Sean K
Moderator
- Joined
- 21 April 2006
- Posts
- 22,389
- Reactions
- 11,770
Alarm grows at China's influence in East Timor
Mark Dodd | April 16, 2008
IMPOVERISHED East Timor has signed a $28 million deal with China to buy two advanced patrol boats in a move that will alarm Australia and Indonesia about increasing Chinese influence in the struggling nation.
The deal was signed on April 12 by Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao, Secretary of State for Defence Julio Pinto and Hao Yantan from the Chinese defence company Poly-Technic.
China has been steadily increasing its presence in East Timor. It is involved in oil and gas exploration and was responsible for compiling a geological survey of the half-island state.
China has also recently built a massive Foreign Ministry office on Dili's waterfront.
One promising long-term project is the joint development with Australia of petroleum and natural gas resources in the waters southeast of Timor. The Portuguese colonial administration granted concessions to Oceanic Exploration Corporation to develop the deposits, however, this was curtailed by the Indonesian invasion in 1976. The resources were divided between Indonesia and Australia with the Timor Gap Treaty in 1989.[24] The treaty established guidelines for joint exploitation of seabed resources in the area of the "gap" left by then-Portuguese Timor in the maritime boundary agreed between the two countries in 1972.[25] Revenues from the "joint" area were to be divided 50%-50%. Woodside Petroleum and ConocoPhillips began development of some resources in the Timor Gap on behalf of the two governments in 1992.
East Timor inherited no permanent maritime boundaries when it attained independence, repudiating the Timor Gap Treaty as illegal. A provisional agreement (the Timor Sea Treaty, signed when East Timor became independent on 20 May 2002) defined a Joint Petroleum Development Area (JPDA), and awarded 90% of revenues from existing projects in that area to East Timor and 10% to Australia.[26] The first significant new development in the JPDA since Timorese independence is the largest petroleum resource in the Timor Sea, the Greater Sunrise gas field. Its exploitation was the subject of separate agreements in 2003 and 2005. Only 20% of the field lies within the JPDA and the rest in waters not subject to the treaty (though claimed by both countries). The initial, temporary agreement gave 82% of revenues to Australia and only 18% to East Timor.[27]
The Government of East Timor has sought to negotiate a definite boundary with Australia at the halfway line between the countries, in accordance with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. The Government of Australia preferred to establish the boundary at the end of the wide Australian continental shelf, as agreed with Indonesia in 1972 and 1991. Normally a dispute such as this could be referred to the International Court of Justice or the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea for an impartial decision,[28] but the Australian government had withdrawn itself from these international jurisdictions (solely on matters relating to maritime boundaries) shortly before Timorese independence.[29] Nevertheless, under public and diplomatic pressure, the Australian government offered instead a last-minute concession on Greater Sunrise gas field royalties alone.[30] On July 7, 2005, an agreement was signed under which both countries would set aside the dispute over the maritime boundary, and East Timor would receive 50% of the revenues (estimated at A$26 billion or about US$20 billion over the lifetime of the project[31]) from the Greater Sunrise development. Other developments within waters claimed by East Timor but outside the JPDA (Laminaria-Corallina and Buffalo) continue to be exploited unilaterally by Australia, however.[32]
I find it hypocritical that Australia supported the division of Indonesia and cashed in on their natural resources. (No I don't buy all the humanitarian intervention rubbish)
Now people are jumping up and down because instead of Woodside, it is a Chinese company there.
The Dutch and Portugese got it wrong. Completely. Like many colonial powers around the globe. Who divides an island that small between 2 countries? What the?
well I'm guessing the reason they're getting them from China is the same reason that Rio Tinto and FMG etc all get their wharves made in China these days , and floated down to the Pilbara ...... yet they're signing contracts for new patrol boats worth millions.
..
And, how do you support your neighbours who are providing all your security and half your GDP. You go and buy those new patrol boats from China. WTF
agentm,kennas, australia did support a number of things in the region - they supported the division of west papua into the hands of the indonesians..
indonesia had not real foothold there it was a landgrab.. the culture and the traditional owners there have had an awful history since, and that country sits almost as close as timor, so we really have two of our closest neighbours in the region in a real mess imho..
i support the independence of the timorese, as i support the plight of the west papua traditional owners. I dont think they had any say in the loss of their country to the colonialists, as i believe the timorese had little say in their own affairs in timor.
Against the grain: the East Timor intervention
Author: Cotton, J.1
Modern Asia has been shaped by intervention, but the principle of non-interference is an integral part of the 'Asian Way'. Countries of the region have doggedly opposed any suggestion that state sovereignty should be softened by a new doctrine of 'humanitarian intervention'. The participation of some of these countries in the 1999 intervention in East Timor - an action sanctioned by the United Nations for specifically humanitarian purposes - was thus out of character.
This departure was a consequence of specific historical and political factors, most importantly, the fact that the UN had never accepted Indonesia's incorporation of the territory as legitimate. Once the United States adopted a more critical attitude, after Australia pressured Indonesia to test local opinion on East Timor's future, the internationalisation of the issue became inevitable. There are certainly lessons in the East Timor case for coalition operations and other interventions in the region. But the actions of the Australian-led coalition do not indicate a wider regional acceptance of the norm of humanitarian intervention.
disarray, maybe you can enlighten me on why East Timor owes us their natural resources in return for our questionable intervention. What do these "peacekeepers" do and what is the underlying cause? (I admit I am not an expert just very skeptical)
What are all the good things we brought them? From the current state of the regions, does not look like much.
And continue to until they wipe out corruption, which I don't think they have any interest in doing.This country is going to be a basket case for years.
I wouldn't be at all surprised if Gusmao was involved.Timor's deputy PM Mario Carrascalao quits after row over corruption with Xanana Gusmao
From: AFP September 08, 2010 4:49PM
EAST Timor's Deputy Prime Minister Mario Carrascalao has resigned over corruption after a public row with Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao.
Mr Carrascalao told reporters he could not tolerate being publicly insulted for blowing the whistle on “rampant” corruption in the finance industry.
Mr Gusmao reportedly called Mr Carrascalao, 73, a “stupid liar” after the deputy accused the Prime Minister of involvement in an alleged $300 million corruption case in the finance ministry.
“After 73 years, for the first time in my life, somebody called me a 'stupid liar'. As a normal citizen, I responded by resigning as Deputy Prime Minister,” Mr Carrascalao told reporters after submitting his resignation to Mr Gusmao.
“The corruption, collusion and nepotism remain rampant and the corruptors are protected in a mutual way. Many have spoken about corruption eradication but only a few have good intentions and remain on the front line.”
And continue to until they wipe out corruption, which I don't think they have any interest in doing.
Anyone who peaks up will get the marching orders.
I wouldn't be at all surprised if Gusmao was involved.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?