Fat Prophets - opinions?

[Miner]

Anyone else on here subscribe to FP and think that their Australian Mining reports are written absolutely terrible?

Seriously - these reports wouldn't pass a year 7 English exam!

There's no beginning, middle or end, no story, no introduction - just a jumble of random technical jargon.

Gives me a headache trying to get through them!

I have one month left on my subscription and definitely wont be re-subscribing.

I think if you see the return to its own shareholders FAT has provided will tell you the story - Who can not they teach.

If FAT was so smart to recommend the right scrip then at least they would have made some money for themselves and their shareholders.

The same applies to Bell Potter - Look their share performance.

If you carefully read ASF postings and put the ramping ones into bin, IMO you would get more value for money from your time with ASF. I must forewarn you that it could be an addiction for some people to be on line with ASF forum

 

[eddyeagle]

Yeah their returns are dreadful!

On their website they are still quoting their annual report card from end of 2007! How convenient!

I honestly feel cheated from paying for this service

 

[mad macks]

None of these stock tipping sites like fat prophets,your money weekly etc can add much if any value to people like us.
Do your own research is the best way.
As an earlier post said: Tipping BHP gee you dont need to subscribe to someone to do that

 

[Apache 1961]

Fat Profits

Has anyone had any dealings with Fat Profits weekly newsletter/ site and if so do they think it was worth the money?

Thanks

 

[jsauer]

Performance figures of their portfolios are Incorrect !!!
Had a membership for a while and they tried to convince me to extend as their portfolios is supposingly doing so well and customers too. When I challenged this we discussed some shares which were recommended some 2 years ago but never got a SELL recommendation. So these types of old BUYS have never be SOLD and still sit on HOLD are not included in their performance figures as they are "unrealised losses". When I challenged that view of publishing performance figures without this basket of shares potentially sitting on a big loss the guy told me that their services is not for me and hung up!!! I leave it up to you to judge their services!

 

[burglar]

... I leave it up to you to judge their services!

I know who makes them fat! :