This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Recovery or Dead Cat Bounce?


Oh, you've heard.

See, I've also 'heard' (the little quotation mark things make it OK) that everything I own is going to skyrocket, and that you all need to buy in before you miss the boat forever. See how that works?
 

The fact that you think day traders have CGT expenses and high brokerage expenses show that you have no idea. Use IB and brokerage can be around US$1.
Your probably trading on comsec paying $20 commissions, holding stocks that are losing value so you can hit the 12 month holding period, and carrying a lot of risk over the weekend. Been there, done that, not my cup of tea
 
Often, traders don't pay CGT, they pay ordinary tax - because they're actually traders as a profession, and not investors.

Try paying the bills with a buy and hold strategy mate, you'll be living on the street in a month.

you cannot discount ordinary tax though. so isn't that pretty much the same thing as paying full tax like as if it were CGT not held after 12 months?
 
Your probably trading on comsec paying $20 commissions, holding stocks that are losing value so you can hit the 12 month holding period, and carrying a lot of risk over the weekend. Been there, done that, not my cup of tea

nice assumption there in bold. you act like you know my investments so well.
 
you cannot discount ordinary tax though. so isn't that pretty much the same thing as paying full tax like as if it were CGT not held after 12 months?

Yes, and? Do you not pay full tax on your personal income as well? You don't seem to appreciate that some people are able to make a fantastic living off of trading - without needing to have any other additional sources of income. Many traders have a portfolio for the future as well, but it really is apples and oranges.
 
nice assumption there in bold. you act like you know my investments so well.

But it's alright for you to make assumptions about daytrading? You obviously have very little understanding of how daytraders actually operate.

you cannot discount ordinary tax though. so isn't that pretty much the same thing as paying full tax like as if it were CGT not held after 12 months?

Did it occur to you that traders that trade for a living are actually running a business and therefore can claim business expenses and pay tax like any other business?

No matter what profession you are in, if you make money you are going to pay tax.
 
From Crikey, this is just about as good a place to post this as anywhere else -

 
here's the graph
 

Attachments

  • 090618-Fed-Balance-Sheet-6172-111df784-6d7d-48fa-bca2-c2e512f4bce5.jpg
    34 KB · Views: 357

what assumptions have i made? all i said was that there are a lot of tax and brokerage expenses added up together that could have been used to compound. that's fact.

in relation to claiming deductions. so what you're saying is that day traders incurring these expenses can claim these as a deduction, therefore it's good enough? expenses don't matter because you can claim as deductions right? in reality you are only claiming your tax bracket only on those expenses, the rest could have been compounded and doesn't change the fact that the whole expense gone could have been used to compound. why don't we all ask our tax accountant to up his tax fees because essentially it's the same thing as what you're saying. "we can claim it anyway as a deduction"

you can't even halve that income on your TR. therefore u're paying more tax than someone who - over the long run - gets the same yearly average compounding ROR as a day trader and defers their tax liability
 

No what I'm saying is it is the same as running any business - there are expenses involved and they pay tax like any other business.

How you can compare a daytrade who draws his income from the the markets to your longer term investment approach is beyond me. Apples and oranges really. Anyway I'm done with this conversation.
 
I'm sniffing a challenge coming on (looks for TH).

I'm yet to see one of these junk talkers (obvious newbs) step upto the plate.

Know where the hills are IV? Start running.
 
If your making your investment/trading/business decisons based on tax alone, then you are way off. Produce a profit first, worry about tax later.

A very wise associate of mine years ago also said the same thing.
 
good lord

gimme a break

yes i daresay those investors from 2 years back are thanking there lucky stars they invested instead of running a shorter term trade approach

great tax benefits lol oops ang on, they may need a profit first

anyways horses for courses ........have noticed one thing tho ,............. very easy for so called experts and guru,s that appear here to slag off any other strategys they obviosly cannot make work themselves instead of having a deeper look at why they cant

being classed as a trader has quite a few beneficial advantages tax wise actually and i suggest you go see a GOOD accountant if pain persists
 
This is a dead cat bounce. Will take another two years for all the **** to settle.
 
IntrinsicValue

What a legend

I bet he knocks back high paying jobs

He's scared he'll pay more tax
 
Possible Golden cross on S&P 500

http://www.fnarena.com/index2.cfm?type=dsp_newsitem&n=062F7428-1871-E587-E1C0FE716BAC517E

Of course it may just bounce off and go down. Still something to watch for.

Thanks for that moXJO, it will be interesting to see which way it breaks. Seems like it can do anything except go sideways, so I guess that will be what happens.

I am curious, how many of the bearish posters on this thread missed the rally and are now waiting for a drop, just to get back into the market?


Regards
Ray
 
"Here, kitty, kitty..... got a nice surprise for ya!"

*BLAM*

*Meee-ooooowwwwwwccchhhh!*

 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...