This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

J.D. Salinger dies at 91

Jump to new

Garpal Gumnut

Ross Island Hotel
Joined
2 January 2006
Posts
13,775
Reactions
10,534
Salinger has passed away. I read Catcher in the Rye when I was 13. What an experience.

Any of you guys/gals who haven't read it should.




http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obi...ies/books-obituaries/7096097/JD-Salinger.html


gg
 
One of the most overrated bits of "literature" ever forced on schoolkids. IMHO.
 
Not exactly in the same league, but Robert B Parker, author of the Spenser novels, died last week.

<sigh>
 
Atlas79 said:
One of the most overrated bits of "literature" ever forced on schoolkids. IMHO.
Click to expand...

Read it again mate, you may have been too mature when you first read it.

If you were forced to read it , then that is an abomination, I agree.

You're not from North Korea or a godbotherer are you?

Forcing kids to read things is not the way to get them to appreciate the contents.

gg
 
I read it as an adult and did not find the least bit cutting edge or important a trust fund baby's running away for 24 hours, encountering no situations that would make the nightly news if they happened in real life, and decrying the adult world to be "phony". (Not from N Korea nor do I bother God. I hope, anyway. You'd have to ask him, her or it.) And I disagree. If you can force kids to eat veggies, you can force upon them books that will do them some good too.
 
I really rated his short stories, "For Esmé - with Love and Squalor, and Other Stories"
Just something a little disturbing about them...something lurking behind the story
similar to "To Kill a Mockingbird"
But on the other hand "Catcher in the Rye" never did much for me, but like you say G.G sometimes it depends on when you read a book and what you take away from it.
I Remember reading Updikes "Run Rabitt Run" and initially I thought it was rubbish - just seemed to be a story about everyday life but when you read it ten years later, it reads like a book of someone looking back at you ten years ago....(does that make sense.???)
 
Howard Zinn popped his cloggs at 87, within a day or so Salinger, with a fairly balanced obit in the NYtimes, no doubt with a cheer from those who also fear Chomsky. They were young once 'But that was then this is now'...
 
ghotib said:
Not exactly in the same league, but Robert B Parker, author of the Spenser novels, died last week.

<sigh>
Click to expand...
I echo your sigh, Ghoti. Mr Parker's novels kept me entertained when nothing else could.


Makes complete sense, kgee. I re-read "Catcher in the Rye" about a year ago and realised how much our social environment has changed. Holden Caulfield was probably one of the first anti-heroes. Since then, of course, they're too common to be interesting.
Also, the language in those days made the book a stand-out.
 
I am with you GG. That book stuck in my memory for years. It was as weird as its author proved to be in real life. I did English Lit at school (which was one of my greatest scholastic mistakes and had to read that book). The best bit about the class was it was jam packed with all the best looking chicks. And only about 5 of us lads.

Catcher had one of my most favourite quotes..
"As sensitive as a toilet seat"
Loved it and is the only book I have re-read.
 
Like Julia, I only read Catcher about a year ago. One weird mother of a book, on the surface an anti-social phony declarer, the deeper you go the weirder Holden was. A true reflection of life and society, past, present and future.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...