- Joined
- 14 February 2005
- Posts
- 15,183
- Reactions
- 17,172
No unless there are exceptional circumstances.
Unless circumstances warrant otherwise, I think there should be a formal announcement when a name is changed. Obviously that may not be appropriate when giving people a second chance etc.
The way I see it, people on ASF become known for having or lacking knowledge in certain areas. For example, tech/a is known for having skills in trading and for his views on property. Likewise anyone who has been reading my posts will likely have concluded that I have more knowledge in the field of energy than when it comes to stock selection.
That said, many would have knowledge that they choose not to post. For example, I don't post much about my forex trading.
When names are changed it creates confusion so it should be kept to a minimum IMO. A $10 fee sounds reasonable unless there are genuine exceptional circumstances such as a member's true identity having been revealed accidentally, some emotional reason (eg they used their partner's name and have since separated or they used the name of a pet that has died etc) in which case I think the fee ought to be waived on grounds of fairness.
Unless circumstances warrant otherwise, I think there should be a formal announcement when a name is changed. Obviously that may not be appropriate when giving people a second chance etc.
The way I see it, people on ASF become known for having or lacking knowledge in certain areas. For example, tech/a is known for having skills in trading and for his views on property. Likewise anyone who has been reading my posts will likely have concluded that I have more knowledge in the field of energy than when it comes to stock selection.
That said, many would have knowledge that they choose not to post. For example, I don't post much about my forex trading.
When names are changed it creates confusion so it should be kept to a minimum IMO. A $10 fee sounds reasonable unless there are genuine exceptional circumstances such as a member's true identity having been revealed accidentally, some emotional reason (eg they used their partner's name and have since separated or they used the name of a pet that has died etc) in which case I think the fee ought to be waived on grounds of fairness.