This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Half a million refugees in Australia from 2 islands

This is gold, a pleasing diversion from what i should be doing. keep it up you guys.
 
Yeah go for it guys, get it out.

But really how can you knock Kiwis? They try hard, like Seth Efricans do and like Aussies do in London, New York - it is the nature of immigration. People have to try harder to settle into foreign lands, they ain't got no connections, school tie and other in-bred crap. So bring in the immigrants and

Love yah maths Roddick, but the fundamentals are flawed - stagnate and wither until we evolve to a self sustaining lifestyle, i.e. reduced consumerism, enjoy old things, stop making stuff unnecessarily complicated. Alas won't happen in my lifetime
 


Who's Roddick? Obviously not talking about me Dinger...

ahh you are so cynical....we won't stagnate. change, but not stagnate. i know you weren't there, but remember when the plague wiped out 2/3 of europe?

not much stagnation there... just an adjustement.

my maths isn't flawed. i don't make those kind of mistakes. heaps of other mistakes, but my logic is sound.

always nice to read your posts zinger.
 
Sorry dude with all the banter going back and forth, got mistaken with Roddick.

We can do without another plague and I could handle some enlightened sustained living, but our economy isn't there yet so we need growth, which comes in the form of increased consumers, producers and talent. All assuming we have a decent system which Australia has, and not corrupt inefficient like most countries with spiralling growth rates (pre Aids in some).
 

absolutely no offense taken. as i said, i like reading your posts.

but there are some fundamentals of our economic model that are incongruent with reality. the most obvious one is the assertion that populations can increase infinitum and the assumption that the market and therefore environment can deal with the by products of economic activity in a similar manner.

both of these assumptions are of course false.

therefore a low birth rate is not such a bad thing, a reduction in the population likewise. a rationalisation of economic modelling is inevitable.
 

These are so typically Australian concerns. It's always someone or something. Roll the clock back 20 years and substitute Japanese for Chinese and communism for Islam and voila! It's the same but different.

A Chinese takeover? You mean like the Japanese takeover of the 80's? The bus loads of turists who would turn up and buy all the membership places at our golf courses?

Immigrants and foreign investment are attracted to our country because of it's success. Whether we become victims of our own success or grand beneficiaries depends on how we respond.

If you've got enough time to be concerned with these things why not allocate part of your think time to brainstorming all the reasons why what you are concerned about is not likely to become a reality. I'd be surprised if you don't come up with at least two or three convincing arguements against yourself.

Don't you have any faith in Australia's ability to absorb and assimilate immigrants?
 

I think the tide has turned in favor of the immigrants, they seem to almost outnumber the traditional Aussie now.
We cant reproduce fast enough or afford more kids thanks to the cost of living/housing.

I hope you're right but it different now to how it was, it's accelerated dramatically.
 

Why the implied "us and them"???

You do understand that the current system is geared toward an expanding population? This isn't just in Australia, it's the entire western world. Practically no-where are the birthrates sufficient to support the welfare obligations to future generations. We are all competing for and striving to integrate immigrants, or we're all working until we're 80.

On the original topic, which immigrants are likely to be the easiest (read: most cost efficient) to integrate into Australia? That would have to be the east islanders, wouldn't it?

FWIW I'd like to see an Australian Union in my lifetime. Quite a force to be reckoned with I would think
 

Interesting perspective, competing for immigrants.

Hope it all turns out ok but I and many others are starting to feel like we're outnumbered by immigrants in our own country.
 
Interesting perspective, competing for immigrants.

Hope it all turns out ok but I and many others are starting to feel like we're outnumbered by immigrants in our own country.

Don't worry Burnsie, you have nothing to fear, it only take a generation to fully assimilate.

I take it you live in a area with a high new migrant population, bit like what i imagine Carlton/Fitzroy was like in the 70's so i can sort of see why you're anxious.

Must say the cultural diversity Melbourne offers is a nice thing but i don't believe in growth for the sake of growth, i.e to drive economic activity and consumption.
 

Hi Julia,

This is not my understanding of the way the Reciprocal Agreements work, in respect of Unemplyoment Payments, in particular.

A reciprocal agreement covers when and how nationals from foreign countries can recieve a welfare payment, if in the reciprocal country.

There is no "balancing of the books"...ie billing or payment between each country.

As Australia has a very generous welfare system by world standards, this is beneficial for citizens of certain countries, especially New Zealanders, British, Italian and Greek citizens.

I believe there are many more Kiwis living in Australia recieving Unemployment benefits than Australians on UB in NZ.

So regretably I inform you, to the best of my knowledge, and notwithstanding your own and many others taxation contribution, that from a welfare perspective, Australian taxpayers ( such as yourself), are indeed subsidising the welfare situation of NZ.

This does not take into account Age Pension, where the payment is made primarily by the country of origin.
 
You have obviouslty never lived on the Gold Coast ( not that the Aussies there have much of a brain either I must admit ) but the amount of kiwis there is amazing.

What annoys me is they keep saying NZ is better, well go back bludgers.
So they don't have a right to say they like their birth place better?




Nope now you’re twisting it, you attack a whole section of the community which indirectly leads to me. Now I think it just came across differently to what you intended but
I will never be convinced that Kiwis here are employed or not involved in crime and are not aggressive, because I have lived in areas where there are a lot of them.

comes across as another kick in my nuts
Where is my love SourD? Where is my love

BTW I have no problem with you having a difference of opinion.


Back on topic
asxgorilla actually brings up some good points. But is the govt aiming for high numbers too quickly when it comes to immigration? I'ts not like public services are being upgraded fast enough to keep up with demand.


AWG I'm sure your right in regards to the Reciprocal Agreement. Just don't think half a million of us are on the dole:
 
For reasons known only to yourself, Soft Dough, you are obviously determined to be unreasonable and thoroughly unpleasant.
Anyone who makes such aggressively unrealistic generalisations is not worth arguing with.
 
Well, it could have changed. Definitely used to happen on a reimbursement basis. I recall a few years ago there was a stand down period introduced so that Kiwis could not get unemployment benefits in Australia for, I think, two years. That would have cured a lot of the problem I guess.

As Australia has a very generous welfare system by world standards, this is beneficial for citizens of certain countries, especially New Zealanders, British, Italian and Greek citizens.
Well yes and no. At age pension age if I were still to be living in NZ, I would receive their non-means tested National Super payment. I would become eligible for this on the basis of all the years I paid taxes in NZ. But because I'm not eligible in Australia for the Australian Age Pension via it being means tested here, I miss out on the basis of the reciprocal agreement between Australia and NZ.

I believe there are many more Kiwis living in Australia recieving Unemployment benefits than Australians on UB in NZ.
Well probably, purely on the basis that more New Zealanders want to live in Australia than vice versa. I don't think that necessarily translates into too many of them being on the dole, however, particularly if as I suspect there is a two year stand down period.
You might be able to find some statistics to back up your suggestion/belief.

Again, you might find some statistics to support this suggestion.
I don't know. I would suggest that there are plenty of New Zealanders working in Australia, contributing to the economy and not 'bludging', to use a favourite Ocker term.



This does not take into account Age Pension, where the payment is made primarily by the country of origin.[/QUOTE]
 
As a Scots who came here in 92 its always been something that has stood out for me, how the ozzie media has been able to ignite these kinds of debates.
I left the Uk to get away from this kind of crap only to find it alive and rampant here in the form of Pauline Pantsdown and her clones who fly the Union Jack and think that anyone who is not a WASP is a danger to their whitebread way of life.

Which to my way of thinking is more than a little hypocritical.
Lets invade that country take its minerals and then complain when any other population wants to come live in the country that we invaded.

"By Jove Roger it's just not on we got it 1st!"

I guess Australia being invaded, and taken over by a race who have always had a deep seated mistrust of anyone not themselves, managed to bring that with them. Funny really since the UK itself was invaded and shaped a few times that way.

Then again... some Indonesian maps still have Australia named as New Indonesia maybe you should be worried eh? maybe it's all a plot to take the country by stealth?? Maybe K-Rudd is a Chinese sleeper agent?? oh no we're doooooooomed I tell you! dooooomed!

Incidentally, since when where Kiwis "refugees"?
 


ROFL Vizion
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...