- Joined
- 12 January 2008
- Posts
- 7,215
- Reactions
- 17,881
AMA plagued by internal shenanigans looks promising, provided the internal strife has ended (doubtful).
Australia’s biggest smash repairer is running out of chances
AMA Group has gone from one problem to the next. Shareholders are giving it more money and another chance, but this time needs to be different.
The only 2 recent events are the capital raise to pay off some debt and for working capital (never a good sign as this does nothing to improve the productivity of the business), and the directors and Thorney buying shares. Otherwise business (and losses) as normal.What has caused the SP to slowly increase?
AMA Group Limited (ASX: AMA) (AMA Group, the Group) today responds to media speculation in the Australian
Financial Review.
The Group refers to previous disclosures that it is progressing its debt refinancing and expects to finalise the
new arrangements through 2H24. The Group is currently considering a range of refinancing structures. These
options do not include an asset sale.
AMA Group will continue to update the market in accordance with its continuous disclosure obligations.
This announcement has been authorised by the Chair of AMA Group Limited.
Following the trade industry representatives and schools, I see that they have been able to change the opinions of parents directing their kids into Uni degrees and steering them towards trades.
Good pickup @JohnDe I have always seen it as a minnow, even though it is in a growing industry and a very labour intensive.
That bit is interesting. In 1984 an associate and I started a not for profit group training scheme. Even though it became the third largest in Australia after the third year of operation, the main hurdle to growth was the attitude of the patents and schools.
Parents wanted little Johnny to work in the bank instead of getting his hands dirty and schools considered trades as a lower education standard and pushed for uni instead.
Glad to hear it has changed at last. Probably helped by the high wages earned by trades without the HECS debt.
The problem with the industry is pay for mechanics is far too low. There are mechanics with 5 years experience out there only earning $80,000 per year with many senior mechanics with 10+ years experience earning something like $120,000 per year.If the industry can increase the number of qualified workers, they should be able to turn over work faster and increase profits. Following the trade industry representatives and schools, I see that they have been able to change the opinions of parents directing their kids into Uni degrees and steering them towards trades.
The problem with the industry is pay for mechanics is far too low. There are mechanics with 5 years experience out there only earning $80,000 per year with many senior mechanics with 10+ years experience earning something like $120,000 per year.
Why do a 4 year apprenticeship and work hard to progress for all those years when you can just work overtime as a traffic controller or forklift driver and earn the same money?
The real solution is the industry needs to increase wages by about 50% to make it an competitive career choice vis a vis other options available. Its one of the clearest examples of a false skills shortage that there is. If they started paying a competitive salary within 5 - 7 years the shortage of mechanics would dissipate completely.
It reminds me of the bakery industry. Plenty of companies complaining about the shortage of qualified bakers yet often they are paying something around $33 per hour for experienced bakers........ Gee I wonder why nobody wants to do a 4 year apprenticeship to become a baker......
You are just repeating what I am saying. $2000 plus per week plus bonuses equates approximately to the $120,000 a year figure I talked about for senior mechanics. As for $1100 per week that is just woeful and many people with no special skills or qualifications are making more than that.Good mechanics are earning $2000 plus per week plus bonuses.
Average are earning $1100 per
You are just repeating what I am saying. $2000 plus per week plus bonuses equates approximately to the $120,000 a year figure I talked about for senior mechanics. As for $1100 per week that is just woeful and many people with no special skills or qualifications are making more than that.
Even $120,000 or $130,000 a year is not enough for someone highly skilled with 10+ years experience who did a 4 year apprenticeship and has to do daily backbreaking and dirty labour. Compare what a good auto mechanic makes to what a good plumber, a good electrician, a good women's hairdresser, a good fridge mechanic etc make and it becomes clear what I am talking about.
A 25 year old lawyer working in the private sector would probably get $130,000 - $150,000 per year. Besides what do you think a 25 year old mechanic would get? My guess is maybe $70,000 - 80,000 per year. Maybe an experienced senior mechanic in their mid 30s would get $120,000 - $140,000 per year if they are good. By that time a plumber, electrician, builder, hairdresser, etc would probably be earning 50% - 100% more than that at the same age.I know a 25 year old working for the federal government as a lawyer, wage is $110,000. That is the current rate as of today, confirmed with a phone call.
A 25 year old lawyer working in the private sector would probably get $130,000 - $150,000 per year. Besides what do you think a 25 year old mechanic would get? My guess is maybe $70,000 - 80,000 per year. Maybe an experienced senior mechanic in their mid 30s would get $120,000 - $140,000 per year if they are good. By that time a plumber, electrician, builder, hairdresser, etc would probably be earning 50% - 100% more than that at the same age.
Somebody working 60 hour weeks as a traffic controller or forklift driver could in the right situation earn $120,000 per year. Why do a 4 year apprenticeship to become a mechanic for?
You talk about maybes, I’m mentioning facts.
Instead of repeating what you hear, go talk to the people. I not only manage my own business, I’m on a committee for the automotive industry, and I know more than one 25 year old lawyer working in government and private, as well as a multitude of other people in all sectors of the economy.
My original comment was about how the automotive industry has improved in the way it is recruiting and retaining workers, and that there is good scope to earn decent money.
Why do a 4 year apprenticeship? Because of opportunity. Doors open up locally, interstate and overseas. Management roles can be made, business opportunities, the list is endless for people with the right mindset.
If you don’t know, you don’t know.
All I’m saying is the automotive industry doesn’t pay enough for what’s involved in the profession (4 year apprenticeship and hard, dirty back breaking labour) relative to other options people have. Until this changes the “shortage” of mechanics, etc will persist. If you choose to disagree that’s fine.You talk about maybes, I’m mentioning facts.
Instead of repeating what you hear, go talk to the people. I not only manage my own business, I’m on a committee for the automotive industry, and I know more than one 25 year old lawyer working in government and private, as well as a multitude of other people in all sectors of the economy.
My original comment was about how the automotive industry has improved in the way it is recruiting and retaining workers, and that there is good scope to earn decent money.
Why do a 4 year apprenticeship? Because of opportunity. Doors open up locally, interstate and overseas. Management roles can be made, business opportunities, the list is endless for people with the right mindset.
If you don’t know, you don’t know.
All I’m saying is the automotive industry doesn’t pay enough for what’s involved in the profession (4 year apprenticeship and hard, dirty back breaking labour) relative to other options people have. Until this changes the “shortage” of mechanics, etc will persist. If you choose to disagree that’s fine.
Pay for almost every profession has gone down over the past 30 years when you properly adjust for inflation.pay and work satisfaction has improved.
Pay for almost every profession has gone down over the past 30 years when you properly adjust for inflation.
If you mean pay in relative terms relative to other professions I would also be skeptical of that and would need to see more evidence before I believe your claim.
July 1990, the Australian economy had just entered a severe recession. Real GDP slowed in the first half of 1990, and then began to fall in the second half of the year. The rate of unemployment in mid 1990 was around 6¾ per cent but rose sharply in the following year. The rate of inflation was around 6 per cent, but was about to decline quickly, to levels not seen since the early 1960s. For many, the decline in inflation was completely unexpected, and many believed for several years that it could not last.
Hello and welcome to Aussie Stock Forums!
To gain full access you must register. Registration is free and takes only a few seconds to complete.
Already a member? Log in here.