- Joined
- 28 March 2006
- Posts
- 3,566
- Reactions
- 1,309
Thank you Boggo for that helpful response.
The program has superb graphics and seems to be very sophisticated. I have also viewed the videos on the Stock Doctor website.
I have a couple of questions
- I have essentially a blue chip portfolio and for someone who is not planning to do much trading, I guess its value would then be mainly in monitoring the portfolio for potential problem areas. As the cost is say $1600 pa, I am wondering if this is a worthwhile investment in that type of situation.
- I noticed in tinhat's post that he referred to Thompson Reuters Consensus forecasts. Have you found these helpful?
Many thanks
Stock Doctor doesn't provide you with a strategy or timing. Their model picks up the occasional stock that turns out to be a disaster, such as FGE and BCI, due to events that lie outside their methodology. That said, they do provide more qualitative analysis of company outlook these days and they do provide warnings where the analyst thinks there is risk in the outlook for the company. Speaking with the analysts is very helpful
From your posts you have obviously been using Stock Doctor for several years. As a matter of interest, have you noticed whether Stock Doctor has often (or ever) issued concerns or warnings on say any top ASX 100 stocks?
Another is CCL which they threw out as a borderline star stock in May 2013 when they gave a downgraded outlook at their AGM.
$1600 for a 12 month subscription...that's a sizable chunk of money.
Cant help but think that if one could afford to pay 1600 annually for this service then you already have money and probably don't need help getting more.
On the other hand, my paper loss from the CCL purchase was $7,000 in one transaction, which potentially makes Stock Doctor pretty cheap
$1600 for a 12 month subscription...that's a sizable chunk of money.
Cant help but think that if one could afford to pay 1600 annually for this service then you already have money and probably don't need help getting more.
I look at it as cheap insurance for my SMSF, there hasn't been a year yet when it has not paid for itself.
Seems like an expensive way to get a robo-advisor?
With an account of 100k it would be the same as paying 1.5% in fees.
Trying the 10 day membership now too.
Hopefully it bears some fruit.
The yearly subscription seems steep for someone who's new to trading.
The All. Ords. last peaked in April 2015 and many stocks have been stuck in a long term sickly range so you could be buying at the top of a market up swing. It would be interesting to know when the star stocks are announced, like at the top of an upswing or at apparent under value. Everyone's portfolio goes underwater at some stage.How the overall market can be positive or flat with my entire portfolio plummeting just baffles me; considering these securities are apparently a result of sound fundamentals analysis. Perhaps I'm just really, really unlucky.
How the overall market can be positive or flat with my entire portfolio plummeting just baffles me; considering these securities are apparently a result of sound fundamentals analysis. Perhaps I'm just really, really unlucky.
I've lost 8% of my life savings, wasted $1500 on this meme service, and missed out on a guaranteed 4% I would have made if I'd just left my money in an online high-interest savings account.
View attachment 69040
Well, after paying $1500 for the annual subscription and sticking with purely star stocks, I've lost 8% of my life savings, wasted $1500 on this meme service, and missed out on a guaranteed 4% I would have made if I'd just left my money in an online high-interest savings account.
The only reason I didn't make even heavier losses is because I sold out of a couple of positions early.
How the overall market can be positive or flat with my entire portfolio plummeting just baffles me;
Perhaps I'm just really, really unlucky.
But this will be my one and final foray into the securities market
I can't think of a rational reason to renew it.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?