Interestingly I flicked though Penfold’s book on the SPI this weekend, but only in a very cursory fashion. It was interesting to see his T/A experience using Elliott Wave, then the move to multiple higher lows/lower highs – almost paralleling some of McLaren’s work. I must get around to reading the other parts of the book more deeply though (I gather you think it is worthwhile?).
lesm said:Hi Magdoran,
Some interesting points in your post.
The first thing I thought of, after reading the above, was with regard to a number of aspects of eastern philosophy as they relate to psychology.
One that readily comes to mind is 'to see things as they really are'. Another, which I will paraphrase is learning to step back from our emotions and focus on what we are doing and doing it well rather than on thinking about whether we may win or lose. Uncontrolled emotions cloud our thinking.
Western philosophy, beliefs and approaches to living whether everyday, sport or business really don't prepare people well for dealing in the market, as not all people are adept at stepping back from their emotions and remaining objective. A lot of people don't cope well with losing, but is something that they need to learn to deal with in the market.
Most successful traders have lost money in the markets, some more than once, but they have learnt from their mistakes and have gone on to be the success that they are. In real terms, how many traders are born and how many have learnt their craft?
The market is a mindless, emotionless and conscienceless beast that gives no regard as to how we may or may not feel. We need to be mindful of these characteristics and prepare ourselves to participate in this unfeeling environment. For a whole range of participants this will require a level of behavior modification. To cope or survive we need to learn the necessary survival skills and think about an approach that enables us to achieve this. We need to refocus the mind to consider performing the act of trading, without worrying about whether we will win or lose, but to do the best we can or to do the right thing, based on the information or knowledge we have. There is a need to bring our fears under control, otherwise we create our own errors or make our own mistakes, as the emotions are in control. Too much subjectiveness is detrimental to developing a consistent trading approach.
lesm said:Imposing a view on the market. The market really doesn't really care what view we impose on it, it's an abstraction created by humans. As participants we hold one of many views and unless we can control the market, which we can't, it's an exercise in futility. We may hold a view, as yet unproven, but only time will tell if we have the right view, at any given point in time. It is how we determine a view as to the potential direction of the market or the stocks that make up the various universes, realising that we may not always be right, that makes the difference. Including the further realisation that we are one of many participants and that there is an opposing view to whichever view we have.
lesm said:Colouring the charts. We need to learn to see charts as they really are, no more no less. This takes practice and experience to develop an objective and unemotional interpretation of charts. This needs to become part of the subconscious, as more often than not the more people study a chart the more likely they are to see what they want to see. Yes, further study may reveal nuances or intricacies in the chart, but the basis for looking at the chart in the first place needs to have some foundation. If you have the capability, try doing and auto-display of the ASX 100 on a five (5) second display and only select the charts that are of interest to you for a more in-depth analysis. Of course there may be some that don't select that may do well, but who has time to examine and analyse each individual chart representing all the stocks on the ASX, or anything from the ASX 500 down to the ASX 50.
lesm said:Bullish vs bearish. The predominant trait of most people is bullish, as it is easier for people to understand making a profit from rising prices. Some of the trading clichés, such as buy low sell high contribute to this. Clichés may sound good, but without understanding what they mean or how to apply them counts for nothing. It is a foreign concept for most people to be comfortable with making money from losing money. For those people, it is a skill or approach that they will need to learn. They also need to learn that simply converting a number of trading systems from trading the long side to trading the short side will not always work.
lesm said:Knowing what to look for. In all probability is a learned skill and requires practice. Trend following is the easiest, but to trade in all sorts of market conditions people need to learn an effective approach to trading in different styles of markets or using different styles/approaches in a single set of market conditions, if they wish to fully exploit the market. In any given market only a particular percentage of stocks are trending. To simplify this the remainder of stocks will be ranging or in some form of consolidation pattern or moving sideways. To exploit opportunities requires the ability to use different trading styles in any given market, as well as knowing what to look for and how to apply it. It also about understanding the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches. For example, a number of trend following systems will start to fail and/or experience high drawdowns, as market volatility increases.
lesm said:Prediction. Probability gives us an approach to dealing with uncertainty, but no guarantees, otherwise we might as well just use darts to select stocks. The quality and reliability of application has a dependency on the user of the method and how much work they are prepared to do to prove/disprove and refine their methods. Of course there will be an element of quesstimation, but whoever said trading was an exact science. There is a need to learn multiple skills, as well as to manage our own psyches, as well as to understand market behavior and how to apply those skills.
Thanks Les,lesm said:Hi Magodran,
I found elements of Penfold's book useful, it also helped some other thoughts I was having fall into place or clarify them.
You can usually find something useful in a range of books, sometimes I am just looking for an alternative view or approach or a clue to help resolve or refocus an issue.
Good to see that you are still posting the chart and following up on it.
Will give Daffy some reading when he gets back, must be busy this weekend, as he has been very quiet.
Cheers,
Les.
It's Snake Pliskin said:Magdoran and Les where did you guys get "Phantom of the Pits"?
Magdoran said:I’ve been working on this stuff for so long now that it’s easy to lose perspective since it’s second nature to me, and sometimes consider that it must come over as jargon and gobbledegook. I’d hate to be boring the pants off everyone with it.
Duckman#72 said:Ah Magdoran......"since it's second nature"........that's just where I want to be!!!
As for "boring the pants off everyone"......rest assured I love this thread, your shared knowledge and your fencing with Tech.
Duckman
lesm said:Snake,
I have included a link to the softcopy below:
http://www.trading-naked.com/library/Phantom_of_the _Pits.pdf
Cheers.
Magdoran said:Love it Wayne!
I actually think you look the most handsome in the 3rd photo.
Your last fancy dress party no?
Magdoran
Hey Duckman#72,Duckman#72 said:Ah Magdoran......"since it's second nature"........that's just where I want to be!!!
As for "boring the pants off everyone"......rest assured I love this thread, your shared knowledge and your fencing with Tech.
Duckman
barney said:Hi guys, Two reasons for this post; Firstly to see if I can get the chart on the screen, and secondly it is a good example of a downward breakout (short term ) (thats how I would describe it anyway) , and a good opportunity to get feedback from the experienced members on the forum on the opinions of a "novice" in "training"
What I see/know about the stock, and why I would/will be "watching" it over the next few days/ weeks;
1) Just had a downgrade of resource at current mining op. (1 third)New mine has been commissioned to produce starting this month I believe. Fundamentals of the Co. basically unchanged apart from that.
2)Large SP drop on big volume (initial spike has eased, volume decreasing slightly, and the spread of the SP has lessened) ........... Indicates to me further drop is likely, but looks to be slowing.
3) Old support area of around $1.35 will now become the point of resistance against the Sp rebounding, but imo this will be a "weak" POR due to the small amount of time/ volume the SP traded in this area. 2nd and third POR's also very weak, which indicates to me, that if/when the SP does reverse, it should have little trouble rebounding strongly.
I would be looking to "possibly" trade this stock in the future if I get confirmation of a positive reversal after the current downtrend has proven to be over. Imo this will most likely happen because the size of the downtrend seems to be an "over reaction" to the news recieved.
Gold prices, (according to those that know more than myself) are tipped to be
a good "long term" investment, so, if this Co. has a resource upgrade (which the management indicates is likely in the future), I could imagine the SP returning to much higher prices.
Of course, if the SP does not reverse. or simply "stagnates" at its new lower level, then no trade would be considered.
Hope the charts "post up" ............... Any opinions and constructive comments/criticisms appreciated ............... Thanks, Barney
( PS The second POR was off the left of screen at about $1.45 ; also short time span.)
It's Snake Pliskin said:Good Morning Barney.
Too much analysis in the charts! Line chart?
Distribution - there is plenty of supply there.
Hi barney,barney said:Hi guys, Two reasons for this post; Firstly to see if I can get the chart on the screen, and secondly it is a good example of a downward breakout (short term ) (thats how I would describe it anyway) , and a good opportunity to get feedback from the experienced members on the forum on the opinions of a "novice" in "training"
What I see/know about the stock, and why I would/will be "watching" it over the next few days/ weeks;
1) Just had a downgrade of resource at current mining op. (1 third)New mine has been commissioned to produce starting this month I believe. Fundamentals of the Co. basically unchanged apart from that.
2)Large SP drop on big volume (initial spike has eased, volume decreasing slightly, and the spread of the SP has lessened) ........... Indicates to me further drop is likely, but looks to be slowing.
3) Old support area of around $1.35 will now become the point of resistance against the Sp rebounding, but imo this will be a "weak" POR due to the small amount of time/ volume the SP traded in this area. 2nd and third POR's also very weak, which indicates to me, that if/when the SP does reverse, it should have little trouble rebounding strongly.
I would be looking to "possibly" trade this stock in the future if I get confirmation of a positive reversal after the current downtrend has proven to be over. Imo this will most likely happen because the size of the downtrend seems to be an "over reaction" to the news recieved.
Gold prices, (according to those that know more than myself) are tipped to be
a good "long term" investment, so, if this Co. has a resource upgrade (which the management indicates is likely in the future), I could imagine the SP returning to much higher prices.
Of course, if the SP does not reverse. or simply "stagnates" at its new lower level, then no trade would be considered.
Hope the charts "post up" ............... Any opinions and constructive comments/criticisms appreciated ............... Thanks, Barney
( PS The second POR was off the left of screen at about $1.45 ; also short time span.)
MichaelD said:Barney,
Myabout BDG.
Why would you be considering BUYING a stock that is going DOWN?
Profitable traders:
Stock price going down = SELL
Stock price going up = BUY
Unprofitable masses:
Stock price going down = BARGAIN
I tend to agree with Snake in that there is a bit too much analysis on your chart. My analysis of BDG follows;
1. Price going down.
2. Breakdown 9-10 with volume spike
3. Materials sector is weak
This signals a short sell on 10-10.
Disclaimer: I hold a paper short in BDG as above (I'm currently paper trading my shorting system until I can prove that it has a positive expectancy).
The FAR more important questions for you to answer are;
1. Can I apply a positive expectancy system to this observed pattern?
2. Can I handle the fact that there is approximately a 50 - 60% chance that I will NOT profit from this trade?
3. Can I handle the fact that in fact the vast majority of my analysis can be shown to be no better than a coin toss?
The entry is merely the starting point, the least important part of your trade.
Magdoran said:Hi barney,
You late night bandit you!
Looking at your chart gives me a headache. It looks like spaghetti. How you can see anything beats me. Agree with Snake and Michael here, there’s way too much going on.
Remember what I said about gizmo’s obscuring the chart? Well this one is so busy with lines everywhere even I had to struggle to mentally filter them out when I was looking at your chart. I can’t help but feel it has to be even more distracting for you since you’re new to this.
Ok, in my view, most people don’t know how to use moving averages effectively at the best of times (of course there are some people on this forum who do). They are a lagging indicator, and in many cases in my view tell you what is happening well after the event has happened, and what the chart was telling you was a probability if you cared to look at it and not the indicator at the time.
In strongly trending markets, this is not so much of a problem, the main trend is easy to see, and if you take longer term trades, you can do quite nicely without much angst, even using moving averages.
In consolidating and creeping markets this all changes, and moving average/oscillator based traders who don’t understand how to use these indicators get whipsawed in and out of trades – the death of 1000 cuts.
Moving averages used the wavepicker uses them in my view is an effective use – he displaces them and ties them into cycle analysis (very important in resource stocks).
Distribution:
Ok, the concept about distribution is that the smart money is exiting in an orderly fashion, and don’t want to upset the price too much as they exit taking profits or reducing exposure, or transferring capital to a different prospect, prior to a sell off of the underlying.
Snake is talking about pattern analysis, and he’s seeing a pattern that he’s interpreting as distribution – the smart money selling off in an orderly fashion before a sell off. When you get a consolidation pattern this often precedes a decline, often a fast and sharp one, hence if this is your view, these present great shorting opportunities.
Broad Market Influences:
Now, there is some danger in looking at the materials index at the moment in isolation. Resources are driven by commodities. If you’re going to trade resource stocks, you have to be aware of the markets that affect them. So, you need to be aware of which metal futures or oil, or gold, are relevant. Then you need to be aware of currency movements.
I remember a trading colleague and I went long LHG a few years ago purely from a bullish gold chart, only to see LHG move down. We couldn’t figure this out at first, but then I realised I hadn’t done my due diligence, and forgot to include currency movements. The US dollar was falling faster than gold was going up, so in net terms, the value to LHG was going DOWN, not up! Just think about these kinds of things when you’re doing your analysis.
If you look at JBM recently, why do you think this has been so bullish? Look at the nickel futures and compare it with other metals (particularly copper). Nickel has been very bullish of late, and the USD has been strengthening. What do you think this might do to the market perception? Of course you could just trade the JBM chart, but watching the relevant commodities and currencies may give you an early warning of opportunities and threats.
I think it is great what you are doing by the way. Saying what you see, then thinking about other perspectives. A great way to learn. But be patient, and filter the many views, and take what you can see. It takes time to learn how to read charts believe me. You never really stop learning.
Regards
Magdoran
P.S. How’s the guitar!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?