practical EV. The presenter made a scorching reference to the effective non competitiveness of non Chinese cars at the end of the review. The price/value equation is stark.
 

I agree, to a certain extent. We live in a throw away society, though I do think some things are changing for the better.

Updateable and upgradeable are two different concepts.

My first Apple iMac purchase was a 2009 27in base model with 8GB ram, 8GB graphics card, and a terabyte HDD. I upgraded the RAM to 16GB and used it as our family computer for everything including video and photo editing. It was still being used as our second computer up until Apple stopped the updates recently.
Without updates it became a security risk, however, I gave it to my mother in-law and she is using it to research her family tree.

Phones are the same, they can't be upgraded but they can be updated. When was the last time a phone battery died? I know people that are still using 10 year old iPhones with the same battery.

EVs are the same, upgrades and updates.

The first Telstra Model S have gone through upgrades with the screen and processor. All Tesla's are updateable, and do have regular updates that fix issues, improve efficiency, add extra features, etc.

Modern ICEV are not upgradeable or updatable. Take the Ford Focus and Fiesta built about 2012 to 2016, transmission was a hybrid manual that acted as an automatic. they were failing on a regular basis, the software updates were numerous but still issues arose, parts wore prematurely. Ford Extended the warranty and kept replacing or repairing long after warranty was gone. There was a class action from owners. Ford had no upgradeable fix; they just slowly wore down owners and discontinued the transmission. Those Focus & Fiesta models are now worth a fraction of their true value and are a hit and miss when it comes to reliability.
 
Last edited:
Also, Consider that the standard Locomotive is already run by an electric motor, it just has a big Diesel generator and a bunch of diesel fuel tanks to power the electric motor, But if you went the full electric route, you can remove the Diesel generator and the fuel tanks which makes some room for batteries, so you already get a certain amount of range before you even need to consider adding etc batteries in a wagon.

And if you had the ability to charge as you went using over head wires at certain points you might not even need a battery wagon, or at least not a huge one.
 
Came across the current situation regarding Lithium Sulfur batteries.
Very promising technology. They offer double plus the energy capacity of LiOn batteries and are only 40% the weight.
They don't use nickel, cobalt or manganese. Far better environmentally and cheaper to produce.

They are currently in commercial production.

Lyten’s lithium-sulfur batteries to power Chrysler’s Halcyon Concept car

Lyten reports its batteries offer double the energy density of those made from traditional lithium-ion chemistries due to their graphene cell.

 
Or buy the cars for the Comm Car fleet and sell them later on as happens now.
As. I explained they would only be able to get 80 cars then, vs 3100. and its basically free to the government because its covered by the stamp duty and GST income basically.
 
This article reminds me of Australia's vehicle fleet at the moment. Large SUV's and Utes are dominating our roads, tax incentives are geared towards business having no choice but to buy one to reduce tax.

My business requires one Ute and one sedan or wagon. In 2013 I ordered a new Holden VF Commodore Ute to replace the 1998 Ford XG Ute. About three or four years ago the tax depreciation was over, and the accountant said, "buy a new Ute".

I did not and still do not want another Ute, I like the VF and plan on keeping it for a very long time. Not only is it the last Holden Ute, but it is also a very comfortable and striking SS-V model.

What I need was a sedan for other work-related chores, like driving people around and using it to learn about EVs. However, because sedans are no commercial vehicles the tax incentive is extremely low. My account kept pushing for me to get a "comfortable dual cab Ute".

On principle, I refused, and my business owns a Ute that is Tax neutral, a sedan receiving the minimal tax breaks, and I have to pay more tax than my mates that update to a bigger Ute every 3 or 4 years.

The tax argument is starting to wear me down. I have recently been thinking about purchasing one of those monster dual cab Utes to help with my tax bill. that will be another car t my fleet, because I will never sell the VF SS-V.

What a mad world we live in.

 

The idea sounds good and has been around since 2008 for high altitude flight.

However, there are issues. Including: reduced cycle life and safety concerns. If it is commercially used in vehicles, it is probably several years away from mass production.

 
As. I explained they would only be able to get 80 cars then, vs 3100. and its basically free to the government because its covered by the stamp duty and GST income basically.

"
There is a lot of business in government fleet sales. The largest fleet is that of the NSW Government, which owns or leases over 25,000 vehicles – 4000 of them in the police force alone. The Commonwealth fleet contains over 12,000 vehicles – 7000 passenger vehicles (including SUVs) and over 5000 light and heavy commercial vehicles. Half are leased and half are owned.

Victoria’s VicFleet has nearly 10,000 vehicles. The other states all have fleets roughly in proportion to their populations, and most local government authorities have their own fleets. Brisbane City Council, by far the largest LGA in Australia, has 3800 vehicles. There are well over 200,000 vehicles in government fleets around Australia."
 
C'mon Horace, stop introducing fatcs figures and statistics.
its the vibe you know.
Mick
 
Yes I know that diesel electric trains have electric drive motors, myself and @IFocus were overhauling them nearly 50 years ago, we were also working on the diesel motors as they were used in the power stations in W.A country towns like Exmouth which ran ex train diesels.

The full electric route you talk about, is already in place in most of the World including Australia, I was referring to areas where full electric isn't available or viable e.g the Nullarbor and the Ghan where regenerative charging of the battery will be very limited.
 
I agree, to a certain extent. We live in a throw away society, though I do think some things are changing for the better.

Updateable and upgradeable are two different concepts.
The part that really galls me John, is the subscription model, I look at young people today and see how they are getting stitched up to a lifetime of debt, due to the next pay packet being spent on subscriptions before they have earned it.

The day of saving up to buy anything is fast going and being replaced with the subscription or afterpay sort of model, then all it becomes is which company can stitch the kid up first, it will lead to a cashless society because no one will have any money left over after paying for all the $hit they are stitched up for.
 

Skimmed commutators for 3 to 6 months cough cough segment insulation only a bit of silica cough cough good days

Remember cleaning parts in X55 I was 15 years old.

Not sure you could scale a battery system big enough for ore trains or as you say long distance trains and if you did not sure I would want to be sitting anywhere near it.

VC over heads lines in remote areas could done but would be very high maintenance (dust) I suspect diesel / electric is still the best way to get the job done may become hydrogen / electric in the future still I see trials of a battery operated dump truck so who knows.
 
Skimmed commutators for 3 to 6 months cough cough segment insulation only a bit of silica cough cough good days

Remember cleaning parts in X55 I was 15 years old.
Jeez that brings back memories, first we used to pressure clean with Turco ( I can't remember the exact spelling) then it was banned because it was carcinogenic and replaced it with X55, then that was banned years later as it was carcinogenic also.

Like you say the silica exposure, then in the power stations all the thermal lagging was blue asbestos, jeezus we have done well to still be alive IMO.
 
On long haul like the Nullarbor just hitch up a couple of battery wagons.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...