.. well really I am new to all this and am a dummy when it comes to shareholding. .. so I apologise to all here for that and beg your kind forebearance.
There are some pretty clever posters here. HT, fred, toph, simonhhh...
If Mr Scott Funston said "all Avanco tenements are in good standing" I suppose it all depends on what he means by good standing. If he means that TN is still the property of AVB he can claim the defense of being technically correct insofar as it is still their property as far as THEY are concerned. However as far as dnpm are concerned it is no longer AVB's property and is open for applications, but nothing can be awarded possibly until the outcome of this appeal is settled. A counter-tactic.
So be shy of interpreting Mr. Funston's bland declaration as being all is Rosy. Interpreting. He did not actually say Trindade North is ours for a further X years, Exploration Report has been accepted, and there is no dispute about TN with dnpm.... I presume.
So it could potentially be what they call a half-truth. Potentially.
Now I have nothing against half-truths. It can be a useful tactic. Quite legal and clever. I indulge in a few myself occasionally with care. But the danger is when people try and interpret half-truths to mean what they would like them to mean.... if you get my drift. Also if bluster is added to a half-truth to try and give it further veracity through vehement indignation, rather than a measured, detailed rebuttal .... a clear thinker might be forgiven for smelling a rat....
If what HT posts is TRUE, and HT has not spent weeks faking it all up, then rather than personally attacking HT, then why not examine the implication of his research??? Verify his claims first of course... far more sensible I would have thought.
Anyway, looks to this dummy like you have a situation where AVB says "Its ours!" and DNPM say "No its not!" As pistol/sword duels are outlawed, I suppose it is off the the Appeal Court. Or have a tug of war.. winner take all.
If No 1 applicant is actually Vale then it is not the end of the world I suppose.
If No 1 applicant is Mrs Jones of Moone Ponds,Vic, and she gets it, well I suppose Vale will be knocking on her door with an Option Agreement too . How to be an instant millionaire in one easy lesson.
Who knows anything for sure ......
.. anyway I am a high-principled church-going person. I detect some unabashed personal accusations of hidden agendas, accusations of beatups, and caustic asides. That is intimidation... or to use a trendy term, bullying.
I would love to continue to pop in here to wonderful ASF for a visit or lurk now and then but if that is the tone of this forum.. that is, any opinion disagreement or a publishing of factual material is met with intimidation, then I am off to the pub. Respect for the viewpoint of others I was taught. Politeness. Pleeeeese.... Ok, off I go to confess my sins.... and let me tell you there are quite a few of them! and that is NOT a half-truth