skc
Goldmember
- Joined
- 12 August 2008
- Posts
- 8,277
- Reactions
- 329
Re: Who trades fulltime?
That's employment status. My definition was about whether someone else pays them to do their job. Presumably the self employed account still gets paid to do someone's books.
But have to say you had me there with professional gamblers.
Your definition is a bigger can of worms. Professional attitude? What about sports person with lots of talent but are lazy, late for practice, carrying guns in nightclubs and doing drugs? And you will no doubt agree there are plenty of professionals (be they engineers, accountants or fortune teller) out there who are neither successful nor skillful...
I know a doctor friend who earns more trading then performing surgery. I guess there is no rule to say you can't be professional in more than one area.
Anyhow... enough of this discussion. Call yourself what you like. I will stick with the one that allows me to get cheaper market data.
You nearly had me there, but what about the term professional gambler? I know (knew) many of those.
You imply that only an employee can be a professional.
Is a self employed accountant not a professional then?
That's employment status. My definition was about whether someone else pays them to do their job. Presumably the self employed account still gets paid to do someone's books.
But have to say you had me there with professional gamblers.
That's a can of worms. As Wayne points out, there are many ways to define "professional". My own definition would be a combination - someone successful, skilled and approaches their work with a professional attitude. I imagine the original intention of the term "professional trader" was used to separate the chaff from the wheat, rather than institutional and retail traders.
Your definition is a bigger can of worms. Professional attitude? What about sports person with lots of talent but are lazy, late for practice, carrying guns in nightclubs and doing drugs? And you will no doubt agree there are plenty of professionals (be they engineers, accountants or fortune teller) out there who are neither successful nor skillful...
Also the component of trading returns as income in your annual tax return. In my opinion, if trading represented the majority of your declared income you would arguably be a "professional" trader.
I know a doctor friend who earns more trading then performing surgery. I guess there is no rule to say you can't be professional in more than one area.
Anyhow... enough of this discussion. Call yourself what you like. I will stick with the one that allows me to get cheaper market data.