Australian (ASX) Stock Market Forum

China on the brink of Catastrophe?

Jump to new
Re: China on the brink of Catastrophe ?

SirRumpole said:
Not much. I'm happier here without all the financial jargon.
Click to expand...

So when CanOZ posted this:-

Shhhhh, don't say it too loud, they might hear you. Honestly, they have no idea. They're all so addicted to credit they really believe it will just go on forever...
Click to expand...

This was too much jargon? :confused:
 
Just another excuse for some hysteria from the ABC. Nothing we've not heard over the last several years.
 
i think it's the environmental degradation that will lead to their catastrophe. Quite possibly this decade they will have such extreme water shortages it will make life very difficult to sustain their. Between aquifers being depleted or polluted there's little drinkable water left, and not much for crops either.
 
US is outsourcing all its jobs to China, China may overtake US as worlds #1 superpower soon source: Brother Nathaniel on youtube.
 
As Julia said, seen it all before.

If, could, should, maybe, crystal balls, tea leaves, rabbit's feet are all irrelevant.

Trade/invest for today. Make money whilst you can. Exit when you feel comfortable, or uncomfortable for that matter.

The rest is white noise.

Did 4 Corners alert us all to the GFC a week before it happened?

Yawn....
 
springhill said:
According to Canstar, and other sources, you are 2 months out of the timeframe there.

The credit crunch was occurring before Sept 2007

http://www.canstar.com.au/home-loans/global-financial-crisis/

I guess when the ABC is your only form of information......
Click to expand...

What???? Have a look at the index charts. The market made a high after it started. After the two Bear Stearns hedge funds collapsed in July it was all over the media but the "market" was saying it will sort itself out. The Market ignored it til way after it was in the Media.


You are just trying to adjust your point of view now your throw away line looks silly.
 
Trembling Hand said:
What???? Have a look at the index charts. The market made a high after it started. After the two Bear Stearns hedge funds collapsed in July it was all over the media but the "market" was saying it will sort itself out. The Market ignored it til way after it was in the Media.


You are just trying to adjust your point of view now your throw away line looks silly.
Click to expand...

Nov 2nd it all started...............ah memories really nice if we could have another one.
.
 

Attachments

  • Chart.jpg
    Chart.jpg
    127.7 KB · Views: 12
Trembling Hand said:
What???? Have a look at the index charts. The market made a high after it started. After the two Bear Stearns hedge funds collapsed in July it was all over the media but the "market" was saying it will sort itself out. The Market ignored it til way after it was in the Media.


You are just trying to adjust your point of view now your throw away line looks silly.
Click to expand...

TH I've never cared for what you have to say or your continual petty points scoring, I'm not going to start now.

You have your position, I have mine. C'est la vie.

Back to the thread topic, if you had listened to all the China bears over the past 5 years, along with the rest of the rabbits scuttling to their warrens, you would have missed out on some lucrative opportunities. Continue to do so, if you wish.

China on the brink of collapse? YAWN

Sure it will probably happen one day, but other economies emerge, progress & develop.

Until then, trade/invest the current conditions.
 
IFocus said:
Nov 2nd it all started...............ah memories really nice if we could have another one.
.
Click to expand...

No, that is the date the market acknowledged it was happening. It was underway in other facets of the economy before that.
 
springhill said:
TH I've never cared for what you have to say or your continual petty points scoring, I'm not going to start now.

You have your position, I have mine. C'est la vie.
Click to expand...

:( He says as he tries to score some silly low blow..... strange. :cautious:

I'm not sure what your problem is but I was just trying to point out that these things are in the media before they fully take hold in the market. Ignoring them on the basis that it was covered by a program on the ABC is incorrect and perfectly illustrated by you first comment.

I was not trumpeting the collapse of the world as it doesn't seem like we are heading straight into GFC II. But dude you seem to have a hardon over something, lighten up. I'm a long way from "missed out on some lucrative opportunities" and it would be nice if you want to aggressively argue at least have the decency of not building a straw man to do so. If you want to be an ar$e do it with facts.
 
Trembling Hand said:
:( He says as he tries to score some silly low blow..... strange. :cautious:

I'm not sure what your problem is but I was just trying to point out that these things are in the media before they fully take hold in the market. Ignoring them on the basis that it was covered by a program on the ABC is incorrect and perfectly illustrated by you first comment.

I was not trumpeting the collapse of the world as it doesn't seem like we are heading straight into GFC II. But dude you seem to have a hardon over something, lighten up. I'm a long way from "missed out on some lucrative opportunities" and it would be nice if you want to aggressively argue at least have the decency of not building a straw man to do so. If you want to be an ar$e do it with facts.
Click to expand...

YAAAAAAAAWN!

Over and out!
 
Energy seems to be the real, hard, physical limit in China.

Coal - China mines 3.55 billion tonnes of coal each year, having reserves of around 115 billion tonnes.

No rocket science is required here to see that there is little scope to grow production and that they must be somewhere near the peak now.

It's not a case of this problem being 32 years away (ie 115 divided by 3.55), it's much sooner than that. It's not the case that you have all the mines (and China has a huge number of coal mines) going one day and they all run out of coal the next. Rather, it's a case of one mine runs out this year, another one next year and so on. They'll still be mining coal 100 years from now most likely, but the reserves are such that current production rates clearly can't be sustained for too long.

It's worth mentioning that China's coal consumption is more than 3 times the total exports of all coal exporting countries, and that China is already buying 17% of internationally traded coal. So ramping up imports isn't without some difficulties one would think.

I'm not saying that the lights are going out in China tomorrow, but the coal issue would seem to be a real impediment to continuing with the recent pattern of development. Eg they have more than tripled coal production since the year 2000 and pretty clearly a repeat of that isn't an option.
 
Trembling Hand said:
:( He says as he tries to score some silly low blow..... strange. :cautious:

I'm not sure what your problem is but I was just trying to point out that these things are in the media before they fully take hold in the market. Ignoring them on the basis that it was covered by a program on the ABC is incorrect and perfectly illustrated by you first comment.

I was not trumpeting the collapse of the world as it doesn't seem like we are heading straight into GFC II. But dude you seem to have a hardon over something, lighten up. I'm a long way from "missed out on some lucrative opportunities" and it would be nice if you want to aggressively argue at least have the decency of not building a straw man to do so. If you want to be an ar$e do it with facts.
Click to expand...

TH, can you expand on that? Is this because you think China keep stimulating/bailing out?
 
waterbottle said:
TH, can you expand on that? Is this because you think China keep stimulating/bailing out?
Click to expand...

Since 2009 the GFC has been in the forefront of everyone's mind. Many have been waiting for an exact replay because they stuffed up GFC 1. To add to it just about every bear cannot think about anything else other than it playing out the same again. They strangely focus on the US re-running it all over.

There will be another financial induced crisis. They come about pretty often. Yet they never play out the same. The result of GFC was the largest group of consumers taking a 10 count and not getting up for a long time. The US is slowly grinding back up but Japan and Euro land are stuck. Meanwhile China have a different problem, no consumers, dodgy investments, corruption, on and on, they probably will be the next catalysis. But that doesn't mean it will look like and have the same outcome as the GFC.

Get over the GFC its been run. Chances are the "next crisis" will be different in cause, magnitude, timeframe and result. That is a better bet than different circumstances (see china) producing the same outcome (US Euro based credit crisis).
 

Similar threads

R
Illusions of The Stock Market
2
Replies
26
Views
6K
RickyY
R
DB008
Rise of the Super Bugs
2
Replies
21
Views
6K
orr
O
S
Global economist David Hale on the economy, recession, and political assassination
Replies
1
Views
5K
lakemac
lakemac
bigdog
Next week is the 20th anniversary of the 1987 crash
Replies
4
Views
5K
noirua
noirua
R
The American use of War Pretext Incidents
Replies
6
Views
9K
sptrawler
sptrawler
Top