Nice ramble but illogical.
Priests can tell about crimiaal activity, but not about "embarrassments" that's their choice. They should be treated like anyone else under the law. If an individual becomes aware of a criminal act, the law says they have to report it. Why should priests be immune from that ?
"The government has decided to attack God". The churches behaviour has become so separated from the Bible, especially the teachings of Jesus that they cannot claim to represent the Bible even for those who choose to believe that book, let alone secular society.
We do not live in a caliphate!No, afaik, and from what i just read today, anything said DURING confession can't be relayed.
Australia has one law for all.We live in a world with multiple law systems, such as Catholic cannon law, secular law, Judaic laws, Islamic laws , etc ... It's a democratic feature to give each freedom , and works out for the best.
Maybe not a surprise in the Catholic Church, but not condoned in the real world.You shouldn't freak out too much if you see bad examples from time to time. Not that much of a surprise.
We live in a world with multiple law systems, such as Catholic cannon law, secular law, Judaic laws, Islamic laws , etc ... It's a democratic feature to give each freedom , and works out for the best.
And not to mention Mary Mackillop, who started heaps of schools for children.
I suspect it was more the other way around in that it was the wealthy who bought indulgences to absolve themselves of sins and go straight to heaven.One thing that he wanted reformed was the idea that priests had to be paid to pray for ordinary,mostly illiterate people.
We do not live in a caliphate!
It is vile that priests can hold the lives of sinners above those sinned against.
And how exactly is that Christian or Gods will?
Australia has one law for all.
Maybe not a surprise in the Catholic Church, but not condoned in the real world.
But you are right, we should not be "surprised", we should be outraged.
Our society rightly rails against some Sharia practices which are anathema and so too should we against any religion that disrespects individual freedoms.
The law of the land takes precedence of any religious "club rules", otherwise anyone calling themselves a religion could make up their own rules that infringe on the rights of others.
This ministry is God's idea,
Do you think Scott Morrison, a religious man it would seem (from some of those clips out there), would obey the law of the land if it was opposed to his personal morals?
Prove it.
Can you prove it's false?Prove it.
Not really. The land isn't a land just for non-believing peopleIf he doesn't obey the law of the land which he is a participant in creating, then he shouldn't be Prime Minister, he should go into a monastery.
Confessionals are only "critical" to the Catholic Church: They are the perfect solution for the perpetuation of a multitude of guiltless crimes!I didn't mean to have freedom for Sharia law. My wording wasn't good there. Nonetheless Christian democracy calls for certain religious freedoms to be allowed.
As per your logic priests should then reveal all criminal offences, and probably other things too, in which case this critical ministry would cease , or be inhibited. That's not going to work. And God is far above any human being, in terms of worth. This ministry is God's idea, and so cannot have human interference.
Well worth mentioning Mother Mary Mackillop. A very down to earth woman who started a new religious order to specifically educate the children of the poor and working class.
She also didn't put up with any xhit. In 1870 she heard about a Catholic priest who was sexually abusing children. She made a formal complaint to the Bishop. The priest was sent back to Ireland; Mother Mary was excommunicated ! Shoot the messenger indeed.
https://www.abc.net.au/am/content/2010/s3021839.htm
A little bit of history.Martin Luther was a Catholic priest until he made a trip to the Vatican.He was shocked by what he saw-the orgies and licentious behaviour.He then started the breakaway Lutheran church .Also the start of the reformation.
One thing that he wanted reformed was the idea that priests had to be paid to pray for ordinary,mostly illiterate people.He taught that people had a direct line to God,bypassing priests.
This,to Luther's horror,led the peasants to believe that they were as good as their masters and led to social unrest.These results were soon forcibly put down etc
Confessionals are only "critical" to the Catholic Church: They are the perfect solution for the perpetuation of a multitude of guiltless crimes!
As to your idea that somehow "this ministry" is Gods idea, it wholly conflicts with the very same Abrahamic God of Judaism, Christianity and Islam who do not need it.
Many at this site who are atheists marvel at the ingenuity of religions to get such mixed messages from God, but it does explain why they babble on.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?