- Joined
- 2 May 2008
- Posts
- 24
- Reactions
- 0
Mate,
the copper hill property is a dud! Very unlikely they will get a developer on board, not economically feasible, it's too risky to think Au a and Cu will remain at an economically vialbe price for this
FIRST POST EVER HERE!
According to a 17-year study conducted by investment firm, Tweedy, Browne, low-valuation small-cap stocks dramatically outperformed their large-cap counterparts between1963 through1980. "One million dollars invested in the smallest fifth of the companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange, which were priced in the bottom fifth in terms of price/earnings ratios, would have increased to $19,500,000 over the 17-year study period," Tweedy, Browne concludes. "By comparison, $1,000,000 invested in the largest market capitalization stocks with the lowest price/earnings ratios would have increased to [only] $8,107,000 over the same period. During the period, the annual investment returns for the market capitalization weighted and equal weighted NYSE Indexes were 7.68% and 12.12%, respectively. One million dollars invested in the market capitalization weighted and equal weighted NYSE Indexes wou ld have increased to $3,518,000 and $6,992,000, respectively."
Overall, that's not too shabby a result for small cap stocks. But financial media coverage tends to ignore small-caps and focus primarily on large caps. That's too bad. Investors are missing out.
The Russell 2000 might not be shooting sparks at this very moment, but it is generally keeping pace with the year over year progress of the much bandied-about Dow Jones Industrial Average.
My point is this: Anyone you encounter who exclusively pushes the large-caps doesn't truly have your best interest in mind.
There are tons of strong deals out there in the small-cap world. Those who hype the large caps to the detriment of all other classes are the groupthink-ers and "conventional wisdom" followers who say Goliath could never lose and that nice guys always finish last.
LOL, now we have Goldman ´s going off YT ´s tips. he he.Young trader,
I respect your opinion too, infact I really like reading your analysis, as it has value to it.
I just want to put point forward, instead of only looking at the upside.
I actually work at Goldmans myself, and we just aren't into speccys here, so i guess its ingrained in me a bit to look at the high risks. But I'm trying to get into adding some to my portfolio now, so really looking around at the poo brigade haha
So, you may not like this stock because it ´s ´risky ´but that is where the big money seems to be made IMO. It ´s obviously where big money can be lost too.
Projects
Copper Hill Copper + Gold, 100%, NSW
JORC 133Mt's@0.31%Cu + 0.28g/t Au = 1g/t + Au Equiv
Now although the deposit is low grade its gold equiv grade is not too bad ie 1g/t Au, but the main Pros and Cons are as follows
http://www.goldencross.com.au/properties/copper-hill/default.html
Pros
- Exisiting infrastructure, rail, town, workforce, equipment etc etc
- Very low waste to ore ratio 0.6:1 this reduces the cost of hauling dirt, for example an operation grading say double Copper Hill but had a waste to Ore ratio of say 2:1 would be less economical as alot more dirt is required to be moved etc etc SO THIS IS A MAJOR FACTOR
- Copper Hill copper concentrates contain no deleterious elements and may attract a price premium. (further metallurgical test work is required)
- Current NPV indicates a very very large return
- Located in Australia = very safe and mining friendly nation to operate it albeit with Environmental green tape
Cons
- Huge Cap Ex = requires the backing of a major partner via either direct farm out or perhaps even offtake with commodity groups etc
- Low grade ore = high cost production (partially offset by low waster ratio) but = requires premium base metals prices to be profitable
NPV
Also here you will find the companies NPV calcs http://www.goldencross.com.au/properties/copper-hill/default.html
It is clearly shown that even using a $600 AUD Gold price vs Current $950+ and a $2.65 AUD Copper price vs current $4.20+ an 8Mt p.a. operation will generate an NPV of $270m ($600m - $330m)
Now even if GCR farmed out 80% of this project to be free carried, that would still = a Net Attributable NPV of $54m = 8.5c
IGV for interests sake
Copper Hill contains 1.2Moz's Gold 420kt's Copper
using current spot prices ($1000 AUD gold and $4.40 Copper)
I.G.V. Copper Hill = $5Billion
I'm not saying hey Copper Hill is worth Millions I'm just saying given the balance of the pros and cons I think you can just cross of Copper Hill as adding value to GCR, but do agree to really take the project seriously the funding via a JV or Offtake needs to be established.
p.s. There is also the EXPLORATION POTENTIAL at Copper Hill, I'd say they are looking to find higher grade satelite ore bodies etc
Hey Refined Silver,
Yeah I guess when looking at Copper Hill their just trying to be cautious.
Projects
Copper Hill Copper + Gold, 100%, NSW
JORC 133Mt's@0.31%Cu + 0.28g/t Au = 1g/t + Au Equiv
Now although the deposit is low grade its gold equiv grade is not too bad ie 1g/t Au, but the main Pros and Cons are as follows
http://www.goldencross.com.au/properties/copper-hill/default.html
Pros
- Exisiting infrastructure, rail, town, workforce, equipment etc etc
- Very low waste to ore ratio 0.6:1 this reduces the cost of hauling dirt, for example an operation grading say double Copper Hill but had a waste to Ore ratio of say 2:1 would be less economical as alot more dirt is required to be moved etc etc SO THIS IS A MAJOR FACTOR
- Copper Hill copper concentrates contain no deleterious elements and may attract a price premium. (further metallurgical test work is required)
- Current NPV indicates a very very large return
- Located in Australia = very safe and mining friendly nation to operate it albeit with Environmental green tape
Cons
- Huge Cap Ex = requires the backing of a major partner via either direct farm out or perhaps even offtake with commodity groups etc
- Low grade ore = high cost production (partially offset by low waster ratio) but = requires premium base metals prices to be profitable
NPV
Also here you will find the companies NPV calcs http://www.goldencross.com.au/properties/copper-hill/default.html
It is clearly shown that even using a $600 AUD Gold price vs Current $950+ and a $2.65 AUD Copper price vs current $4.20+ an 8Mt p.a. operation will generate an NPV of $270m ($600m - $330m)
Now even if GCR farmed out 80% of this project to be free carried, that would still = a Net Attributable NPV of $54m = 8.5c
IGV for interests sake
Copper Hill contains 1.2Moz's Gold 420kt's Copper
using current spot prices ($1000 AUD gold and $4.40 Copper)
I.G.V. Copper Hill = $5Billion
I'm not saying hey Copper Hill is worth Millions I'm just saying given the balance of the pros and cons I think you can just cross of Copper Hill as adding value to GCR, but do agree to really take the project seriously the funding via a JV or Offtake needs to be established.
p.s. There is also the EXPLORATION POTENTIAL at Copper Hill, I'd say they are looking to find higher grade satelite ore bodies etc
Refined Silver and others thanks for the kind words, I enjoy doing it so its a pleasure really,
I'm still waiting to hear back from my friend re GCR in Offtake discussions for Copper Hill, has anyone else out there heard anything? As I said if this can be confirmed it would be a serious turning point for the company and the project as securing "Offtakes" can sort out the project funding issue
As soon as I hear anything I'll let you guys
Well, finally some good news about Copper Hill.
GCR’s Managing Director, Kim Stanton-Cook, said today (ASX ann. inter-alia)
"The project has the capacity to deliver a steady stream of copper-in-concentrate for at least ten years at reasonable cost, so the big hurdle for GCR is the estimated capital cost. GCR will consider potential joint venturers requiring a steady supply of clean copper concentrate with gold credits and the financial capacity to fund the project through to start-up.”
Infact im going to be starting my own research website in the very very near future, focusing on very small caps (all totally independent of goldmans, just a bit of fun on the side, will be free, just really posting my own research I will be doing, but will present it in well put together reports), and Im thinking of initiating coverage of GCR and certainly will be using some of these ideas.
?
Ok before I go any further I think its very important that anyone hoping to understand exactly what GCR's Phosphate potential is read this report
http://www.goldencross.com.au/properties/mount-isa/PDF/Phosphate-20071224.pdf
also more info can be found on the companies web page
Projects
Mt Isa Phosphate, 20% Free Carried by Legend Corp, Qld near Mt Isa and near to Incitecs exisitng Phosphate mine
Qld Govt Historic JORC 500Mt's@15%Phosphate
Now this is a historic resource and the only reason it deosn't meet the JORC standard is because it was defined prior to the existance of the JORC code, ie any deposits no matter how ell defined that were established prior to the JORC code don't meet it, but really its just a technicality
See for yoursefl on the Qld Govt Minerals Database
http://www.vizmap.com/NRM/Commodities/493685.htm
http://www.vizmap.com/NRM/Commodities/491206.htm
http://www.vizmap.com/NRM/Commodities/494076.htm
http://www.vizmap.com/NRM/Commodities/494100.htm
GCR's JV partner is Legend International a major Phosphate player in Aust, for more info on Legend see http://www.lgdi.net/
Now Legend are working towards getting the whole project area towards production, they recently completed a scoping study and have an updated presentation which shows cost etimates, margins, production scenarios and resulting profit scenarios as well as timelines etc well worth a look http://www.lgdi.net/pdf/Legend_Phosp...ril_2008v2.pdf
Valuing Mt Isa
EV
Now the task of putting a value on Mt Isa, my prefered method of valuation is to use an Enterprise Value or EV which simply gives a company a value per tonne of given resource
Now because the Poo sector is light on companies the easiest and most obvious way to extract an EV is to determine the EV being attibuted to GCR's big brother Legend
Legend current shareprice = $3.10 with 200m shares fully dilluted its MKT CAP is now $620m US = $680m AUD
Legend has a NET 1.3Bt's@15% Phosphate (1.4Bt's but 100mt's is GCR's)
$680m With 1.3Bt's@15%Phosphate = 52c per tonne ore @15% Phosphate or $3 per tonne Phosphate
GCR has 20% of 500Mt's@15%Phosphate = Net 100Mt's
@ 52c/t = $52m 8.2c GCR
To keep an eye on Legends share price ann's and mkt cap see http://www.lgdi.net/inc/redirect_share_price.php but remember the Mkt Cap given doesn't take into account the 20m or so options and thus is 10% under what it should be
A % OF IGV
Another methood used (though I'm not sure how credible) is to use 10% of a deposits IGV as the value attributable to a company. I AM NOT A FAN OF THIS METHOD
Mt Isa PHOSPHATE:
500Mt's@0.15%P = 75Mt's of Phosphate
The current spot price for Phosphate is $350-$400 US/t = say $400 AUD roughly
So I.G.V. Mt Isa = 75Mt's x $400/t (current Phosphate Price) = $30BILLION now even though GCR 20% they have a net attributable amount of $6Billion
10% IGV = $600m = 95c
Conclusions Mt Isa
- Based on my prefered valuation the EV GCR is worth 8c+ on Mt Isa alone
-GCR is one of only 4 ASX listed companies with an actual Agricultural deposit
IPL's mkt cap is $8Billion
MAK's mkt cap is $275m
RWD's mkt cap is $130m
GCR's mkt cap is $25m
- GCR's deposits are between 60kms-150kms from IPL's operating Phosphate Mine
- GCR's project is part of a bigger project for big brother Legend kinda like the CUL/AQA relationship, the big brother has the deep funding pockes and expertise needed to advance these projects to production allowing GCR to advance its many other projects
Goldmandane - i accidentally got into this thread and astonished the amazing value you, YT, Refined Silver and others have put here.
Your candid note on Goldman sachs and its crappy business is startling too.
How do we know about your website and appreciate if you please advise in this forum when you open it.
Regards
Hey guys little bit hung over today but I have some very good news
On Friday GCR's big brother Legend has continued its very strong rally and on Friday closed at an all time high of $3.90
Valuing Mt Isa
EV
Legend current shareprice = $3.90 with 200m shares fully dilluted its MKT CAP is now $780m US = $860m AUD
Legend has a NET 1.3Bt's@15% Phosphate (1.4Bt's but 100mt's is GCR's)
$860m With 1.3Bt's@15%Phosphate = 66c per tonne ore @15% Phosphate
GCR has 20% of 500Mt's@15%Phosphate = Net 100Mt's
@ 66c/t = $66m 10.5c GCR
To keep an eye on Legends share price ann's and mkt cap see http://www.lgdi.net/inc/redirect_share_price.php but remember the Mkt Cap given doesn't take into account the 20m or so options and thus is 10% under what it should be
So GCR's Current Implied EV on Mt Isa alone is 10.5c how long can it stay at 4c?
later on I'm going to try and put everything together and come up with a reasonable price target based on everything
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?