In a house in a residential area closeby to a well-funded public school and local facilities. Thats where most human beings live.
Jail is not the place for people who are mentally ill.
Once upon a time we had functional psychiatric institutions with secure wings where people whose violent behaviour made them unsafe to be at large were kept. Better for them and better for the community.
The whole experiment of 'treating mentally ill people within the community' has been a dismal failure.
Story on the midday news just now that some US states are looking at abolishing the death penalty in favour of life imprisonment.
Apparently it's related to finances, more specifically, how the global economic crisis is stretching the budgets of US states to the extent that they can no longer afford the death penalty.
The claim is that execution costs more than life imprisonment. Very difficult to believe.
Pity we don't re-introduce the death penalty here in Australia. I can't see how it wouldn't be a lot cheaper than keeping those animals in jail for many decades.
Anger after child rapist walks free
Posted 28 minutes ago
Updated 21 minutes ago
Map: South Grafton 2460
The New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) may heed pressure from both sides of politics to appeal against a decision to let a man who raped a four-year-old girl walk free.
The 24-year old man pleaded guilty last month to breaking into a house near South Grafton, on the state's north coast, and sexually assaulting a girl as she slept in 2007.
He was given a two-year suspended sentence in Sydney's Downing Centre District Court, after spending at least 14 months in remand awaiting his trial.
NSW Attorney-General John Hatzistergos says he is seeking urgent advice from the DPP on the prospects of an appeal.
Shadow attorney-general Greg Smith SC says the "manifestly inadequate sentence" needs to be overturned.
"I just can't understand what possesses someone to give such a light sentence," he said.
A spokeswoman for the DPP says the department is waiting for remarks from the sentencing judge and will consider an appeal within the next few weeks.
From ABC, 3 Mar. 09
CHILD RAPIST WALKS FREE, DPP APPEALS
The New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) will appeal against the two-year suspended sentence given to a man who raped a four-year-old girl in the state's north.
The 24-year-old man pleaded guilty in a Sydney court last month to breaking into a house north of Grafton and sexually assaulting the girl as she slept in 2007.
He was allowed to walk free from court last month, after spending at least 14 months in remand awaiting his trial.
State Attorney-General John Hatzistergos says the DPP will argue that the sentence is manifestly inadequate.
"The maximum penalty that is available for sexually assaulting a child under the age of 10 is 25 years. The standard minimum sentence is 15 years," he said.
"It's important that those signposts are kept in mind because that reflects the strong abhorrence that the community has to crimes of this nature."
Shadow attorney-general Greg Smith SC also spoke out against the sentence this morning.
"I just can't understand what possesses someone to give such a light sentence," he said.
Earlier today, a spokeswoman for the DPP said the department was waiting for remarks from the sentencing judge and would consider an appeal within the next few weeks.
In addition to addressing inappropriate sentencing, and considering changes to the law, don't we have to also look at why violence is increasing exponentially?
So why is this happening? Have parents failed to set boundaries about behaviour? Do kids as young as this get the violence concept from TV?
.
It certainly has, Julia.
Yet the authorities refuse to face up to that fact, continue to close down the psychiatric institutions and attempt to rehabilitate the inmates and put them back in the community.
The story of the Yorkshire Ripper is typical of the thinking here in Australia. Some moron who is big on professional qualifications but small on common sense, decides that some horrifically violent offender like Peter Sutcliffe, (the Ripper) can function normally while he's on medication.
And so a recommendation is made that he be released back into society.
Such a stupid decision doesn't take into account that many of these people just don't continue taking their medication unless they're incarcerated and are under constant supervision.
I have a relative who once worked as a mental health nurse in the Acute Psychiatric Unit of a large regional hospital. She can tell countless stories of patients who were readmitted to hospital time after time because they stopped taking their medication as soon as they were released, or in some cases got on booze and illicit drugs while taking their medication, went completely off their heads, and committed further crimes.
It almost beggars belief that those who are responsible for deciding what to do with people, continue with policies and strategies that are just not working.
From ABC 6 Mar. 09
NO JAIL FOR CANADIAN BUS BEHEADER
A mentally ill man who beheaded and then cannibalised a fellow passenger on a Greyhound bus last year cannot be held responsible for his actions, and will be housed indefinitely in a secure mental institution, a Canadian court has ruled.
Justice John Scurfield agreed with lawyers who said Vincent Weiguang Li, 40, was suffering from a major mental illness when he attacked a sleeping passenger on the bus in July last year, stabbing him dozens of times in the back and chest.
Li later held up the severed head of the victim, Tim McLean, and as police watched from outside the bus, he continued to mutilate the body and eat some of the remains.
Mr McLean was on his way home to Winnipeg from a job as a carnival worker in Edmonton, western Canada.
Dr Stanley Yaren, the only witness for the prosecution, told the court that Li said he heard voices from God in his head telling him to kill McLean. He described Li as a "decent person" suffering from untreated schizophrenia, with a strong chance of recovery.
"He thought that Mr McLean was an evil entity, that if he didn't kill Mr McLean, Mr McLean would kill him," said Li's lawyer, Alan Libman.
"If Mr Li, because of a mental illness, believed that he was defending himself, he didn't know what he was doing was wrong.
"And if someone doesn't know what they're doing is wrong, we don't punish them."
Debra Parkes, a law professor at University of Manitoba, noted that Li will stay indefinitely in a secure psychiatric hospital, subject to reviews, and this might give him a longer period in custody than a murderer sentenced to jail time.
The court also heard of a 2005 incident in which police picked Li up walking down an Ontario highway and Li said he was "following the sun."
He was briefly hospitalised and given medication for schizophrenia, but he denied he had a problem and left the hospital.
-Reuters
From ABC 6 Mar. 09
SCHIZOPHRENIA SUFFERER NOT GUILTY OF STABBING MURDER
By Rebecca Barrett
A New Zealand man has been found not guilty by reason of mental illness over the stabbing murder of a 60-year-old man in north-west Sydney last year.
Sixty-year-old Josef Maskiewicz was found stabbed to death inside his Castle Hill home in February last year.
Clinton Dion Moko Moko was charged with Mr Maskiewicz's murder and extradited from New Zealand last March.
At the start of his Supreme Court trial, 35-year-old Moko Moko pleaded not guilty by reason of mental illness.
The prosecution has told the court the Crown case relied on admissions of guilt made by Moko Moko to his wife and psychiatrist.
But Justice Bruce James found Moko Moko did not know what he was doing because his reasoning was defective due to a disease of the mind.
Moko Moko is being treated for paranoid schizophrenia and will stay in jail until the Mental Health Review Tribunal decides on his future.
FOUR JAILED FOR SETTING MAN ALIGHT
From ABC 6 Mar. 09
By Liz Hobday
In Victoria, four Mornington Peninsula men who set an elderly man on fire have each been sentenced to five years in jail.
Tyson Jessen, 19, Richard Findlay, Allan Walters, and Adam Taylor, all in their 20s, threw petrol on mentally-ill man Irving Plotkin, and set him on fire.
Mr Plotkin was critically injured and his Rosebud house, south-east of Melbourne, was destroyed.
They pleaded guilty to arson and conduct endangering life.
Judge Barbara Cotterell said their crimes were horrifying and the attack left Mr Plotkin scarred and disfigured.
The court heard Mr Plotkin's eyelids and lips had to be removed, and it was highly likely his ears would need to be amputated.
Judge Barbara Cotterell said their conduct was disgraceful and horrifying.
Jessen, Walters and Taylor broke down as they were sentenced but Findlay showed no emotion.
The court heard they had been threatened in jail and were under protection.
They will serve a non-parole period of three years.
Co-defendant James Dingle is yet to be sentenced.
VETERAN BASHED FOR 50 CENTS, ATTACKER JAILED
From ABC 6 Mar. 09
A Sydney man has been sentenced to at least 15 months in jail for bashing an 83-year-old war veteran over 50 cents.
Sutherland Local Court heard 30-year-old Kristopher Cowie approached Ernest Evans at Carringbah, in southern Sydney, last October and asked for the money.
The court was told Mr Evans was punched at least three times in the face when he refused to hand over 50 cents.
Cowie was found guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm last October.
He was sentenced to a maximum of two years' jail today.
The 30-year-old will spend a minimum 15 months behind bars and be eligible for parole in April 2011
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?