This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Van Tharp - Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom

Tech
Does this book do as much as Tharp's $1000 home study course? Basically, I want to know if I should invest the $1000 in Tharp's course.
Thanks in advance of your advice.
 
I just bought Tharp's - Trade your way to financial freedom book yesterday. Seems good so far
 
Bin57again said:
Tech
Does this book do as much as Tharp's $1000 home study course? Basically, I want to know if I should invest the $1000 in Tharp's course.
Thanks in advance of your advice.

I havent seen the Course but read the book so cant comment on the course itself.

Personally I'd invest in education with Nick Radge.

He's in Aust,a straight shooter.More experience than most educators.
Has a great support instrument through his site and WILL show you the way to Profit in the market. You'll have access to a real person not just a course.

Email him and ask what he can offer.

Set out what you want to achieve as specifically as you can and I'm sure nick will have something that will suit.
Here I can speak from experience---best I've seen by a mile.
 
I've seen Radge's site and know he's (1) genuine; (2) well regarded. His service seems more appropriate for learning how to enter discretionary trades. How do you build a positive expectancy or system from his advice? How does it work? Do you follow each of his thoughts or do you get an idea of how he trades and try and learn from that?
On the Tharp issue, this is the link for his course. I'm wondering whether anyone has used it? $1000 is a lot but you know what? Time is my biggest enemy. I've been trying to put together so many of the items discussed above by RichKid and others over the last 2 years. The penny finally dropped that the least important element is entry. Tharp's course seems a snip at $1000 when you think most systems could give you that back in days.
http://www.iitm.com/products/systapes/trading-system-home-study.htm
 

My understanding is that Radge has extensive experience in systems trading, not just discretionary trading, although he explains the money and risk mgmt of the latter better than anyone else on ASF imo, just speak to Radge and see what he says or buy his Adaptive Analysis first and see the thread on his book here on ASF. Good luck Binh and don't be eager to part with your hard earned capital so easily!!
 

Bin,
Mr Tharp has probably been my biggest influence, as I have done extensive reading and research on what the guy offers. Regarding his courses, I did not even consider them due to the cost element. His book is good, but there is a lot more you can get without buying his courses - please think about that. I do believe his courses would be very good quality though. Importantly you should read his special report on money management even if you have to buy it - though some of it may not be simple to follow; some is not relevant to the AUS market either. Mr Radge has been a big influence too.

Watch these: http://www.yourproductteam.com/ftp/Rmultiples/player.html
http://www.yourproductteam.com/ftp/STDEV/player.html
http://www.yourproductteam.com/ftp/Confidence/player.html
 


I have know Nick for around 10 yrs.
I can assure you there are few who understand expectancy more than Nick.
Let me also assure you that Nick wont trade anything without a proven expectancy. Where can you get advice from an ex Floor trader CBOT,London and SFE who lives in Australia.

Start simply with a "Positive Expectancy" with regard to Nicks ability as an educator.

Simply ask him how to design your trading around a positive expectancy.
Pay the man and the rest will be up to you to implement!
Bet you get the cost of education back 10 fold in quick time. I did!!! (actually its around 250x).
 

Snake speaks the truth about the cost of the courses Bin! I found those video tutes really helpful as well, very simple. Also look for the 'free stuff' thread on ASF for freebies, I think the money mgmt report may be linked there too.
 
Bin,
From the Van Tharp Institute:

 
Rich/Snake- thanks, you're right, parting with cash may make me feel like I'm getting something but ultimately you have to do the hard work yourself. I'll do as you suggest. Thanks also guys for the links/info.
Tech - I think I'll try and contact Nick Radge. Should I email Trish on his website? How do I approach him? It's not so much that I want to learn about +expectancy. I think I have a grasp (sure, I'm not an expert). What I want to know is how to put together a paper which outlines the system/plan. E.g. the paper would say:
Objectives, starting capital, etc. Then:
1. What is the set-up (let's say some type of breakout).
2. Which instrument - let's say ASX CFDs
3. Timeframe - let's say position (days to weeks)
4. Entry - basically the set-up where you can enter at low risk (define - %, ATR, support/resistance, whatever).
5. Exits
6. Position sizing
7. Risk of ruin, max.drawdown/consecutive losses, etc
I know it's individual but having someone criticise the paper, add input, say "yeh, sure but have you (1) monte carlo'd it; or (2) your data's not big enough; or (3) what about this or that; (4) have you realised this or that?
Sorry for rambling.
Could he help with this do you think? I basically need a mentor!
Best regards.
 
Just contact him through his website.
Either through Trish or direct.
 
I got a lot from Van Tharp's book. I like the Holy Grail stuff at the front, and the system testing and position sizing info really made me search for suitable portfolio testing software (MS / TradeSim / AmiBroker).

Rather than give a method he gives a framework for assessing methods. If you want to develop your own systems and approach to the market then this is a very good book to read. I thought that the title was a little outrageous but there is a lot of excellent stuff in between the covers.

I also wonder if the book outlines 99% of what Van Tharp has to say and all the courses etc that he runs is really just a repeat of the themes in the book. But then I haven't had the urge or need to shell out the dollars for any of his other stuff.

regards
Steve
 
Stevo
Having looked into Tharp's courses a bit more (to be honest RichKid and Snake had already convinced me not to spend the $1000) I think you're right when you say they probably just re-run the themes in the book. For example, I re-read last night chapter 3, the interview with Tom Basso and the section on sorting out your objectives, analysing what pschological issues you have (I've got many - not all trading related!), etc. It's clear that if you do the "homework" the book sets you, you're probably on your way. (Just as a side comment, it bugged me a bit how perfect Basso's answers were. E.g. do you have any weaknesses or problems? None, etc.) Anyway, as I said, I'll keep the $1000.
Bin
PS - Has anyone checked out Van Tharp's simulator/trading game on position sizing? I found it useful. See top right of link headed "Van Tharp's trading game". http://www.iitm.com/
 
Bin57again said:
PS - Has anyone checked out Van Tharp's simulator/trading game on position sizing? I found it useful. See top right of link headed "Van Tharp's trading game". http://www.iitm.com/

I'm downloading it right now.

I know this is naughty, but does anyone have the full version copy of it?...if so, please message me.
 
Has anyone tried Athena, the position size software which Tharp recommends?

Qaz -Sorry I don't (otherwise I would lend you have a copy). If I come across one, I'll buzz you. I found it helpful just playing 1-3 (the latter stages seem a rehash of the principles of 1-3).
 
Hi Bin57
I haven't looked at athena but I do recommend having a look at Stator which has a free download. It is portfolio management software that has a very good position sizing calculator included amongst a lot of additional features. The author is continuously developing the software. It is a great product.

http://www.stator-afm.com/


Cheers

Shane
PS I have no financial interest in Stator. Just a very happy user.
 
I thought that Athena software mentioned in TYWTFF was more like TradeSim or maybe even MSA. From memory it was used to backtest different position sizing strategies.

Stevo
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...