Having read all 749 posts in this forum I found that the question posed at the beginning of the thread (Serious or Scam?) has still not been answered.
I therefore decided to investigate myself. Anybody can make claims one way or another. I therefore decided to disregard all claims made on this thread, including the claims made by Daniel Kertcher (and his paid posters on this thread) and went to the one truly believable source of information: The website of Daniel Kertcher's investment vehicle, Spectrum Live Capital Management Pty. Ltd.
To invest in the "Spectrum Live Portfolio Select managed investment scheme" one has to have attended one of Daniel's courses, because, in his own words: "An educated person makes a better investor." Be that as it may, the only thing that counts are results. And results is just what I found.
This "Scheme" started to operate in April 2013. Management fee was set at 3.3 % p.a. and investors would receive "Units" with an initial value of $1.00 each and the value of the units would change monthly based on the return the fund would achieve. Initially the value of the units would increase slowly month by month until November 2013 by which time the value of one unit had increased to $1.067 or a 6.7 % return for 7 months (11.5 % annualised).
However, November 2013 was the last time any results were available publicly and this fact alone made me very suspicous. All requests made to Spectrum Live Capital Management Pty. Ltd. for monthly results after November 2013 were met with a blank refusal. Apparantly only actual investors were entitled to the results.
So, I had a quick look around and it was not too difficult to find people who had actually invested with Spectrum Live and were prepared to talk about the results. And a totally different picture emerges. As at December 2014 the value of one unit has sunk to $0.99, a reduction of 1 % since April 2013. In addition, an investor would have been charged 2 annual management fees of 3.3 % each, resulting in a total loss of 7.6 % of his capital over 20 months
Spectrum Live Capital Management Pty. Ltd. list a total of 14 risks in the PDS. And they are: General, market, timing, political, liquidity, sector, concentration, portfolio investment, investment manager, fund of fund, counterparty, multi class, default class and scheme risk. So, here we have it: with so many risks attached, why would anyone want to invest?
As I said before, the only thing that matters are results. And the results are there for all to see.