This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

10,000 hours to success

Jump to new

bowman

Joined
29 June 2007
Posts
467
Reactions
0
A good read here about what it takes to become a competent trader:

http://www.tradersnarrative.com/the-definitive-guide-to-trading-mastery-success-2460.html

I should be logging my 10,000 hours this year, and until the recent crash, I had considered I was advancing beyond beginner status and getting to the point where I thought I knew a little about trading.

The crash was my first experience of trading a market that wasn't essentially a bull market and I took a pretty big hit - holding on to a lot of speccy rubbish.

The lesson has been learned and I'm back to feeling confident about my future prospects as a trader.
 
I first became aware of the 10 000 hours principle through a newsletter from Van Tharp and it clicked for me straight away. I mean the necessity to discover AND understand the multitude of trading possibilities. There is so much information out there and many many possible paths to take.

My trading stubborness has been my greatest obstacle ...

2 Ignore risk management
Always value conviction over discipline. Don’t worry when a trade goes against you, just put it aside and think of it as a long term investment. Or double down. It has to come back eventually.
Click to expand...

The market always goes up, right? Wrong.
 
The problem with this figure is that this is the amount suggest to become truly good. However, one never needs to be great to be profitable. Success is subjective, and I would describe a decently profitable trader (enough to afford a comfortable living) as a successful trader.

Skill is rarely developed at a linear rate, so it's likely that even if it does take 10,000+ hours to become great, one should be able to become a very good trader in a far shorter time, and a profitable trader in a far shorter time still.
 
That 10,000 is rubbish in that just doing the time will not get you there. Its 10,000 hours in deliberative practise. Not the 50,000 hours most punters spend on the market chopping and changing and never reflecting or reviewing.
 
Trembling Hand said:
That 10,000 is rubbish in that just doing the time will not get you there. Its 10,000 hours in deliberative practise. Not the 50,000 hours most punters spend on the market chopping and changing and never reflecting or reviewing.
Click to expand...

An excerpt from the article:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
So putting it plainly, to become a successful trader, you need to invest at least 10,000 hours of your time doing just that… trading. Of course, that means that you’ll also have to think about trading to come up with ideas, read about the current market, learn about market history to put the present in context, learn different ways of analyzing the market like technical analysis, tape reading, sentiment, etc. There’s a lot there but you need to put in those hours before you can expect success.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm curious as to who these people are that chop and change for 50,000 hours (30 years of trading) and how big their original inheritance was?

 
Average apprenticeship 3 yrs 6240 hrs
Average Degree 3 yrs 6240 hrs
Masters 8320 hrs
Doctorate 14560 hrs

Most race drivers start in carts at 7 and end up racing at 18 ish.
So say 11 yrs at 10 hrs a week 5720 hrs.
Most pro golfers would have spent 10,000 hrs + playing golf.

Most businesses fail in the first 3 yrs 6240 hrs.
Most traders in the same time frame.

10,000 hrs is a good "Average" for consistent understanding of a discipline I think.
Just as 95% of traders fail is a good "Average".
 
I think it is understood the figure is simply a general one. Trembling Hand has his tongue firmly planted within his cheeks. :
 
Guys this 10,000 hours thing is really misunderstood and misquoted.

Its comes from work in the 90s by mostly Dr. K. Anders Ericsson and some others.

Its not 10,000 "doing". Ericsson found that the difference between expert performers and the good performers was that the so call experts or the one recognised as be at the top of their field had engaged in deliberate practice of at least 10,000 hours.

Just doing does not make you an expert. To take techs example how many apprenticeship become true masters? Close to none but most have logged 10,000 by their 4 -5 year. They become competent but not top of their field.

The 10,000 hours thing is now quoted as 10,000 hours to success. this is exactly the opposite to what the studies, and there is a heap of them, was proving. Lots of people clock up 10,000 hours doing. Few become masters in their field.
 

True, i think its more your passion and interest in the field that will get you furthest... if you simply have no interest in it other than the fact of making money, even after 10,000 hours of trading you still wont be a great trader.
 
jono1887 said:
True, i think its more your passion and interest in the field that will get you furthest... if you simply have no interest in it other than the fact of making money, even after 10,000 hours of trading you still wont be a great trader.
Click to expand...

There is no way you could do 10 000 hours of anything you weren't interested in.
 
Trembling Hand said:
The 10,000 hours thing is now quoted as 10,000 hours to success. this is exactly the opposite to what the studies, and there is a heap of them, was proving. Lots of people clock up 10,000 hours doing. Few become masters in their field.
Click to expand...

Which is why I said one doesn't need to be great to be successful (unless one defines success as being great). I may not ever become a great trader, I may never become a good one, but I'm confident I will become decent enough to make a good living.
 
jersey10 said:
There is no way you could do 10 000 hours of anything you weren't interested in.
Click to expand...

Most people do it every day, every wk, every month, every year, at work.

Just saw your reply first TH, unsure about the parent part, hope it's not that bad!
 
Trembling Hand said:
Really? every been to school? ever had a job? ever been a parent?
Click to expand...

yes , yes , no.

was interested in school, was interested in my jobs, i assume i will like being a parent and as a result would like to have children.

point is, people don't choose and continue with activities that are optional as choosing to become a trader or an athlete or a guitarist that take a lot of practice are. School is required by law, job is required to live, parents who no longer want to be parents don't really have the option to make their children disappear.
 
Personally I'm happy with competency until I hop in a plane/have a complex medical problem/employ mid/high level management then I want Greatness.

Id want to be great if I were trading $1 million + but if less then competency FOR ME will be fine.
 
I've probably put in 160,000 and I'm still crap.
 
Trembling Hand said:
Really? every been to school? ever had a job? ever been a parent?
Click to expand...

Choices.

Do we have a choice in these? I don't think so. We have to goto school, whether we are interested in it or not. We have to have a job if we want to live properly, whether we are interested in jobs or not, and as far as a parent go, thats upto the stupid individual who decides to have a kid before they are ready.

Trading is a choice, therefore as it was said, it would be very hard to stack up 10,000 hours of something that you weren't interested in and had a passion for. No different than Golf or Knitting, no one in their right mind will sit down and commit themselves to 10,000 hours of either if they have no interest in them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Article
Resources for Systematic/Algorithmic Trading
Replies
12
Views
3K
Richard Dale
Success stories
Replies
8
Views
1K
basilio
T
Starting Personal Stock Trading Business Question
Replies
1
Views
729
frugal.rock
ETFs - when to 'cut your losses' and reinvest?
Replies
9
Views
2K
Joe Blow
Basic chart analysis/chart reading 101 for beginners
Replies
10
Views
4K
Gunnerguy
G
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more...