This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.
Re: XAO Analysis



I will point this out (Your post) which echo's the sentiment of most who just dont get it.

Let me ask this question.
If you analyse a company fundamentally and find it undervalued buy into it and find in 3 months its lost 20-50% of value--that analysis is wrong?

Or a Triangle pattern fails,or a pennent or a breakout fails or a trendline is broken or an M/A is broken or a candlestick pattern fails---these then are simply in accurate voodoo with little value?

ALL analysis simply supplies a setup---an opportunity to START or END a trade.
E/W is in some respects no different but in other respects very different in that ALL counts are continually DYNAMIC and can be updated from bar to bar.

Its not a flaw but an amazing advantage.
If people can understand that there is NO RIGIDITY and when disproven doesnt mean the worlds fallen in or the analysis has NO VALUE---then you'll actually begin to UNDERSTAND how to apply the analysis and never post a post like that above
 
Re: XAO Analysis

I heard there is another school that is based around Glenn Neely teachings. Is it any worth to read his book? I am content around the classic style but I try to keep and open mind to any new idea."

Classic Elliot is 100 times easier to understand than Neely's book.

Unless you are seriously bright give it a miss.I found it so hard I gave up, but I am not that bright.

I know somebody ( a professional Trader) who also didn't complete the book.


Neely has also made some bad calls in the past and I believe is using a "new technique" called Neely river I think.
 
Re: XAO Analysis


1. no the fundamental analysis is correct , its the same company with the same bottom line , same intrisinc value etc
, it was the wrong use of TA or whatever calculation was used to come up with your entry price that is now 30% different

2.no just the same as EW analysis in the regards that it was wrong and it caused a failed trade/missed trade .no voodoo involved

i think you have already answered my point that it was no different to any other form of TA in form of accuracy and by some of the calls here ,by those using it were just as way off the mark as non users of it when it came to direction/pivot points/support etc etc .
 
Re: XAO Analysis

Jesus, she was sick today! S&P falling too, global indices are looking absolutely HORRIBLE, so much for my short-term bounce, shows the power of anyone making 'predictions'. No point, if it hits new lows, good chance it's going lower.

Oh god, the EW debate is back, just as the new lows points above, I don't see what is wrong with HH, HL etc. Much easier
 
Re: XAO Analysis


Yeah, agree on both counts MRC.

I have only been using EW manually as a range finder, ie to identify potential swings and their degree based on my other FA and TA analysis.

But I have another 'conspiracy' (sorta) theory or maybe at least a self fullifillng prophecy theory.

With all the algirythmic and market predicting software out there today, maybe people are going with and getting what they expect from their software... self fullfilling prophecy.

But having said all that, I think we are at another significant juncture that should unfold shortly ie the USDX falling again (Details on the where is gold going thread)
 
Re: XAO Analysis

With all the algirythmic and market predicting software out there today, maybe people are going with and getting what they expect from their software... self fullfilling prophecy.
hello,

no, the reason we are in this mess is because of mechanical algorithmic trading which left an opening and least point of resistance to something that has not and could not be tested before

thankyou,
chopstalebbots
 
Re: XAO Analysis

Seems like a number of different markets are in the midst of the early stages of an Elliott Wave 5 this evening, breaking out of wave 4 triangles.

Same patterns are evident in the DJIA and even AUS buck!

Dow looks like 7200 is a possibility based on a measured move and Aus buck 59-60. Phew! Who would have thought hat 12 months ago!
Robert Prechter believes triangles are the penultimate pattern, not the ultimate or final pattern.

It could be that stock markets are going to get a hefty global bounce in November. There are at least three events on the horizon that could provide the boost.

First, if Obama is elected, you have the end of uncertainty about the U.S. election (and some highly irrational optimism that things will now be different, better, and nicer). Second, you'll get a new stimulus plan from the Democratic Congress in the U.S., which should give stocks a bit of a kick. And third, the big G20 meeting in Washington Kevin Rudd is headed too. Something that looks and feels good should come from that.


The only other possibility is perhaps the if the final Prechterian wave 5 truncates, at this stage given the fear that does not look like happening


All the best

STONER
 
Re: XAO Analysis

My opinion: the "govt deposit g'tee" is causing retirees in particular to redeem managed funds in droves.

Causing a major capitulation.

wont stop till gains and dividends are consistently stronger than cash rates.
 
Re: XAO Analysis

Dow futures down 500/5.7% right now, Euro markets down over 6%, Asian markets down in the vicinity of 10%, is this still panic or the denial stage? An interesting article on CNBC:

Wall Street Moves Quickly From Panic to Despair

 
Re: XAO Analysis

Europe down -8:0% plus, S&P500 futures down -6.5% which is 'limit down', could we see the circuit breakers in action tonight? Or will the Fed and treasury reach into their ever shrinking bag of tricks and pull something out?
 
Re: XAO Analysis

Watching the zaniness now..

UK 3rd quarter GDP -0.5%

 
Re: XAO Analysis

Europe down -8:0% plus, S&P500 futures down -6.5% which is 'limit down', could we see the circuit breakers in action tonight? Or will the Fed and treasury reach into their ever shrinking bag of tricks and pull something out?

Wouldn't be surprised to see it fall hard tonight, to be honest, but what tricks are there left to pull now? From Bloomberg:

S&P 500, Dow Average Futures Reach `Limit Down' Level

 
Re: XAO Analysis

Ouch, this is getting stupid. Probably end up 200 points by the end of the night?

Who knows in this current environment????????????
 
Re: XAO Analysis


closed hard on that red line end of this week GP, and ominously has pushed well through in futures and CFD's after the bell.
Nice support a little further down on the big green line though - can't see it pushing through that as easily.
 

Attachments

  • XAO 3monthly.doc
    30.5 KB · Views: 47
Re: XAO Analysis

lol classic post.
Gotta admit I was expecting a higher green line........

Futures @ around 190 atm..

Going to be an interesting monday..
Can't see us getting past support @ 3400.

Not on monday anyway.
 
Re: XAO Analysis

My opinion: the "govt deposit g'tee" is causing retirees in particular to redeem managed funds in droves.
Undoubtedly true, but I suspect many retirees who have been following advice to "hold on, it will all be fine" may have reached the stage where they no longer have any faith in that suggestion and would have cashed out anyway.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...