This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

The official "ASX is tanking!" panic thread

I'm no expert, but I do have my take on how this could pan out. Looking at the All Ords in 2007, the index was trending very positively for a long long time before it all of a sudden came tumbling down from its all-time high. Sentiment was overly positive, everyone was in love with stocks, so when the bad news started pouring in, it was a recipe for disaster as all those bulls turned into bears almost at the flick of a switch.

The difference this time is that we are not into all time highs, and we have a very extensive trading zone (..well sideways market) to the left which is caused by long term nervousness. Hence, assuming the stock market does get hit as hard as some are predicting, I reckon the damage this time round shouldn't be nearly as bad as the first dip. Most of the nervousness has already been priced into the market.

Fear not fellows - my two cents - I suppose no one knows what will happen but this is what I think.
 
Just a general comment the if the US addresses their dept problem they will certainly slide into recession, US market fall 40% on average on recessions.

Still we will see how far we go markets can and do over shoot.
 
It's pretty clear few here trade with any real capital if at all.

Seems an unusualy sweeping statement for you t/a,
When you say "trade" are you talking a specific instrument (spi, currency, options, asx) or just in general?
When you say "here" do you mean the posters in this thread or on the ASF forum generally?
What do you consider 'real capital" to be?

Just asking because I sometime wonder if the definitions of "trading" aren't sometimes applied in too limited a perspective in this forum from time to time.
 
I'm actually very surprised that no one knows the reason for the big sell-off. Even today's article in smh couldn't explain why, and papers usually come up with all sorts of reasons explaining market movement.

It's also funny, because they say "the market" knows this, "the market" knows that...but we are the market, so then why don't any of us know the reasons for movement?
 

In this thread.
200K +
Suggesting running ---trading it--a stock portfolio.
 
Just a general comment the if the US addresses their dept problem they will certainly slide into recession, US market fall 40% on average on recessions.

Still we will see how far we go markets can and do over shoot.

The US "austerity measures" will mean nothing. They are cutting $45B this year in an economy that is worth $3,800B, or 0.12%... the impact is negligible. What it does mean, however, is that people can no longer count on further US debt funded stimulus.

Back in the GFC days, most people analysed with hindsight that we didn't have a great depression because of government stimulus. Now that tap is turned off before the US economy can stand on its own two feet... and hence we are running scared.

On a scale that includes the GFC, there's no tangable panic on the Ted Spread,

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/quote?ticker=.TEDSP:IND

The TED spread is intrabank. The last crisis was intrabank where people are worried about toxic assets on bank balance sheets and not knowing who will blow up next.

To measure the scale of the crisis now you need to look at the spread between German vs Italy/Spainish debt imo.


See above. The other thing you need to be aware of is that share prices have fallen from the recent high. What you don't know is whether we are cheap now, or if we were expensive back then.
 
The TED spread is intrabank. The last crisis was intrabank where people are worried about toxic assets on bank balance sheets and not knowing who will blow up next.
A sovereign debt crisis wouldn't feed down to the banks ?

A question, not a criticism of the above viewpoint.
 
Sometimes real men cut and run

The trick is to do it early enough.
Agree. Real women do the same.


Tyler, have a read of Stephen Bartholomeusz's piece which explains the situation clearly.


I'd ask just one question of those who are relishing being able to 'grab bargains' in this storm: What will have actually changed in the global situation on Monday, Tuesday, etc? i.e. why will it be any safer to buy when nothing has changed?

In the GFC governments were able to prop up/buy out financial institutions and provide stimulus to economies.

Now they're pretty much broke.

Even Germany can't go on bailing out the other European nations without risking its own position.

So why would you anticipate a rapid return to postive sentiment?
 
Now that's a really good comment!


What you don't know is whether we are cheap now, or if we were expensive back then.

I dropped a couple of bucks today too, but not really unexpected... perhaps just un-hoped for.....

I wonder what will happen come Monday
 

Problem for the US is to address the dept problem before the bond market makes judgment call the US must pay down its dept levels.

If they chose a glide path its means pretty much knocking off 1% growth (cutting government expenditure and raising taxes) that means recession (current growth well below 2%)







Again bond markets will decide the fate of the Italy / Spain etc, Italy at the moment is looking shaky...........

This has a long way to play out early days yet.

The threat on the world stage remains war rather than financial.
 
Tyler, have a read of Stephen Bartholomeusz's piece which explains the situation clearly

Ok, that's a very good read. But now I ask, why now? Why didn't all this happen before the US debt ceiling was raised?
 
This is the double dip we had to have!

At least that's one way of looking at it...all the great market pull backs have had a double dip and this is clearly the GFC double dip, how far we are into the dip is what's uncertain...i remember the pull back of May/June last year, this forum was full of double dip panic merchants..they were right about the dip just got the timing wrong by 14 or so months.

Looking at the 3 year chart below we are clearly well above the GFC bottom and only a couple of hundred points below Post GFC support, so all in all its just not that bad....my portfolio is down around 12% from the recent highs and my open profits have fallen about 16% ~ what hasn't fallen are my closed trade profits profits that ive taken from buying stocks that are falling and selling when they have risen.
~
 

Attachments

  • xjo.JPG
    144.2 KB · Views: 4
Ok, that's a very good read. But now I ask, why now? Why didn't all this happen before the US debt ceiling was raised?
Tyler, if you have a think about it, you will probably be able to come up with some suggestions. This is more useful to you than people 'telling you stuff'.

Look forward to seeing what you think.
 
A sovereign debt crisis wouldn't feed down to the banks ?

A question, not a criticism of the above viewpoint.

Yes but I guess we are only at the start. And this time the starting point is at the sovereign level.
 
Yes but I guess we are only at the start. And this time the starting point is at the sovereign level.

Unfortunately a large number of banks are holding government dept, its as safe as you know the government.......... the main problem with the GFC was no one knew who was going to fall over hence price of capital went through the roof.

That was solved by governments backing the banks (how did that work out for Ireland?)

Now it gets ugly as who will believe governments are solvent........
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...