- Joined
- 27 February 2008
- Posts
- 4,670
- Reactions
- 10
forex is a lot more volatile then other markets. it can go up and down very dramatically.
having a small profit and a large stop may in fact be acceptable; depending on results.
having a small stop might have the position taken out quite regularly, where as a larger stop loss might allow the market to fluctuate and go up to its take profit.
its kind of hard to explain if you havent watched charts a lot.
but an example for numbers sake.
take profit of 25. stop loss of 100. you would need 4 winners per loser. however you may find that your indicators produce 6 winners per loser - a positive expectancy. as long as your money management is calculated on 100 pip stop loss there is nothing wrong with that system.
in a volatile market, u might enter and it drops 25 points, even 50. however it might only very rarely drop 75 or more points. if your stop loss was 25 (1:1 risk ratio) then your trade might get taken out more then half the time, then rise back up to your original profit level.
a larger take profit might see your position gain 25 points, then retreat 50 after that.
im not sure of the markets you usually trade, and what their dynamics are, but risk ratio and % successful trade together gives an indication of a worthwhile trading system; not the risk ratio in isolation.
im not sure if i expressed myself very well, let me know what you make of my waffle.
i trade the ASX and Gold and often varios indicies
i use charts , hence my question actually . why would one use such a wide stop.
i hear where you coming from re getting stopped out maybe too early but if one was a lil more proficient in charting in the first place maybe they would have a lower % stop because of the perceived support /resistance/pivot points
ok , cheers for the reply and realise forex etc different but still cant find myself drawn to the attraction of needing 4 wins to break even on 1 loss
each to there own , cheers