So_Cynical
The Contrarian Averager
- Joined
- 31 August 2007
- Posts
- 7,467
- Reactions
- 1,469
I have almost 30,000 KSC that I bought years ago at an average of $2.88, so I am behind big time. I expect the SP will improve when KSC either winds back unprofitable business, or that business improves, plus, the WA business should do well.
but barriers to entry substantial
Are there really though? Perhaps there are some scale advantages but are fixed costs significant compared to say, the airline industry?
Transport seems more like a typical market with no barriers to entry (margins are low as are roe roa). Efficiency is the only thing that matters.
When i wrote that i was considering the obstacles a new start up would encounter...the fact that there are already many players in the industry with many decades of experience and relationships built on trust and reliability...the fact that with such small margins anyway there would seem to be little incentive for a new player to burn cash for years just to get to break even.
I think there are significant barriers to entry....i mean if you had 5 or 10 million bucks and wanted to start a business would you go out and buy 6 or 7 trucks, set up depots in 3 or 4 state capitals and take on 2 dozen or so employees?
For me scale and experience = efficiency
Adding to this the returns of logistics companies such as KSC, QUB and TOL all average around the high single figures to low teens in terms of return on capital over the last decade (obviously QUB hasn't been listed for this long). I don't know many other road-based companies that are listed, but AIO has never been fantastic either for comparison to a similar industry. Operating margins are also generally single figures.To bring it back to a more relevant example, all those truck companies whose drivers speed (saw somehting about Scott on the news tonight), drive while drug affected to meet impossibly tight deadlines etc would indicate that there is very little in the way of competitive advantage or barriers to entry.
My average is a bit less than $2.88 but im way behind too, only a matter of time till these sorts of business turn...i was surprised the KSC share price didn't take a hit today on the Scott transport speed limiter tampering, as reported on the news yesterday and again tonight.
Because of the links between Scott transport and KSC
I think if anything it just highlights how tough it is to be profitable in this industry over the long-term.I wonder if the fact that 1st Fleet went into administration last week has anything to do with the renewed interest in KSC. One man dead may be another man's bread.
I think if anything it just highlights how tough it is to be profitable in this industry over the long-term.
Nice move on Friday to close at $1.30. I recently sold my private holding to my SMSF, which also held KSC, so there are now 30,732 shares in that portfolio. I think KSC will improve, and it pays a reasonable dividend of 10c a year, so it suits an SMSF.
I wonder if the fact that 1st Fleet went into administration last week has anything to do with the renewed interest in KSC. One man dead may be another man's bread.
How long does a truck last on the road? I'm looking at their cash flow statement and if you figure that over the business cycle motor vehicle capex will approach depreciation then the dividend looks unsustainable and/or there will be a capital raising at some point. Unless the asset is written down to zero and still has a fair bit of life left in it.
I know that K&S actually sell some unwanted trucks and Trailers thur the K&S web site
They are currently selling a 1990 model Western Star Prime mover...if they have had that from new then id say with some confidence that its been depreciated to $0 a long time ago.
http://ksfreighter.ihub.ninemsn.com..._Int32|1||p_StockPrice_Decimal|1&TabID=804306
Wow! There's an answer!Although they say they depreciate trucks at rates of between 5-40%. And they probably capitalise some of the major mechanical work that gets done.
(5th-May-2012) I picked up a few more KSC shares on the 23rd of March at $1.10 (and only now realised i didn't post) thinking i didn't want to let this second major dip get away from me like the first one did a few months before..so far the timings been perfect, brought my average price down to $1.76 and elevated KSC to my #4 portfolio stock by value.
(12th-April-2010) has announced a Share Purchase Plan at a reasonable discount, i figure $2.56 per share is a reasonable discount considering KSC has been going sideways between 2.70 and 3.00 for 6 months.
(April - 2011)In today at the crazy low price of $1.62 :cowboy:
Almost 3 years into this/these trade/s and finally completed today at $2.07 ~ total of 8 parcels sold, a combination of trades and dividend reinvestments, 4 winners and 4 losers, freed up a heap of cash and overall realised a trade profit of 7.14% reducing my average price per share held to $1.46
Overall a good result thanks to aggressive bottom buying, 1 entry that fluked the bottom and 2 dividend reinvestments either side of that bottom at $1.12 and $1.14 ~ gross dividend yield going forward of 9.8% with the last 2 dividends factored forward...any increase of course would up that yield to over 10%
What more could a long term, yield chasing, low cost entry and averaging contrarian ask for.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?