- Joined
- 28 May 2006
- Posts
- 9,985
- Reactions
- 2
Re: Barack 2008!
Howard followed USA blindly, yet was a monachist.
probably just for pragmatic reasons, I doubt he was a Queen's man in the same sense that Menzies was - Menzies would regularly sing the Queen's praises "I did but see her passing by, and I shall love her till I die" sort of thing.
Labour were certainly heading us towards a Republic - started by Gough who was an avowed republican - and was totally for independent Australian "spirit". And until Gough we didn't even have an Australian dictionary for instance. And with him big investiment in all things Aus, the Arts, etc - as well as pulling the troops out of Vietnam.
Back to the Libs, had Costello been leader at the time of the Referendum, we could well be a republic by now as well (my guess). - just another legacy of Johnny Howard's : - And now we have a chance with Malcolm Turnball knocking on the door (who knows where Nelson stands on this - or on anything for that matter)?
But to my recollection, no-one has ever suggested anything like the US primaries etc to model it on. I'd say most Aussies would cringe at the thought of the various states of Aus carrying on like they do in USA for months and months. At least with only 8 states/terrories, we'd be over and done with - probably one bit "Super-Saturday". (we always have elections on Saturday - gives you something to do on your day off - on your way to the races or the pub or whatever).
Maybe delegation to Parliament to come up with a shortlist - and then another vote. etcetc. - by either the people or a select committee - If the powers of such a President are no more than the current GovGen, then no need to get too carried away sheesh. I mean the GG (even under a new title El Presidente) would still not be capable of telling us we are at war - without partliamentary approval - as Bush can do to the US public. And continuing at war " I don't give a flying f*** what the polls say about Iraq, I'm the president and what I say goes" etc.
Come to think of it I'd prefer even a re-incarnated Menzies to Bush
(I'm sure others who have studied politics could offer more comment). But I'm doubting it will look much like the US system (just imo) - espeially as the President will probably be just a figurehead
PS maye we can copy the East Timorese consitution lol. At least with Zanana Gusmao and Jose Ramos Horta they have some true statesmen to emulate
yes and no - its full of contradictionsWhy not?
Everything else is American.
Howard followed USA blindly, yet was a monachist.
probably just for pragmatic reasons, I doubt he was a Queen's man in the same sense that Menzies was - Menzies would regularly sing the Queen's praises "I did but see her passing by, and I shall love her till I die" sort of thing.
Labour were certainly heading us towards a Republic - started by Gough who was an avowed republican - and was totally for independent Australian "spirit". And until Gough we didn't even have an Australian dictionary for instance. And with him big investiment in all things Aus, the Arts, etc - as well as pulling the troops out of Vietnam.
Back to the Libs, had Costello been leader at the time of the Referendum, we could well be a republic by now as well (my guess). - just another legacy of Johnny Howard's : - And now we have a chance with Malcolm Turnball knocking on the door (who knows where Nelson stands on this - or on anything for that matter)?
But to my recollection, no-one has ever suggested anything like the US primaries etc to model it on. I'd say most Aussies would cringe at the thought of the various states of Aus carrying on like they do in USA for months and months. At least with only 8 states/terrories, we'd be over and done with - probably one bit "Super-Saturday". (we always have elections on Saturday - gives you something to do on your day off - on your way to the races or the pub or whatever).
Maybe delegation to Parliament to come up with a shortlist - and then another vote. etcetc. - by either the people or a select committee - If the powers of such a President are no more than the current GovGen, then no need to get too carried away sheesh. I mean the GG (even under a new title El Presidente) would still not be capable of telling us we are at war - without partliamentary approval - as Bush can do to the US public. And continuing at war " I don't give a flying f*** what the polls say about Iraq, I'm the president and what I say goes" etc.
Come to think of it I'd prefer even a re-incarnated Menzies to Bush
(I'm sure others who have studied politics could offer more comment). But I'm doubting it will look much like the US system (just imo) - espeially as the President will probably be just a figurehead
PS maye we can copy the East Timorese consitution lol. At least with Zanana Gusmao and Jose Ramos Horta they have some true statesmen to emulate